Patrick O’Brien has done a masterful job of taking us and dropping us aboard the British sloop Sophie in the middle of the Napoleonic Wars. In amongst the suspenseful action of naval warfare, we are treated with insight into the thinking of a newly promoted Jack Aubrey as he learns and deals the various realities of command set upon him.
The narration by Patrick Tull is phenomenal; better than the Simon Vance sample I’ve heard.
After beginning to listen to this in this book at home I relegated myself to listening to it only in the car, well out of the earshot of my 2, 4 and 6 year-old children. Obviously seamen talk as seamen do. O’Brien does a good job of telling the story so that you get the sense of the salty language of the ship, but without bombarding you with incessant expletives. Most of the time he handles it in an indirect fashion such as, “and a stream of cursing could be heard when…” Beware, there is a short song toward the end which repeatedly uses the F--- word;
A ship’s diagram would be very helpful in understanding the ship jargon. Perhaps Audible could provide related illustrations on the website.
A solid 4 stars (would be 5 except for “saltiness”). I plan to get the rest of the series.
DIONNE is the ANTI-CRICHTON
Having enjoyed State of Fear, Jurasic Park and the like I greatly lamented the passing of Michael Crichton. As Karen Dionne was promoted as a "female Michael Crichton", I eagerly took the plunge.
But the writing quality was not engaging, and the science greatly lacking. Crichton had a more than superficial scientific understanding of his material and because of that took a critical view of what passes these days for eco-science. He cared deeply for the real science of the environment and lambasted the ECO-WACKOS, instead pointing us to shun the PC eco-politics in favor of a real understanding of our world.
Dionne, seems not to have this understanding of the material, and falls prey to the PC eco-pseudo-science to a frustrating degree. It also makes many of her story premises unplausible making suspension of disbelief near impossible.
The characters are uninteresting, though she has made them to a degree mundane (in a good way) that they feel "real" like the scientists and businessmen I meet daily (with the exception of the key villains).
If you miss Crichton....
Avoid this book!
Lynch gives some great insight into using your life's experineces as an "edge" into finding stocks, and then shows you how to research those stocks, and what to look for before choosing to invest. Finally he shows how to identify when to sell.
I've already listened to this book three times through. Each time I get somthing new from it. It is like drinking from a fire hose. I'm not sure if this is due to the abridgement, or if an unabridged version would take even more useful information and pack it even more densely into this book.
Peter Lynch does an excellent job of narrating his own book. An author narrating his own book can always be hit or miss... Lynch is a hit!
I wish he told about where to find free sources for the detailed stock research he suggests using. I'd hate to spend money on the paid services for my first few small investments, as it'd eat up any potential gains.
Yes, 1927 was the original copyright date for this book. It really brings back an age of literature when heroes were without any nasty flaws. These boys obey their parents and don't grumble when Mom asks them to run an errand. I don't know if that hearkens to an earlier age of teenagers, or just an earlier age of literature.
It pulled in my 6-yo daughters attention immediately as she merely wandered through the room.
This Narrator is excellent, and I like the old style "radio drama" music they've added from the golden age of radio.
I wish audible had the whole series, I'd get them all.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.