Without a doubt one of the most enjoyable listens so far (although I admit I've only listened to a handful of audiobooks). Highly entertaining. After listening to several other Dogma Debate audiobooks I have to say this is by far the best I've heard from them as well.
With the title and an author as well known as PZ Myers it might seem easy to lump it in with any other atheist book. It certainly has common elements to many atheist books, as it touches on common subjects and responds to common theist arguments. But it's very unlike many atheist books in that it is absolutely dripping with sarcasm, sharp wit, and humor. It doesn't take itself so seriously. Emphasis should be placed on "Happy" rather than "Atheist", because it's very much meant to be something we can laugh about rather than simply more arguments over religion. PZ's well known style won't let his fans down, and I think any atheist can enjoy the lighter tone this book takes. And humor and happiness are potent weapons when used by skilled writers like PZ, there are still plenty of punches even if it's not as dense as Dawkins or Hitchens, or as somber as many books of deconversion from theism. Perfect for an audiobook.
I admit that I am biased, Aron Ra is one of my heroes and I downloaded this book immediately when I heard it was Aron Ra that read it. But I also went in a little curious and skeptical. Aron Ra has a tendency to talk fast, go from quiet to loud, and I wasn't sure how much of either Aron Ra would drown out PZ's voice or how little of Aron Ra's unique character would be sacrificed for the sake of the audiobook. I am happy to say I was pleasantly surprised. Aron Ra blew me away with his performance. He spoke clearly, slowly, level, emphasized just the right words when needed, and had a clear passion that any Aron Ra fan has come to love and expect. But he was still very much reading PZ's words, there was no point when I felt PZ was overshadowed by the Texas Tank. I was also thrilled at hearing Aron Ra do several voices and impressions where appropriate, it added an extra layer of humor to an already brilliantly funny book. I really hope this is not Aron's last audiobook.
PZ's analogy at the beginning of religion being like a hat was fantastic. And while I'm sure Pharyngula readers (or even people who don't even really know PZ) will be familiar with the "eucharist controversy", it never ceases to amaze me hearing how people react so venomously over something so silly. But really throughout the book I was impressed by PZ's words, arguments, and insights, and regularly laughing out loud to something said.
I'm still unsure what audience PZ had in mind. It seems like a book more for atheists and specifically those at least casually familiar with him. Even though it's a fairly light book I probably wouldn't recommend it to any Christians or Muslims I know personally, there are still plenty of points when they're the brunt of the joke (for good reason). But there are also many times when it seems it's addressing a believer or touching on an argument no atheist hasn't already heard a million times before. Perhaps there are thick skinned liberal theists or those sitting on the fence who could listen to and appreciate this book, but PZ doesn't seem interested in convincing anyone or deconverting anyone either. I think it's more for entertainment than anything. And entertaining it was!
Report Inappropriate Content