Through sloppy usage and low standards on the Internet, in e-mail, and now "txt msgs", we have made proper punctuation an endangered species. In Eats, Shoots & Leaves, former editor Lynne Truss dares to say, in her delightfully urbane, witty, and very English way, that it is time to look at our commas and semicolons and see them as the wonderful and necessary things they are.
©2003 Lynne Truss; (P)2004 BBC Audiobooks, Ltd
"Oh, to be in England. Or rather, oh, to have quotidian access to BBC4 radio productions such as Cutting a Dash....Thank goodness all six episodes are available as a classy audio production....Through it all, the crisp, humor-filled voice of comedy writer/literary editor Lynne Truss gives us permission to laugh aloud while being shocked, yes shocked, about the disastrous state of punctuation and grammar in the modern world." (AudioFile)
First, is't not the original book, which I assumed it was. Rather is a number of disjointed excerpts, interviews, and sound bites, with lackluster attempts at comedy. I took away nothing I did not know.
It is poor value for the cost. If the price we $3.95, I probably would not return it.
I was hoping for so much more; disappointing product. This content may have been better as the BBC show or as written material. There were parts such as the walks along London streets that did not work well in this format. There are better books on this subject matter.
Cute, but because it is a collection of radio broadcasts, it becomes very formulaic and predictable. Enjoyable for a quick listen, but seemed long, although it was only an hour in length.
Your Brother in Christ
This isn't the book! I say that because it is obvious from the title of this program if one reads the whole thing, but it seems many didn't bother and then were disappointed with the product for being what it says it is.
This is the radio broadcast that inspired the book. It's a very clever program that helps a person think about punctuation and its uses. It shows, for instance, how a misplaced coma can have deadly consequences. "Let's eat grandpa!" means something entirely different than "Lets eat, grandpa!". Lynne Truss uses such examples to show the usefulness of punctuation. And that is the usefulness of this program it arouses interest in punctuation and alerts the listener to the need for punctuation.
Of course, there is talk of how punctuation is used properly and different mistakes made with punctuation and why. The history of punctuation and the uses of different marks was also interesting. However, the show is by no means exhaustive in its treatment of punctuation. Most of the individual segments are maybe 10 minutes long. Also, there are no chapter breaks in this program. That seems like it would have been an easy thing to do. The whole program is one hour and runs through the entire broadcast in one fell swoop. No re-listening to just that segment on the comma.
I really enjoyed this book and it really helped me with my writing, but I think it was just the recordings of the radio show that the book is based on because it didn't flow like most audio books. I plan on buying the actual book to compare.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.