The Scottish-born son of a failed weaver and a mother who supported the family by binding shoes, Andrew Carnegie was the embodiment of the American dream. In his rise from a job as a bobbin boy in a cotton factory to being the richest man in the world, he was single-minded, relentless, and a major player in some of the most violent and notorious labor strikes of the time. The prototype of today's billionaire, he was a visionary in the way he earned his money and in the way he gave it away.
Nasaw explains how Carnegie made his fortune and how he tried to pull the world back from a war he predicted. Brimming with new material, personal letters, diaries, prenuptial agreements, letters to and from presidents and prime ministers, Nasaw plumbs the core of this fascinating man, fixing him in his place as one of the most compelling, elusive, and multifaceted personalities of the 20th century.
©2006 David Nasaw; (P)2007 Gildan Media Corp
"This is biography on the grand scale." (Washington Post Book World)
Grover Gardner has a very natural story-telling voice which draws you in and keeps you wanting more.
This book has made Carnegie seem more human in many ways for I have always had an almost a God-like perception of him after reading the Gospel of Wealth essay.
This book also made me want to visit Scotland!
This was a decent read but my God was it long! I feel like the book could easily have been cut in half and would have told a story equal in history, dialog, and content. This one just seemed to drag on and on, and on.
The book talks about the childhood and young adulthood of Mr. Carnegie, but cuts right to the chase. He makes himself a millionaire in the first 1/10 of the book and the rest id spent discussing his philanthropies, which though interesting, becomes dry at times.
I’m more interested in how he made his money and since he did it so young, there really isn’t much to tell in that regard. And since he saved darn near every correspondence throughout his life the book subject the reader to often dull and un-interesting introspects of his life. Even his love life seemed dull.
I don’t regret the time I spent listening to the dialog, as there are many interesting facts that kept me tuned in. I was just hoping for a biography that placed more focus on how he made his millions versus how he spent it.
Less about his business, more about his charity and politics. Overall still a good read about AC's life. Amazing how much he can and has accomplished by writing letters.
Capture a lot of the dynamic personality of Carnegie while not ignoring his foibles. As with most biographical works, it possessed its own bias, but it was milder than most. It captured the complex nature of the man and the inherent dichotomy of a philanthropic robber baron.
Mike @ CustomChess.com
The writing in this book was great. The author presents all the information in a logical, linear way that is easy to follow, and does a great job of capturing the essence of Andrew Carnegie. Grover Gardner does a fantastic job of reading capturing the inflection of the author as well. The peoblem is that Andrew Carnegie was not really all that intersting. He was involved in some inovating and exciting things early in his life which led him to accumulate a fair amount of money. From his early 30's on, however, he basically just functioned as a source of capital, while relying on the brains and hard work of others to do the bulk of the work in building his fortune. Meanwhile he flitted around the world traveling and fishing and what not. Then, he spent the latter part of his life trying to influence others to accomplish great things... again, trying to rely on them to actually do the work. Even his philanthropy work was, for the most part, delegated to others. Then, he relied on the hard work of his trustees to do good works with the funds. Carnegie was a smart man who knew how to surround himself with talented, hard working people who could achieve great things for him. In the end, however, he personally didn't significantly contribute much or accomplish much on his own. The exception to that perhaps being his philosophy of philanthropy. There are more intersting people to read about from the same period, such as Rockefeller or the Morgans.
First, let me state that this is a book "best served abridged"! After sloshing through the first 2 parts, I gave up and discovered everything about this man in Wikipedia. Andrew Carnegie was part of history but not a very interesting one. He got stuck on one theme and just stayed there, refusing or unable to really grasp the world around him. He didn't marry or really date until his mother died when he was 50. He hated his father for being weak. Carnegie reminded me of a highly functional idiot savant whose "savant" was knowing how to make something out of nothing. I'm not mad at him for that. What is disturbing is that this man was a vocal abolitionist who hated slavery. Yet he basically enslaved his own people in his iron and steel mills. His drive came, not from an outstanding work ethic, but from being 5 feet tall - he decided at some point he could overcome his short stature by standing on his wallet! By the time he died, he could have been a power forward in the NBA!! Again, I ain't mad at him for conning over here from Scotland and becoming a stupid rich robber baron. What bothers me is that he was aware of the devastation that his mills did in Pennsylvania, yet his idea of "giving his money away to the less fortunate" was building libraries, concert halls, and universities. Tell me how that helped the disenfranchised whom worked 12-hour shifts, 7 days a week, with not breaks? Who had time to read a book or go to a symphony? Yet he fought down striking workers who only wanted to allowed to work a regular 8-hour day in grueling, hot, unsafe conditions. He felt that he had some kind of entitlement as he raped the country who gave him a chance. Carnegie's mills only hired African-Americans as strike breakers and our people had been here about 200 years before his family! I don't get this guy at all. At least Cornelius Vanderbilt and the rest of that era's industrialists made no excuses for the bad they did nor did they try to act like they were humanitarians. I can't give this book 1-star because it does have its moments. But save your money and look "Shorty" up in Wikipedia. Way too long with no skeletons in the closet.
David Nasaw seriously needs to produce an abridged version of this book
I enjoyed the stories of elaborate vacations across the world which took up more time than Carnegie's business activities.
The account of the violent confrontation at Carnegie's Homestead factory in 1892 was extremely good - balanced and yet very compelling.
Great biography and very informative. Just very long.
the very best
The volume of the book is quite staggering but I never thought of quitting at any part as i have done with some books in the past. As someone who has read both his biography of himself and David Nasaw's, this story of Andrew Carnegie gives another perspective on the life of a real titan of industry and world affairs in an enjoyable narrative starting from pre-birth to the very end. Great read!
Entrepreneur using Audible to fill the endless hours spent traversing this wonderful land until Google finishes their car!
A well put together biography with the right level of detail into the life of Andrew Carnegie. You see him not as a unapproachable titan destined to where he ended, but as a nuanced man with the typical characteristics we all have, with the advantage of having been a "boy in the room" at the right time to get his capitalistic start.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.