I haven't read the print version so can't compare. However, the narrator, Jill Tanner, of the audio edition goes way above and beyond standard narration. Indeed, she makes the book almost a dramatic performance. With her beautiful, contralto voice, Tanner is able to even create characters with individual sounding voices. Truly remarkable.
So relevant today, even though written 150 years ago. The prose is beautiful.
She gives a performance of the book. Her elocution is perfect. She's able to create what could be local-sounding British accents of the day. Very entertaining.
Yes. It made me cry. Having experienced some major "troubles" in life, it was wonderful to read of others who have struggled.
Absolutely. The prose is beautiful.
Gatsby, the person with a past.
No, I have not heard him narrate. It's wonderful for actors to narrate classics such as this. They bring intent and interest to the story. The elocution is wonderful. Gives me a new appreciation for how important voice is one of the instruments of master actors.
Near the top
It's rather like choosing which part of a quilt keeps me warmest, the book has many memorable moments and is very difficult to single out just one.
I love that you ask about Ms. Stevenson's "performance", rather than her "narration". I have not listened to any of her "performances", but I most certainly will. It is utterly amazing to think that such a fine performer would undertake a labor of recording such a lengthy work. It is a testament to the importance of elocution for an actor. Stevenson's ability to create, and maintain, believable "voices" for different characters in the book is absolutely astonishing. She even has a knack for creating a voice for an old man and a younger man. Her portrayal of old, befuddled Brooke is amazing and quite comic. Listening to her, one realizes the talent and skill which contribute to fine acting. Watching performances, great actors make the creation of characters seem so effortless. When one listens, one focuses simply on the vocal skill of the actor, which in the case of Stevenson, is so very gifted.
Oh yes, I laughed several times and sometimes it brought a tear to my eye. Eliot's prose is some of the finest written. Also, she was able to create such very likeable characters.
I am finding that I am choosing audiobooks not only for the content, but for the quality of the narration. To have accomplished actors such as Stevenson "perform" a book of this quality is an experience not to be missed. It's an art form unto itself.
Atonement is one of my favorite films. The book is also wonderful, but the visuals of the film are stupendous. The book is quite different than the film in some areas, but not significantly. The description of what happened at Dunkirk is especially moving. How easy it is to forget the sacrifice made by so many young men. This book reminds one of the incredible devastation of war.
Yes, I probably will listen to the book again. It is a wonderful story and charged with Jim Broadbent's first rate narration. This audio-book should be the standard which all narrators should emulate. First, Broadbent does not rush. He allows the listener a bit of time for certain sentences to sink in. This is especially important because of the incredibly beautiful prose of Joyce. Secondly, there are so many gorgeous metaphors created by the author. Sometimes there are metaphors in literature which are pretentious and forced. Joyce's metaphors seem to be like a normal adjective, some of them are pure genius.
One of the great actors of the day, having performed in "Moulin Rouge" and "Iron Lady", Broadbent brings a very gifted actors' sensitivity to expression and language. As an audiobook, Broadbent has created something of a performance. His tone of voice are perfect for the story. Also, of course, I imagined Mr. Broadbent as the protagonist, which brought an even more wonderful experience to the novel.
I sure hope he continues to narrate. Spectacular.
The older "distinguished" gentleman Harold meets at a train station.
I do hope Joyce continues writing novels. When I googled her, I couldn't believe this was her first novel. I had just completed George Eliots' "Mill on the Floss", and in my humble opinion, Joyce's work was comparable. However, Joyce is contemporary. Her gentle style is simple, yet refined.
The narrator is speaking in a British accent much too quickly. It's hard enough to follow what he is saying, let alone have any time for reflection.
It truly amazed me to learn that Lincoln suffered from acute depression. I could identify with many experiences he had related to depression. It was also beneficial to learn that to be melancholic in Lincoln's day could be perceived as a virtue. It certainly doesn't have the stigma it has today.
I learned that even great men such as Lincoln have suffered from depression. That depression can actually enhance one's life experience.
Report Inappropriate Content