Beginning with his installation as director of Central Intelligence in 1997, Tenet unfolds the momentous events that led up to 9/11: his declaration of war on Al Qa'ida, his worldwide operational plan to fight terror, his warnings to White House officials, and the plan for a response laid down just six days after the attack. Tenet also reveals the CIA's efforts since 9/11 to hunt down the fugitive members of Al Qa'ida's leadership.
In his gripping narrative of the run-up to the war in Iraq, Tenet provides fresh insights and background, including a privileged account of how the famous "sixteen words" made it into the president's State of the Union speech, the real context of his own now-famous "slam-dunk" comment, and the CIA's views of the rise of an Iraqi insurgency. Finally, as the country digs in for a prolonged war, he gives his thoughts on how we can forge a more secure world.
©2007 George Tenet; (P)2007 HarperCollins Publishers
I write my reviews under my wife Karen's account. Retired USN Russian linguist/analyst; actor; director; producer. Biography & History focus
I am the first to take anything said by a politician or political appointee with a huge grain of salt. So I have done so with George Tenet. That being said, I have to admit that this memoir which covers Al Quaeda, 9/11, and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq is believable, complete and, surprisingly, not self-serving. Well written with eyes of objectivity amazingly wide open, Mr. Tenet admits his and his organization's (CIA) victories and defeats, triumphs and mistakes. This memoir is nicely narrated, well paced and well produced. This book will sit well with Republicans, Democrats and Independents. No Bush bashing here, Mr. Tenet focuses on the facts. He is obviously not a fan of Cheney or Rumsfeld but he does not allow his personal issues to cloud his past. The story here is obviously from his point of view, how HE remembers things, but he does provide documentation and explanation. This book is NOT for those looking for a castigation of Bush and his administration. This is Mr. Tenet's attempt at a historical recreation of his tenure as DCI 1996 - 2004. I rarely give a book 5 stars (check and see - maybe 3 times over the last 10 years/500 books) but I give this recommendation without qualification or hesitation.
BA English MA Political Science Political Independent Intellectually curious Critical reader
I looked at this book for a few months before picking it up. I am glad I did. I follow politics pretty closely and was fairly unimpressed with what I saw coming from Tenet and the CIA, but he puts up a pretty good defense of himself in this book while doing something few big names like to do...admit they made a mistake or did something wrong. This book gives great insight and has shifted some of my opinions of the government, though my views on the political administration is still firmly affixed. If you want a political diatribe this book will leave you jilted. If you want a pretty fair assessment this is a good start.
I was thoroughly interested in hearing the perspective of this participant in the goings-on before and after 9/11. It's sometimes difficult to find one's own opinion amidst the sound-bites, slants, takes, and, imo, downright lies. Mr. Tenet, as well, has his "slant"; but it's an honest one and can be deciphered without the difficulty of much confusion and muddle. Thank you, Mr. Tenet!
I must admit that I've gone from being disdainful of George Tenet, to being an admirer. This wasn't the book that changed my opinion -that was "The One Percent Doctrine", Ron Suskind - but this book confirms my feelings.
There are no new startling revelations in this book, but it is probably the best insider view we will ever get during a critical time in world history.
Why only 4 stars? The narration and writing style quite match. Making the book slow going at times, and at other times making the authors quips fall very flat
George Tenet was at the center of the storm for seven years. He explains how an executive order did not allow U.S. forces to kill OBL before 9/11, how the CIA knew a major terrorist act was coming soon, but did not know where, and how quickly U.S. intelligence agencies used information gained in the 9/11 attacks to stop further attacks. His most strident comments, though, are reserved for the Bush sycophants working under Cheney and Rumsfeld who began planning the invasion of Iraq and Iran even before taking office, the mindless conduct of the war and the stupid policy decisions implemented afterwards. It's pretty clear he disagrees with the decision to invade Iraq to some degree and disagrees with how the "peace" is conducted to a greater degree.
