It could be said that Leon Panetta has had two of the most consequential careers of any American public servant in the past 50 years. His first career, beginning as an army intelligence officer and including a distinguished run as one of Congress' most powerful and respected members, lasted 35 years and culminated in his transformational role as Clinton's budget czar and White House chief of staff. He then "retired" to establish the Panetta Institute with his wife of 50 years, Sylvia; to serve on the Iraq Study Group; and to protect his beloved California coastline. But in 2009, he accepted what many said was a thankless task: returning to public office as the director of the CIA, taking it from a state of turmoil after the Bush-era torture debates and moving it back to the vital center of America's war against Al Qaeda, including the campaign that led to the killing of Osama bin Laden. And then, in the wake of bin Laden's death, Panetta became the U.S. secretary of defense, inheriting two troubled wars in a time of austerity and painful choices.
Like his career, Worthy Fights is a reflection of Panetta's values. It is imbued with the frank, grounded, and often quite funny spirit of a man who never lost touch with where he came from: his family's walnut farm in beautiful Carmel Valley, California. It is also a testament to a lost kind of political leadership, which favors progress and duty to country over partisanship. Panetta is a Democrat who pushed for balanced budgets while also expanding care for the elderly and sick; a devout Catholic who opposes the death penalty but had to weigh every drone strike from 2009 through 2011. Throughout his career, Panetta's polestar has been his belief that a public servant's real choice is between leadership or crisis. Troubles always come about through no fault of one's own, but most can be prevented with courage and foresight.
©2014 Leon Panetta and Jim Newton (P)2014 Penguin Audio
I am an avid eclectic reader.
Panetta memoir is the third cabinet member’s memoir and Obama is still in office. The memoir is a sub category of the autobiography. When I read a memoir I expect a narrow focus and want to feel I am looking at the situations as if I was that person. I am reading to get a better understanding of the events for a historical perspective. Panetta’s book gives a brief review of his earlier life so we can understand how he got to the point in the book that he is focusing on. He successfully puts me into the life of the director of CIA and Secretary of Defense. I felt as if I was in the meetings with him, understanding what he knew and thought and reactions to people and events as he covers his time as director of the CIA and Secretary of Defense. More than half of the book covers Panetta’s time as director of the CIA and his time as Secretary of Defense.
Panetta’s book is well-written with frank descriptions of personalities and events. Panetta had been in government service for a long time and was the Congressman for the Monterey Bay area for many years. I enjoyed the story of his parents and grandparents immigration from Italy to the Monterey Bay area and Leon’s stories of childhood in Monterey. Panetta’s personality and his honesty came through in the book. The author covers in-depth the jobs he had in government including his being fired by Nixon when Panetta worked at Dept. of HEW enforcing the new laws about school segregation. I remember when the law was passed to create the Monterey Bay Marine Sanctuary to protect our beautiful coast (I live here). Therefore I found Panetta’s discussion about how he went about trying to protect the coast from off shore drilling and all the methods he tried and failed at until coming up on the creation of a marine sanctuary very interesting. Panetta tells of his time in the Clinton White House as first budget director and later chief of staff. He is frank about the problems he had trying to bring order and discipline to the White House when Clinton had no self discipline. He describes Clinton as brilliant but disorganized. He resigned in 1997 and thought his career was over.
Panetta created the Panetta Institute that is on the campus of the Monterey Bay State University. He was running this until 2009 when Obama asked him to be director of the CIA. Panetta is a master of the budget and the CIA was in dire need of his services and organization skills. Panetta discusses his problems with Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and retired Admiral Dennis Blair who was Director of National Intelligence. He also tells the fascinating story of finding Osama bin Laden and sending in the seal team.
Panetta’s disagreements with the Obama White House when he was director of CIA and Secretary of Defense is well documented in his testimony before Congress therefore his frank to almost blistering comments in this book should not be surprising. Panetta opposed the prisoner exchange for Bowe Bergdahl. He disagreed with the removal of all troops from Iraq. He agreed with Hillary Clinton and David Petreius about intervening in Syria. Most of all he said Obama’s failure to act when Syria crossed the red line Obama laid down about the use of chemical weapons on the Syrian people destroyed American credibility. The author provides us with his opinion about Obama’s ability as a president and he is careful to provide both positive and negative points of his abilities. Most of all Panetta minced no words about the dysfunction of Congress. He says there will be lots of problems coming up to blame on Congress because of their failure to agree on a budget and forcing the 10% across the board cuts that is going to destroy the ability of the military to do their job. Panetta had no good words for our dysfunctional Congress. I feel this memoir has provided an inside look into the workings of the CIA, department of defense and the white house.
