Although I know it will not be worth it, periodically I succumb to mass hysteria (on an individual basis) and buy a book like this one. I am always dissapointed.
I enjoyed Johnny Carson and Ed McMahon on TV as much as the next person. But this book does not replicate what I enjoyed on the TV screen. It is not that the book is bad, as much as it just doesn't "do" anything.
We get a little history, nothing that was unknown before. We get a lot of humor, nothing that hasn't been told before. We get a lot of sentiment, and nothing pleases me more than to know that these two personalities loved and respected one another as they had good reason to do so. But none of this was new.
Listening to this selection did make me wonder why I buy and listen to the selections I do. I may not have come up with any answers, but I know I must do a better job of resisting buying more of these celebrity titles.
This selection did not live up the expectation of the first two in the trilogy. Maybe because I lived through this portion of history it did not seem as exciting. I was getting lost by the characters and bored with everyone's sexual encounters. Enough is enough. The narration was good but the story wasn't as good.
How can you not root for the success of the poor relations? Though the story line is simple and rather outrageous, it is all fun!! And all the fun is only made better by Davina Porter narrating. Can't miss.
The series continues to keep me interested, but it does get confusing at times remembering all the story lines and characters. I swear some are thrown in for use in future volumes, but add nothing to the current tale.
I cannot imagine these books without Davina Porter. In fact, as much as I have enjoyed the TV series so far, I miss hearing Davina's voice and think somehow she should be added. Hint! Hint!
This recommendation by a friend proved more interesting than I imagined. The story works around a few known realities of Louise Brooks, a silent movie star, but Louise is not the center of the story. Cora blooms throughout this tale. In the middle of the book (maybe a little further along), a dramatic surprise is introduced. The story could easily have ended there but doesn't. And I'm glad it didn't.
I consider the narration uneven. When not speaking for the characters, McGovern presents very sophisticated voice. But when either Cora or Louise speak, a midtown corny voice is used, one that doesn't fit nor is it convincing.
Even though it was a little difficult to follow all of the characters from the first installment, it was a great read (listen) and fascinating!! The hours flew by. Narration was wonderful. Can't wait to get to the last installment!!
I heard about this book and was fascinated but waited to purchase it for almost nine months. Then I didn't listen to it for another eight months. But within the first five minutes I wondered why I took so long. I then purchased an electronic version because I wanted to "see" so much of what she wrote about in order to communicate it to others.
Seeing other reviews about this book it saddens me that it has not necessarily caught on to the audience that needs to read it the most: the "lay" population. I see a lot of doctors and nurses (myself included) who recognize the value of this topic. But the word needs to get out there to everyone else!
This book was well written. It has clear language about evidence based research findings. The writing catches and keeps your interest. The author reads it very well. I love everything about this book!! I will use the information not only in my personal life, but also in my professional life: as a nurse an as an educator.
I have not agreed with others when they rave about Sue Monk Kidd's books. I enjoy her writing (enjoyed her Guideposts entries years ago much more) but haven't fallen in love with them. I was hesitant then to get this book. I was not aware of the fact-based foundation until Kidd revealed it in the recording at the end of the book. Her explanation of how she came to write what she did, fact here and fiction there, made me like the story much more, for some odd reason.
It was Sarah's character that gave me pause. I did not see her as the driving character she must have been in real life. Her desires for a real and full life were well presented, but I also saw her being drawn into her situations by others and not initiating actions on her on.
Hetty and her story, on the other hand, was fascinating. I saw her truthful (especially her statement about how her and Sarah's lives were both restricted but for different reasons) wisdom and struggle throughout. I could understand what she felt and why she did what she did.
And Angelina's role in the story seemed to come in as an afterthought.
Narration by both was well done.
I say get the book as much because everyone else has in order to be able to intelligently discuss it. but don't get it because you think it might be compelling literature.
It was so good to really get immersed in a good listen!! The time was simpler and the characters revealed that. What was good was good and what was bad was bad. The main family exemplified strong values. They stood up for what they believed in and acted out in appropriate ways for what was wrong. I loved the scene where a number of men at night were going to "raid" the camp. In simple honesty, the wife started greeting the men by name, asking about family and work and such. Very simple, but very powerful. She knew and stated that if they were called out by name, they would be ashamed of what they were trying to do and leave. And that was exactly what happened. Simple, honest, powerful.
For a story about how a Japanese internment camp changed a local village, there was not much about the "prisoners" in the story. There was enough to show how the main family tried to do what they could to provide a good example and interact with them as much as possible. But the Japanese families were just a side event, even though their existence was the basis of the story.
Narration was excellent. This is definitely worth the credit. I will purchase more by this author.
I have listened to several very long books. I will not pursue additional books in this series as this one wasn't worth it. The story itself was interesting and carries/carried much potential. But the pompous characters, almost all, were ridiculous. There were stray ends that could have taken the story along a variety of directions. Many never went anywhere and were unworthy fodder.
Narration was decent.
One distracting piece was a lack of attention, I feel, to accuracy of the era. I have read enough books placed in this timeframe and maybe I am used to their attention to the differences from our times. For example, paper was a scarcity. It was hard to come by and therefore treated with such respect. It lent to an unbelieveability for much of what happened.
This was a good story even though there was a great deal of predictability to it. I have never read any of this series before and usually don't start with one in the middle. But based on the other reviews, maybe I am glad I did as I did not know that I was missing some good interaction that was present in previous writings.
The narration was not the worst I have heard, but certainly not the best. Do not let that stop you from listening to this one.
Report Inappropriate Content