I completely understand the frustration of folks who find this book to be "too much." I had the same reaction to Robb's "Discovery of France," which does not have an audio version. I posted a 3-star review at Amazon taking some hard shots. But I always had the disquieting feeling that the book was simply difficult, not at all unworthy, the opposite, in fact. That feeling won out, over time, and ultimately I took down my carping review.
As of now, I have only the Audible version of this latest Robb book. It is difficult to casually follow. IT IS DIFFICULT TO CASUALLY FOLLOW. But for those with the inclination, the payoff is huge.
There is no need to be judgmental here. Some people -- most people, perhaps -- are mildly interested and wish to be amused and informed while remaining in a casual relationship to the material. Nothing at all wrong with that, but it does not work for this book. At least, not for me. I regard it as more like a college course; I plan to read the book and to listen more than once. For those who have that level of interest, it is a dazzling tale. To me, it is more than worth the effort...big investment, big payoff.
The narration for Agustus's speech was awful and ruined the entire book for me. After three hours, I gave it up.
Because Augustus was written as a cantankerous character, Mr. Horsley got the idea that he should shout, instead of read, the words of that character. A horrible judgment that ruined the audio version of this great book. Completely ruined it.
Great book in written format, great story-telling by McMurtry.
Why not salvage this situation with a do-over of the narration? A lot of people love this book which, in my opinion, accounts for the overall high rating. But if you look in detail, many people found the narration for Augustus just as disturbing as I did even if they could not bring themselves to be harsh in their overall judgment of such a great book.
Report Inappropriate Content