Of course. Overall a great author.
I did find this book a bit disappointing in that Mr. Winchester seemed to let more of his own personal philosophy, politics and moral judgement leak into this book, a vanity of many authors of history he has up to now, to his credit, refused to indulge in.
A good editor. Far less exposition and geek speak. The book falls into the usual trap that all those other "in the tradition of 'famous author'", in thinking that the liberal insertion of whatever jargon and technical detail into a thin plot makes for a thrilling inside novel. I'm an insider and I found it tedious. To outsiders it must be clutter that is both excruciatingly boring and utterly unhelpful in moving the story along.The plot in the last third of the book simply became absurd, rendering the government investigative team as utter morons, and the resolution completely predictable.Thats perhaps the biggest criticism of the book. There are no surprises, Mr. Suarez telegraphs every plot advancement and resolution; except when it simply jars into a new, different thread.Performance wise, I felt like I was listening to a never ending Michael Bay movie trailer. Note to Mr. Gurner. Subtly and an even measured cadence makes for an enjoyably listen.
No, huge fan of Stephenson, this is a pale pale imitation
The idea at the core of the book has potential, although in reality its just another variant of the Skynet plot. I'm not sure it could ever be made workable though
Leave her righteous indignation out of it, or at least save it for her own personal take in a chapter to itself.
Not really. Her tone was vaguely supercilious.
It became apparent just a few paragraphs into the introduction this was not going to be a dispassionate historical account, but rather, morals and judgement, dispensed in great righteous dollops. What ever happened to articulate factual historical recounting and letting us, the little ole reader, for themselves, decide what moral judgment, if indeed any is even needed. If you've already decided it was pure evil incarnate, I cannot expect to get an accurate narrative of the history.
Report Inappropriate Content