The book is long and is well narrated by a professional speaker. It is, however, a difficult read because it covers seven years of history and politics. Plan to read it over a considerable period of time.
As Mr Tenet was a major player during 9/11 and the Iraq invasion, and yet not one of the principals you normally get to hear in the media, I was interested in hearing his side of the story.
The book appears well written and holds interest. As an audio performance, it holds interest throughout and flows well. Some of the edits are a bit sloppy as you can hear the reader's voice change in timbre as re-reads have been inserted. But this is not objectionable.
By far the most interesting part of the book is the afterward, spoken by Mr Tenet himself. Here, he ponders on the future, using his past experience as a guide and, at least for me, hits every nail on the head. The things he says in print are things that I have been verbalizing to acquaintances for years.
This is not to mean that I blindly agree with Mr Tenet:
1) No matter what he says in the book, 9/11 was missed under his tenure. He may have seen the dots, but without being able to put them together, he lost the game. And that's what it's all about: winning the game.
2) He also (admittedly) got it wrong regarding WMAs in Iraq, which, although it was not the Bush Administration's sole reason for invading Iraq (the others being even more ridiculous), was the reason being fed to the public to justify invasion.
In both cases, he bears responsibility, at least in part, for the deaths of many people, which he really has yet to admit to.
After reading Tim Weiner's excellent "Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA", I was eager to hear the CIA story from an insider's perspective. Unfortunately, Mr. Tenet spends most of the book defending CIA employees' dedication, commitment and patriotism instead of giving close examination to their oft-repeated failure to identify threats to this nation and its people. The CIA's reduction in budget and manpower in the years following the collapse of the Soviet Union was more related to a realization by the nation's leaders that even with huge multi-billion dollar appropriations, it was ineffective and hide-bound. It's not at all clear that even with better funding, CIA would have predicted any better than it did the rise of Islamic terrorism and the 9/11 attack. the Agency was, after all, a huge and secret bureaucracy more interested in protecting its own personnel and in its own survival, than in fulfilling its mission. We can only hope that this is not still so.
Geopolitics, history, and philosophy junkie. I love smoothly flowing prose that moves me effortlessly from one idea to the next.
I love to read memoirs of those who played leading roles in history.
Well spoken, clear and interesting.
General Pervez Musharraf's coming to Jesus moment when Tenet said, " We stole these nuclear weapon blueprints from AQ Khan, and he stole them from you." WOW, that was gold!
It's a perspective that really needed to be told. Mr. Tenet demonstrates clearly what he was faced with and gave some incredible insight that only he could know. However, some aspects were designed with a formal defense in mind...I can't blame him. He took a lot of heat.
In the beginning of the book he mentioned that he would talk openly and fairly about his successes and failures. By the end of the book I was still looking for the "failure" he mention, I was expecting an act of contrition...a coming to Jesus moment about his part in the problem of WMD intelligence. There was none of it. Somehow I feel cheated but I did find the book interesting, well organized, and quickly paced.
Read it, it's a SLAM DUNK!
Avid general reader with a fondness for British and Irish Writers and world history.
George Tenant has written a valuable book. The trials and tribulations of CIA administrators and line officers is well illustrated along with the mistrust, competition and difficulties that plague the intellligence communities and which put the country at risk.
This is not a general 'spy' tale, athough there are some anecdotal references. Tenant's long tenure and the 'lofty' position gives authority to this book.
Recommended reading (and not in the least bit boring)
Arthur Morey is usually a very good narrator, but in this book, he did something that made listening to him painful. He tried out 4 or 5 pronounciations of Al Qaeda, sometimes in three consecutive sentences. He finally settled on the most annoying pronounciation, AL-KAY-EEDA, which, because it was used so often, was extremely distracting.
The pace never stopped. Things about recent history I never knew .... and neither did the media at the time.
He's a far better narrator than George Tenet the author! Had the right timbre - I thought he was George Tenet!
Iraq......you're a pain in the backside.
This is a reference work for future academics.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.