Copyright ©1993 Philip Roth; Copyright (P)1993 Dove Audio, Inc.
"One of Roth's grand inventions.... [He is] a comic genius...a living master." (Harold Bloom, The New York Review of Books)
"The uncontested master of comic irony." (Time)
"A brilliant novel of ideas...Roth has gone farther into his own genius than he ever has before." (The Nation)
"... there are times when silence is a poem." - John Fowles, the Magus ^(;,;)^
This is where the late great Roth run began. Operation Shylock started what might just be the greatest series of amazing books by one author I can think of:
Operation Shylock: A Confession (1993)
Sabbath's Theater (1995)
American Pastoral (1997)
I Married a Communist (1998)
The Human Stain (2000)
So, like I tend to do with great writers, I back into their early greats. I read backwards, crosswise, and reverse into the first.
So, 2014 (21 years after it was first published), I find myself reading and loving Operation Shylock. I am amazed by Roth's ability to bend an idea back and forth without having it break. He is able to flex and bend (sinister?) an idea until every detail has been bled out. The ink of the effort is all on the page. He is able to construct a book filled with doppelgängers, liars, Jews and Palestinian rock throwers and professors and wreck havoc on any simplicity of plot. Every mirror in Roth's novel reverses the part in your hair and eventually shows you that your belief about who you are and what you believe is constructed out of fiction. There is no fact only deception and transgression.
This novel isn't built from one narrative. It is built out of several narratives. The narrative of Roth writing about a Roth (a fictionalized version of Roth) being stalked by a Roth (Moshe Pipkin). Everyone is gaming everyone. Interjected into the narrative are several true narratives (Aharon Apelfeld, Leon Klinghoffer, John Demjanjuk (who may be also be Ivan the Terrible Demjanjuk). These "true" narratives serve to also deepen the idea of a fluid identity, our mutual responsibility, our ultimate nature to lie, to deceive, to hustle. Then there is the other true narrative. The narrative of the Jew, the Goy, Israel, and the Diaspora. Roth is somehow able to weave this all together in a way that fits and works. Roth is able to reflect on his place within the Jewish community and as a writer in a way that he couldn't without being confronted with a transgressive doppelgänger. Anyway, I'm still trying to get my brain and my stomach comfortably around the whole of it. Perhaps, I'll write more tomorrow about the missing Chapter 11, or perhaps I'll just say screw it and return to my own goy problems.
I loved this book! I listened to Operation Shylock while commuting to work--I shivered at its brilliance, gasped aloud each time I reached my destination and had to turn it off. As one whose profession it is to sort through the psychological complexities of mental illness, neurosis, psychosis, shifting perceptions and altered realities, I found the minds of the twin Philip Roths (real or imagined?) as fascinating as any patient I've ever had the opportunity to accompany through the dark abyss of self-doubt, creativity, confusion, and triumph. It takes one down thrilling internal twists and turns of the American Jewish psyche, back alleys of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, and the Nazi war trials. This is one of those rare books I will listen to again.
After listening to American Pastoral with great pleasure, I embarked upon Operation Shylock, which presents the political situation in Israel of the 1980's. Current (2004) events in Israel show a country frozen in time for decades, and contributed to my sense that this book may be Roth's attempt to voice independent perspectives on the situation in the Middle East. As such, I found it not so much a work of fiction as a political discourse. And that is why I rate it low--I expected something quite different. But in continuing to listen, I continually questioned if he was not, at the time of writing it, still suffering from drug-induced paranoia in reality.
Each perspective is one which I certainly have considered as I contemplate the morass that is the political situation there. Perhaps each character, however, is a Halcyon-derived fragment of Roth himself, torn between loyalty to and criticism of the Israeli leadership and settlers. If so, one reads the premise of his book as his alter-ego searching for the best way to preserve the lives of Israeli Jews who seem once again to be facing annihilation, partly due to their own aggressive policies.
Diasporism, as Roth envisions it, though surely not as welcomed by Europe as the faux-Roth hopes, certainly seems to be a better alternative than the "identification with the (Nazi) aggressor" they appear to be demonstrating toward the Palestinians at present. Curiously, an article in the New Yorker just this week (May 31, 2004 issue, "Among the Settlers"), asks, "Will they destroy Israel?"
Philip Roth's double, also named Philip Roth, is traveling the world touting diasporism -- the ideology that Ashkenazic Jews should escape an inevitable holocaust in Israel and return to Europe where he is conviced they will be welcomed. As he pursues and then encounters his alter ego, Roth the writer becomes or pretends to become Roth the diasporist. As with everything Roth writes, this book is skillful, witty, and elegantly written, but I found it tiring, as each character--Jewish, Palestinian, Zionist, or Diasporist--seems to embody an idee fixe and ranted on about his obsession.
This is my second audiobook by Roth, first was American Pastoral, and found it very enjoyable--full of his dark humor--"there's no business like Shoah business" ect... and as another reviewer mentioned it has enough pyschologizing to be meditated over for weeks. I'd recommend listening to American Pastoral first but this is a good listen and Fritz Weaver has done an excellent reading!
I made what I believe to be the "mistake" of making this my first Philip Roth experience. I don't get the impression that this is typical of his work. I found it interesting and somewhat enjoyable, but I felt throughout as though I was missing things that may have been relating to previous works (almost like "in" jokes I didn't understand). Part of this may be that I am not of Jewish heritage and thus cannot relate specifically to the whole Israeli gestalt. Nevertheless, I am not sorry for having listened to Operation Shylock. It held my attention and certainly employed many interesting techniques for telling a story. I will check in with friends and see what they think should be my next Roth listen.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.