I really enjoyed this whole series, however, this book was a little slower and some parts dragged on a bit too long. I really thought the romance that began in the last book took so long to get established that the heat of it kind of fizzled by the time they could finally be together. All in all, though, it was still really good and kept me entertained the whole time. I did not like the 2 narrators for the last book, though. I felt like the parts from Hector's perspective were a little boring and his voice didn't really fit the part. It seemed unnecessary to add Hector's point of view for this book. I liked it better just from Elisa's point of view.
This book was just OK. There was nothing that made it very interesting or unique. It felt like a fluffed up transitional book with very lazy writing. There was just so much unnecessary storyline and not much meat. It was just a filler book in the series. Nothing really even happened until the very end.
As for the narrators... At first when I heard Ed Westwick I was happy because his voice is dreamy. However, this was NOT the right book for him to narrate! It doesn't get worse than a Britt trying to do a Jewish New Yorker accent. It was awful! Simon sounded like a weasely cartoon rat thug and Jace sounded like Sylvester Stallone. It was bad. Then Molly C. Quinn starts her chapter and oh my goodness, I couldn't believe how bad it was. You would think that the director would have run out and found a new narrator the second he heard her start reading, but no, they actually let her continue in her embarrassing train wreck of a performance. She sounded like a high-schooler who was called on in English class to stand up and read aloud to the class. She worked so hard to enunciate every single word perfectly that it sounded completely unnatural. Not to mention that most of her characters had the exact same voice so it was hard to tell who was even talking. It was so bad. Like unbearably bad, as this is the most I have ever written about narrators in a review!
The only reason I gave this book 4 stars instead of 5 is because there were a few parts that were a bit long and boring. Aside from that, this was such a lovely story of mystery, bravery, honor, and love. I found myself genuinely caring about the characters and wanting everything to work out for them. The setting was interesting and fun and made me want to be there. Juliet Marillier paints a beautiful world with words. Great, clean-cut story for kids and adults alike.
Narration was a pleasure to listen to and she did well with all the characters voices.
This is an interesting start to a series. It's totally unique and mysterious. Part of me hates being completely in the dark about what is going on but part of me is enjoying the unfolding of the plot piece by piece. It definitely keeps you guessing and wanting to hear more.
Narration is great!
Book one was very intriguing and interesting, but from there it was a long, boring and steady decline to fizzling out at the end. This book can hardly be called the conclusion to the trilogy because it concludes nothing at all. The title of the book is a total lie. Basically the entire storyline of this book was completely pointless. It was disorganized, random, and so unnecessarily long and drawn out... all for nothing. Like other reviewers, I too stopped caring about the characters to the point that when a major character died, I didn't even care. At one point I thought Thomas was going to die and I truly didn't care.
The questions you have had the entire time you've invested in this series NEVER get answered. You get no background, as Thomas chooses not to get his memories back. What? Seriously, what was the point of everything? What a waste of time and credits! Sadly, I am pretty sure all of my questions would be answered by listening to the prequel, but at this point I am so annoyed and turned off by being strung along through this series that I just want to be done with it and not waste any more time.
Narration was great, but that was the only good thing about this book.
I read the other reviews and I'm not sure why people loved this book so much, but it seems that I am 1 of only 2 people who thought it was unnecessarily slow and long. For all the wasted hours I had to hear Celaena complaining, whining, and being pissed off or prideful, there could have been an actual storyline there. I just got so tired of her whiny baby attitude... and Rowan was no better. Of course, by the end of the book they suddenly grew up and accepted their fates, but geez, it took them freakin' long enough to get there!
I was so put off (as I also was by the previous 3 books) by Celaena's childish pride (and everyone else's pride for that matter) that it was hard for me to even get into the story. I think it just wasted a lot of time, got people unnecessarily killed or injured and cheapened the quality of the story. I think you can still take your lead character on a journey from immaturity to maturity and still make them likable to the reader, but that was not the case with Celaena for me. I think this is the first series I have ever read where I strongly disliked the lead character.
As far as the actual storyline goes, I think it was disjointed and developed really poorly, and because of that I wasn't invested enough in the characters to feel much emotion about all that went on. It also dragged on so long that I was just plain bored. The story also lacks originality, as I felt like I was listening to a mishmash of plots from other books I've read lately.
I don't care for the narrator either, as I think she may be adding some inflections of pride or anger to all the character's voices that might not have been there had I read the book instead of listened. Oh, and the whole time I thought this was the final book but clearly it's not and I'm actually annoyed by that. I've invested so much time in this series that I feel like I have to follow it through to the end to see how it turns out. But if the last book is anything like this one, I may pull my hair out before making it all the way through.
I really enjoyed this book. I fell in love with the characters and found myself really wanting to be in their world. It was a sweet story that was beautiful and dark and fun and magical. The whimsical characters drew me into the story and made me want to keep listening to find out what happened next. This is a great book for teens, as it is clean-cut, but I believe most adults would thoroughly enjoy it as well. I'm excited to listen to Cybele's Secret and see where the adventures lead next!