Panetta is plain spoken and impassioned in the book. I found it to be most informative and easy to read. Leon Panetta narrated his own book.
Goes well beyond the narrowly focused media coverage and provides a look at the kind of thoughtful, centered person one hopes to find in public service, as well as a sense of the context behind the actions in several Administrations.
This book, read by Secretary Leon Paneta addresses the major issues of the Clinton and Obama administrations as well as his experiences as a Congressman. I really enjoyed this book which was doubly interesting being read by the author.
His expressiveness and tension served as clues to identify those issues that he felt strongly about.
Time well spent? Not so much. I expected a lot from Leon Panetta but what I got was a boring recitation of facts in a slow monotonous voice. Perhaps if I had read the book instead of listening to it, I might have given it a higher rating. Couldn't take his voice any longer halfway through the book.
A more balanced view instead of a partisan political view
Insight about the functioning of CIA and the Pentagon
Let me start by thanking Leon Panetta for his service to this great country. I have been a member of Audible for well over a decade and this is the first review I have written. I have always respected Leon Panetta for his level headed view of things but this book is not one of his greatest moments. Instead of speaking out as an American, he spoke as a Democrat. Ask not what you can do for your country, ask what you can do for your party. He bickers about partisanship at the same time he pens a book that is partisan. I would have expected someone of Leon's stature to at least touch upon the exploding budget deficit but that is left untouched. This book is about defending Obama more than telling people about the risks to the greatness of America going forward. If you are a hard core Democrat who is interesting in defending Obama's record, this is a really good feel good book. If you are a rational middle of the road person, save yourself time and money, this book is all about blaming Republicans and praising Obama. To borrow a line from SNL, "Democrats and Obama, good. Republicans, bad". I am truly saddened.
Mr. Panetta is a great American whose contributions in Congress and the executive branch were profound. Mr. Panetta is NOT, however, a great narrator, and this contribution to this book was to drag it down into sheer boredom. This is not an action story to begin with so a little drama in the performance might have held my interest. It was as if Mr. Panetta was testifying before Congress rather than trying to entertain and inform his readers.
mr. Panetta tells a compelling story of American leadership dating back to the immigrants who were his parents and came from Italy. Our country needs more people like mr. Panetta. he's truly a man of service unselfish and a man of this country
Basically a 17 hour long love letter to president Obama and the Clinton family with a few interesting moments discussing his time as CIA director. I don't consider myself right or left wing but this book really annoyed me. Every chance he got Mr. Panetta would mention how great the Clintons are and how amazing Barrack Obama's policies are. He would then bash George Bush and Ronald Reagan. It was more of a left wing propaganda novel than it was a memoir.
I stuck through the whole thing and I regret that I did. Waste of money.
Really enjoyed this book. Found it so interesting about decision making and one man's life long dedication to public service. To hear it in Mr. Penetta's voice allowed his personal warmth and character to shine. I wonder why he didn't pursue higher office. I would have supported him.
It is very sad that such a great personality, statesman, a person who influenced many lives of individuals and nations with such great experiences (congress, lawyer, cabinet member and chief of staff for many presidents, CIA and Defense secretary, father of 3 sons,, etc.) wrote a book containing very little personal information, very few opinions, and event descriptions sanitized to the degree of absurdity (for example, I read from newspapers and heard on PRI more data about Asama Bin Laden identification than Mr. Panetta describes in his book). Literary, people were never hired, they gracefully accept the position of power, and they were never fired, they insisted on their resignations, or in advanced agreed to stay in power for just that much, etc. All decisions are good, and republicans lead poor people to poverty, but after Mr. Panetta changed party affiliation... and so it goes.
However, the book is large and covers a very long period of time, so if complimented with other books of that era, it maybe an interesting read.
I gave 2 stars for performance only because I always appreciate when author wants to bring to his listeners his own voice. But I had to listen it with 1.5 speed -- thanks to Audible technical engineers, that was possible; otherwise it would be very difficult to listen.
Report Inappropriate Content