I'm not above a good soap opera...Trollope, Dickens, etc., but this one was so bad that I must warn people about it. It's written in the Romance fiction genre as in Barbara Cartlen, etc. The love scenes are ridiculous. There is so much "fill" that one sits and waits for the plot to move on. The narrator does and okay job with the British accents except for the lower classes which cause one to wince every time she does one. Stereotypical cardboard characterizations throughout.
A big disappointment.
It was too silly. There was so much trivial fill that I couldn't stay with it. Was it supposed to create suspense? It didn't for me.
The narration was not so much the problem. She was just acting out a very silly narrative.
Men who like this author's work
The Trinity Game
That's what did me in. It took me ages to first, get the names straight then, to get the characters straight. Then he kept bringing in new characters.
Not for me.
The book felt very crowded and the narration was too fast. That is possibly what his readers like.
I was hoping for more history of the 15th century. The dialogue had a very modern tone to it which was offputting. Things (events) just happened and happened and then it ended. It was fairly light hearted and humorous and I was looking for a more serious effort.
This is one of the best books that I've ever read. The scope of the book covers the 60 years of blacks migrating to the north, east and west. It rarely gets boring. Mostly because Wilkerson follows 3 very different people out of the South. She intersperses the data between the ongoing stories of their lives so well that you forget that it's nonfiction. It's only the second book that has moved me, shocked me and made me cry... the other being The Grapes of Wrath. The Jim Crow brutalities and oppression were horrifying and deserved her detailed descriptions. Robin Miles narration has a great deal to do with the books success. She does a superb job of southern voices both men and women, all of them distinct from each other.
I can't recommend the book highly enough.
I've read Lee Child before and had enjoyed it but this book, in my humble opinion, was terrible. The narrator was too melodramatic in his story telling. There was way too much macho testosterone, The sex scenes were agonizingly slow and felt gratuitously explicit as well as serving as much of the "fill" that burdened the book. If it hadn't been for all of the above, it was a very interesting story. PJD
I read this book based entirely on Heinline's recommendation. I found it to be one cut above a comic book. The characters were stereotypical as in Dr. Horvath and cardboard thin. The book could have been at least a third shorter. The pacing seemed very uneven. The narrator made almost everyone speak in the same halted and stiff speech. I didn't want to finish it but I had to find out what happened even though the solution of the blockade seemed unimaginable and anticlimactic. AND it took way to long to get to. Comic books move right along.
Report Inappropriate Content