The narrator was pretty good overall but so much of the time her voice would take on a very childlike tone that it made the main character sound much younger than she was supposed to be.
While listening to this book I enjoyed it for the most part but now that I finished it, I'm not sure how I feel about it as a whole. There was never a time when I was just dying to find out what happened next or where I couldn't stop thinking about the book after I finished listening to it. The writing was very very detailed, which made for a long and slow book, but mostly it wasn't boring. The story was interesting and mysterious but I think it unfolded so slowly and in such a way that it was anticlimactic.
I'm thinking I sort of lost my taste for this book when there was a scene where a man has sex with his horse. It gave WAY too much detail (any detail was too much) and it made me nauseous! I also felt some of the things were a little unbelievable at the end based on the way the characters had been written all the way through the book. It seemed like at the end, all the unrelenting stubbornness just vanished and suddenly all were amicable.
Eduardo Ballerini is a great narrator and does multiple different voices well, but after a while his voices became grating to me, especially the women's voices. I saw that there was a sequel and I may get it one of these days but I'm not feeling super eager at the moment.
I read this book quite a few years ago and loved it so much I considered it one of the best Christian books I had ever read, so I decided to try the Audible version. While I still loved this book in audio, I guess I have changed a lot since first reading it. I loved the raw emotional journey you go on but this time I really didn't care for the mystical aspects (Lilybet, etc.) and I also didn't like how they went about finding the truth by using dishonest means, even at the very end when they are ringing the death bell to gather everyone. None of those things ruined it for me though. It was still a heartbreaking and beautiful story that I would highly recommend.
This series began in book 1 with such mystery, beauty and promise but steadily declined from there. Book 3 was so, so unnecessarily long and wordy! It was trying (WAY TOO HARD) to be very poetic but it just made the whole story very disjointed and hard to keep track of.
I think introducing the new characters and background story lines in the final book was a mistake in this case. The new backstories really needed SO much more development and detail but instead it was just thrown in bit by confusing little bit. And what detail was given, was done so in such a poetic way that it really did nothing to help you understand the story. For as long as the book was, all of the unnecessary stuff should have been removed, and detail and attention given to developing the new characters and backstory in a straightforward manner. It was like she was trying to create mystery up until the very last second but instead created confusion and the build up just fizzled when revealed because it never quite meshed with the rest of the story.
The characters were also very disjointed and felt thrown into the story at random. Sometimes you wouldn't even hear about a particular character for many many chapters. Long enough in between to forget what was even going on with them. Also, many important things that were built up all throughout the book (i.e. Zuzana and Mik finally getting engaged) were just completely glossed over and only given one or two sentences after they occurred. Big letdown!
The ending of the book was so jumbled and all over the place. It really didn't make a whole lot of sense. I still don't even understand all the backstory that led to the ending. And a lot of things were just left open-ended, which sometimes works, but in this case it feels like certain characters were just forgotten about.
While I thought the narrator did a great job with the voices, she sounded a bit subdued throughout this book, even in very intense scenes which should have warranted much more enthusiasm. She read the entire book as if it were one long (too long) poem. She also mispronounced so many words that I thought it was really silly that the editor didn't catch any of them. Oh, and when you change the way you pronounce names and places from one book to the next in a series, it's distracting. I feel like this has happened quite often with audio books and I wonder why the narrator doesn't find out how to pronounce the names and places of characters from the author before recording. Especially in fantasy books where the names are sometimes difficult.
Anyway, I would love to read book 1 again but I won't be wasting my time with books 2 or 3.
I rated the first book 5 stars all around but I took away one star all around for book 2 for the following reasons:
Book 1 was so intriguing, fascinating, exciting, and mysterious. It made me want to be Karou... what a fascinating and mysterious life she had! But then at the end you find out she's not actually Karou, but Madrigal, and that is when the fun mystery that has been so built up all comes crashing down- never to be picked back up again.
In book 2, I was mourning the loss of the exciting, young life of Karou as the whole tone of the story shifted and became dark, anguished, heavy and dry. The whole feel of book 1 that captivated me was gone and I missed it and it was never coming back. In addition to that, the mysterious characters- such as Brimstone, who I so longed to discover more of- were all dead!
The beautiful imagery that painted book 1 so lovely and made you want to be there was missing from this book. Left mostly to my own imagination, Eretz was vast and empty, without much detail by the way of landscape.
The story was really heavy and angsty, which got on my nerves. In my review of book 1, I had said I was relieved it wasn't full of angst, but book 2 more than made up for that with plenty of angst. However, once I accepted that this was now a new and different story with a totally different feel, I was able to enjoy the book for what it was, especially for the way it ended.
Finally, the reason I removed a star for the narrator is because she read this book in a strangely continuous manner. What I mean by that is the story frequently changes locations or perspectives from Madrigal to Karou to other characters, but the narrator transitions from one scene to another completely seamlessly, without even a pause, so if you aren't paying close attention, you may lose track of where you are.
Like I said, I was still able to enjoy and appreciate this book, but be prepared for a dramatic change to everything you loved about book 1.
Report Inappropriate Content