This is my least favorite of the four in the series, but as you can see from the ratings I gave it, it's still good.
Unlike most of his works, this one has portions that some parents will want to pre-screen before reading to young children because of explicit references to animal sexuality, detailed accounts of collecting specimens for artificial insemination, etc. And, additionally, parents should be aware that this was a hard-drinking culture, and Herriot didn't minimize that fact.
The story is also oddly disjointed, making frequent jumps from the 1940's to the 1960's and back again, which detracted from its quality in my opinion.
However, it's still very enjoyable because Herriot had a wonderful eye for beauty, for humor, for poignancy, for sorrow, for joy. And he knew how to set it all down masterfully on paper.
And the narration? Well, it's Christopher Timothy! What more needs to be said? He's wonderful.
It's hard to imagine listening to a biography of one life for 54 hours...but this particular life was so packed with amazing events lived by an amazing man, that every hour was justified.
Okay, I'll admit there were a few hours that began to feel a little boring to me at times, particularly about his childhood and his ancestors. But I'm glad I listened to them, because biographies are about knowing people, and people are about all of the factors that shaped them, including the mundanities. Truman never forgot who he was and where he came from, so those shaping influences were necessary to the story.
And, as I'm learning from reading other minutiae-minded authors (such as Marilynne Robinson and even Victor Hugo), the little details provide ambiance, and ambiance immerses the reader, if the reader will allow it to. The reader begins to feel as though he is walking through life with the main character, and where this may not always be exciting, it certainly deepens the understanding and even affection that is developed.
And I became very fond of Harry Truman while listening to this biography. I knew next-to-nothing about him before reading it, but now I feel a deep respect and appreciation for him. Though we disagree on some fundamentals, I can now at least appreciate his positions. And though I can see some of his mistakes, I can respect that they were well-intended mistakes. He was, in short, a good man. And a good man is always worth getting to know. Frankly, that's one important way that this book helped me grow as a person. It showed me how much it's possible to respect someone with whom I disagree on major political issues. And that's a huge gift, because respect is a major antidote to...well...being a knee-jerk JERK. I hope to be less of a knee-jerker with people on the other side of the political spectrum, more interested in getting to know them as people rather than as political labels.
But mistakes and disagreements aside, this man did a phenomenal job in two terms which threw more staggering challenges at him than any previous president had ever faced. Few men could have stood up under the assault. I defy his critics to have done better.
As for the narrator, he was excellent. It must be a challenge to make a 54-hour biography enjoyable to listen to, but he certainly did it.
Somewhere past halfway through the book, something changed in the studio, because the mic picked up a lot of mouth noises from there until the end of the book. But that should reflect on the technicians, not on the narrator himself. And it should certainly not discourage anyone from taking this very worthwhile walk through the life of Harry Truman.
All of Herriot's books are very enjoyable because he had a wonderful eye for beauty, for humor, for poignancy, for sorrow, and for joy. And he knew how to set it all down masterfully on paper.
However, before reading this to children, parents should be aware that this was a hard-drinking culture, and Herriot didn't minimize that fact.
As for the narration? Well, it's Christopher Timothy! What more needs to be said? He's wonderful.
The story itself was enjoyable. It follows the old formula of creating ambiance by adding in lots of seemingly extraneous dialogue (though not nearly as much as you'd find in some other old stories, like "Les Miserables"). If you know that in advance, and don't expect a perfectly streamlined, a-b-c plotline, you'll be able to relax and enjoy that ambiance. Raveloe will start to feel like a town you know. And you'll be glad you took the time, because it's a pleasant, feel-good story.
As for the narrator, he's even better than the story. I'd happily listen to him again.
I confess that this is my first Bronté novel. I say, "Confess," because it seems almost criminal now to have lived nearly 50 years without having read her before...especially since I'm already a fan of Jane Austen, who wrote similar works.
Jane Eyre is an amazing work of fiction. Brilliantly descriptive language transports the reader into another world...and the narrator is the perfect vehicle for the story. Susan Ericksen does a masterful job. She handles the different characterizations with ease, seamlessly, almost completely without stumble (and with none that are serious). I would happily read Bronté again, and I would happily listen to Ericksen again.
(This review covers both the Kindle version and the professional narration.)
I loved this book!
I have long been prone to being paralyzed by the fear of making mistakes, and would often rather live with the consequences of other people's decisions than make decisions of my own.
The Lord has been working on this problem in my life for a while, chipping away at the walls of my prison. But reading this book was like putting down my little chipping tool and trying dynamite instead. Fresh air at last!
Lots of good biblical wisdom here, and lots of dismantling of pseudo-religious thinking which shackles so many people. If you or someone you know is struggling with decisions and the will of God, get this book!
The professional narration was good. No complaints. I would readily listen to him again.
(This review covers both the eBook and the companion audiobook from Audible.)
This book touched and helped me in many ways.
First, it gave me a detailed account of an amazing life. A good biography leaves one feeling that one actually knew the subject. Though Bonhoeffer died back when my mother was only a tiny girl, I feel as if he was a friend...the kind of friend who inspires and enriches me. He makes me not only want to be closer to God, but also shows how God draws near to us in life's darkest hours. Since the world is becoming increasingly hostile toward Christianity, even in America, it is good to see an example of a man who lived what Christ taught. Bonhoeffer loved his enemies, did good to them, and taught the pure, unadulterated Gospel fearlessly. He died a martyr, just as fearlessly.
