I thought the concept of the different view points and delivery were terrific, I just would have liked a bit more rounded perspective on the parts of the characters other than Adams. It certainly did take you to the battle field and give you the feelings of fear. I did learn quite about the Pacific Theater that I did not know before. Probably great if you like war novels, just not quite my cup of tea.
I love almost all of NGs work, but this was not one of them. The back ground music and the acoustical treatment was distracting. The story was interesting and his reading was good, but missed the pace that his work usually has. I would have preferred that it had been more of a story that was told and become suspended in that world w/ out the interruption of the discordant musical track. I did like the quartet but not here.
There have been so many previous reviews that truly describe the experience of this work. Put it right up there w/ "Neverwhere" or "Night Circus" and you would not be off the mark. I have not enjoyed a tale this good for quite a long time. You learn to understand and love just about all the characters and the words bring a visual world that is almost three dimensional. Needless to say I think I may have to return and read again in a short time. Buy it read it and you won't be sorry.
I look forward to more of the writers work and of course GG is just as good as it gets. Thanks to all the creators. Chuck Cunningham, Solvang, CA.
Truly between S.King and N.Gahman. Its been a while since I found something of this nature very involving. Great dialog and character portraits. Started out a bit slow, but built rapidly into a great tale. I like it so much I am writing the review prior to finishing the book. Sorry thats all for now, got to get back to the listen! Chuck Cunningham, Solvang, CA
Sparse, clean, evocative, enchanting and wondrous. My words can not start to describe this work.
You walk and dream right along w/ Harold during his journey as he discovers much of his life in the rear view mirror. It seems often, it is only after the fact that we get a clear understanding of what we have experienced and who we should have recognized as important, no mater what a small part they played in our lives (are their small parts or do they all add up?). I don't understand why more people don't know about this work. It reminds me of "Gump", "Racing in the Rain", "Guernsey Potato Pie Society", or "Legend of Bagger Vance".
This is one of the best works I have ever read.
Now how wonderful was the reader!! Just as excellent as possible! I don't think this book will be done justice on the printed page after being colored w/ such a rich read. I will listen to more by Jim Broadbent no matter what he reads! His voice is reminiscent of Anthony Hopkins or Richard Burtan. I can not say enough good things about the artists and their production group.
Thanks so much for such a textured experience and it is an experience.
Chuck Cunningham, Solvang, CA
I have gotten away from JGs work of late having found it pushed and not anywhere near the excellence of his original novels. I read the reviews and thought this one sounded like he might have returned to previous levels, but that sadly is not the case. I enjoyed parts and the reader, but the story does not drive forward and has multiple digressions that just are not important.
I would not suggest wasting the credit on this mediocre tale. Chuck
Well read but the story just did not hold up. Way too much poor kids stuff and an ending that was just too far out. I have enjoyed some of her other books, but this one some how got off the tracks. Some interesting moments, unfortunately over shadowed by the poor and unbelievable story line. I could not wait for this book to end while hoping for the best.
This and the first book had some very interesting and intriguing moments, but you can only do so much w/ a plot. This one just dragged out the first and then didn't finish!!! Quite a bit out in left field. The narrator however did his best and drew the characters in vivid color. No way am I buying the next one, sorry. Chuck
I read a lot of books and this is one of the best in this genre. A little bit of Gaiman, Bradbury and some Rowings! What a great tale and super delivery. I did not want it to end and wanted to spend more time w/ the characters and the intrigue, not to mention the core of the story, the love of the two magicians! Reminds me a bit of "Stardust". I think its a good read for kids to adults w/ a whimsical bone. Super narration by a reader that in the past has done mostly children s books. I appreciated his characterization of all the parts! Good work. My only disappointment is that its over and it will be several years before I can read it again! Thanks again for the wonderful time at the "Night Circus"! Chuck
What an imaginative work! It took my thick brain a bit of time to get the picture. I am sure I would benefit from a second reading w/o worrying about who is doing what to whom! This was one of the most creative works I have had the pleasure to try to figure out while enjoying the character struggles that are so much the same for all of us to some degree. It did seem like so segmented chapters put together, but it is a book that I would (do) strongly recommend to friends. Thank you Jenifer
Report Inappropriate Content