A big-hearted, boundary-vaulting novel that heralds a remarkable new talent: set in 1970s New York, a story outsized in its generosity, warmth, and ambition, its deep feeling for its characters, its exuberant imagination.
The individuals who live within this extraordinary first novel are: Regan and William Hamilton-Sweeney, estranged heirs to one of the city's largest fortunes; Keith and Mercer, the men who, for better or worse, love them; Charlie and Samantha, two suburban teenagers seduced by downtown's punk scene; an obsessive magazine reporter and his idealistic neighbor; and the detective trying to figure out what any of them have to do with a shooting in Central Park. Their entangled relationships open up the loneliest-seeming corners of the crowded city. And when the infamous blackout of July 13, 1977, plunges this world into darkness, each of these lives will be changed forever. A novel about love and betrayal and forgiveness, about art and truth and rock 'n' roll, about how the people closest to us are sometimes the hardest to reach - about what it means to be human.
Read by Rebecca Lowman with Macleod Andrews, Alex McKenna, Paul Michael, Tristan Morris, and Bronson Pinchot.
©2015 Garth Risk Hallberg (P)2015 Random House Audio
"City on Fire is a big, stunning first novel and an amazing virtual reality machine, whisking us back to New York City in the 1970s with bravura swagger and style and heart . . . The ghosts of New York memorialized by earlier writers—F. Scott Fitzgerald, J. D. Salinger, Richard Price—hover over City on Fire…[In] Hallberg's XXL tool kit as a storyteller: a love of language and the handsprings he can make it perform; a bone-deep knowledge of his characters' inner lives that's as unerring as that of the young Salinger; an instinctive gift for spinning suspense. He also possesses a journalistic eye for those telling details that can trigger memories of the reader's own like small Proustian grenades…A novel of head-snapping ambition and heart-stopping power—a novel that attests to its young author's boundless and unflagging talents." (New York Times)
"A remarkably assured, multivalent tale...an epic panorama of musicians, writers, and power brokers and the surprising ways they connect...The story never feels overwritten, and the plotlines interlace without feeling pat...At times the novel feels like a metafictional tribute to America's finest doorstop manufacturers, circa 1970 to the present: Price (street-wise cops), Wolfe (top-tier wealth), Franzen (busted families), Wallace (the seductions of drugs and pop culture), and DeLillo (the unseen forces behind everything). That's not to say Hallberg has written a pastiche.... As his various plotlines braid tighter during the July 1977 blackout, his novel becomes an ambitious showpiece for just how much the novel can contain without busting apart. The very-damn-good American novel." (Kirkus Reviews)
"Dazzling…City on Fire is an extraordinary performance…Hallberg inhabits the minds of whites and blacks, men and women, old and young, gay and straight with equal fidelity…making every one of them thrum with real life…And what endlessly fascinating characters they are!...[The novel's] Whitmanesque arms embrace an entire city of lovers and strivers, saints and killers." (Washington Post)
Unless you're a fan of vocal fry and alternation between surfer accent or cliche NY cop accent to differentiate various male voices of all age ranges, Rebecca Lowman's narration leaves much to be desired.
The story is a good one though.
Yes. in time. The two negatives I mention below would not keep me away.
1. I didn't enjoy the "interludes," at all. I thought they were boring and they felt self-indulgent to me.
2. Toward the end, the author jumped 20 years forward in time, at random, while the action is going on. Personally, I was invested in the period of the novel, not future small details.
I would recommend it to all of my New Yorker friends, young and old. The author allows glimpses into several different worlds of NYC, and a time in history that was crazy, gritty, a hellhole of squalor; and unlike most of NYC today.
Rebecca Lowman's narration gets on my nerves and was the weakest point of this Audible book. I will avoid her narrations.
William, of course. He was the star. He was a star.
I can already see the movie in my head
One master-passion in the br east, like Aaron's serpent, swallows all the rest. A. Pope
A brilliant, incendiary book set in the brazier that was New York City in 1977, like a "Municipality Infernality," an "Immolation Station."
Don't be deterred by the novel's length. If you can attain and enjoy total immersion in a place and time through the very real connections given the human mind by the magic of reading great literature, you should buy this book.
I see the similarity between "City on Fire" and a Dickens novel like "Bleak House," in that both interweave connected story lines toward solving a mystery, here a college freshman co-ed from Long Island, involved in the punk rock scene, is shot on New Year's Eve, 1976, in the Park outside a soiree' being held by a wealthy family, the Hamilton-Sweeneys. The novel culminates in the NYC blackout of mid-July 1977.
The novel's primary cast is populated by mid-the H-S patriarch's mid-30s daughter, Regan, and her husband Keith Lamplighter (Hallberg has a talent like Dickens for character names); Regan's late 20s brother, William Hamilton-Sweeney, and his boyfriend Mercer Goodman, an African-American teacher from rural Georgia; a talented, alcoholic, investigative reporter and his neighbor; the co-ed and her close friend (boyfriend?) the fiery (red-head) Charlie a/k/a The Prophet; the detective trying to solve the shooting; a serpentine uncle referred to as the "Demon Brother," and a saurian punkcubus named Nicky Chaos. Minor characters include a pill-popping, conservative radio talk jock stirring up the masses, and a punk rock band soundman named, also in Dickensian fashion, Solomon Grungy. If I have a criticism of the book, it was the short diversions to the talk radio host and the protest march he whipped up; yet, I can see where these are important to his painting a NYC aboil, making my gripe akin to a complaint there's too much timpani in a symphony.
The criticism that the novel has too many characters to follow is misplaced because of how and when each is introduced (seamlessly). And, as you'd expect from the title, New York City takes on its own calescent, then blazing, character. In CITY ON FIRE, Mr. Hallberg also shows quite a risible flare, unlike another recent, acclaimed novel set in NYC, "A Little Life" (in which I don't recall one moment of levity).
After a torrid pace on the last night of the blackout, Hallberg ties then furls the story lines together nicely, like the end of a stunning symphony.
The narration was great for all but an hour. But, oh was that hour BAD. Around mid-book, like a bag full of week-old shrimp hulls thrown into a quaint Italian restaurant, comes the most annoying narrator I've heard in hundreds of audiobooks, with the worst case of "vocal fry" I've ever heard [google "vocal fry," if you don't know]. I would understand using this speech pattern if it had been used by teenagers of the late 1970s, but it was NOT. While I don't like giving a combo of narrators a bad rating because of only one, I'd be less than honest if I didn't share with potential readers how severely disconcerting it was to have that grenade dropped into this audiobook.
Wanted to really like this book: my time and my place - 70's in NYC. But it was just much too long and digressive. Narration was excellent but it's a long slog for the listener. Disappointing.
Editor please! I honestly cannot believe at 900 pages and 38 hours of audible listening there is not one single character I cared about. BTW the group setting of the main characters in Pulaski's office? preposterous! hear that sound? that is the phone ringing from the publisher that wants it's 2 million dollar advance back!
Even tho very long, with so many characters, and many jumps in time, I couldn't put it down. Well written with well drawn, diverse characters.
City On Fire is the best book of the year, the decade - among the top ten in a sixty-five year reading addiction. All analysis, all praise is trite in the shade if this beautiful, insightful writing.
the overall book got a little mystical at times especially towards the end. But the performance made it easier to follow all the various characters. the use of all the main narrators voices was really quite amazing. I don't think I would have gotten through just reading this book
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.