Second, I had heard differing accounts of Bonhoeffer which confused me. Some called him a great Christian, and others called him a heretic. This book showed which of his writings have been twisted to completely misrepresent his beliefs, and explained how it happened. I can't imagine that anyone could read this book and come away believing that he was heretical. His faith was too solid, too Biblical for that.
Third, it inspired me to buy another book, this one by Bonhoeffer himself. It's called, "The Cost of Discipleship," and I can't wait to read it. I know I will be challenged in very important ways.
Now, as for the audio narration, I can only give 4 stars. The narrator generally did a good job with the text (except when he tried to do female voices, which I'm glad he quickly stopped trying to do), and I would not hesitate to listen to one of his readings again. But for reasons that I cannot fathom, he was chosen for a book which requires the ability to pronounce German words and names...an ability which he largely lacks. Even the main character's name was mispronounced in painful ways much of the time. Really, the problem is not a reflection on the narrator himself, but on the choice to pair him with this particular book. But I say these things only to prepare listeners so that they won't be unpleasantly surprised. By all means, do NOT let this problem keep you from this excellent book. It is well worth it, even if you have a finicky ear.
I am so glad I read this book. Bonhoeffer was a true man of God and an inspiration to countless people. I am glad to now be included in that number.
(This review covers the Kindle version and the companion audiobook from Audible.)
I debated whether or not to buy this book, and I'm SO GLAD I did! It has been a breath of fresh air in every way.
I did not grow up in a tradition that uses catechisms, and I had no familiarity at all with the Heidelberg. I did, however, grow up in a church that taught me to love good theology, and I have pursued good theology for years...sometimes losing the pursuit of God Himself in the process.
Not that God can be known apart from good theology. But it's possible to pursue theological knowledge as an end in itself, and to do so with a desire to master Christianity and master others with your Christianity. In other words, it's possible to be a Pharisee.
Good theology, rightly pursued, is not a desire to master God, but to be mastered by Him. The true knowledge of God must always lead to submission, as can be clearly seen by the Biblical accounts of everyone who encountered God's majesty firsthand. One pursues good theology in order to rightly know this God to whom we all must give account, and, knowing Him, to live every day in a right relationship to Him.
Enter the Heidelberg Catechism, and DeYoung's warm exposition of it.
I have rarely been privileged to hear such a wonderful depth of worshipful theology condensed into such a small package. I often felt joy and even wonder at the beautiful simplicity and depth of the truths expounded there, and expanded by DeYoung. In addition the narrator managed to capture DeYoung's pastoral tone very well, and was obviously a good choice for the audiobook.
Even in the one area where we truly disagree (DeYoung is a paedobaptist, and I'm a credobaptist), I found the book helpful. I was reassured by what the Catechism's paedobaptist view does and does NOT embrace (for example, it avoids the heresy of baptismal regeneration). I also appreciated DeYoung's warm, humble, joyful, loving defense of his views on the subject. He is a brother in Christ that I would enjoy meeting on this earth if I ever had the chance, and I look forward to getting to know him in Glory!
I can't wait to share this book with my entire family as a part of our family devotions for the next year.
My first encounter with this book was as the basis of an adult Sunday School class. I found it so helpful that I went out and bought the audio version to listen to it again. I have no doubt I'll listen again in the future.
This book helps parents to be real, dealing with real children and real life circumstances. Unfortunately, far too many parenting books see children as blank slates for parents to write upon, clean disk drives to program, or Pavlovian dogs that we can teach to drool on cue. And of course, they teach parents how to look good (i.e. "super spiritual) in the process, because that's really what it's all about, isn't it? If we raise our kids right, they'll be great trophies of our parenting skills.
Well, "Spiritual Parenting" is not that kind of book at all. It's all about humbly, lovingly, intentionally creating atmospheres that invite our children to taste the grace of God, and that invite God in as the welcome Lord (and as the ONLY perfect Parent). It deals wisely and LOVINGLY with the inevitable mistakes and sins of both parents and children, without ever disrespecting the individuality of either.
The narrator is the author herself, and she reads with all the feeling that one would expect from the woman who cared enough to write the book, and who is often sharing her own stories, or the stories of others that personally impacted her.
I was tempted to say that Elyse Fitzpatrick is trying to "bridge the gap" between faith and works, but of course that would be terribly inaccurate. What she is doing is showing that the gap doesn't exist, and only our misunderstanding of the Gospel creates a chasm.
She does an excellent job of showing how the only true good works are those born of "faith working through love" as the Bible says. She hammers home the truth of God's Love in its rich fullness...not the bubble-gum love of the so-called "prosperity preachers," but the real Gospel love that transforms lives. She helps the reader rest in God's love, not as a place of self-indulgence, but as a base for godly living.
The narrator does a very good job with the text. My definition of good narratior is that she helps the listener immerse herself in the text, without calling attention to herself in the process. Raudman accomplished that at least 90% of the time.
Report Inappropriate Content