"I wanted to be able to give this 5 stars."
I really wanted to be able to give this book 5 stars!! Most of the book I kept thinking what a good book this was, possibly better than the first one in the series (my favorite so far). However, there were a few things that really detracted from it.
The main thing was that the climax was extremely disappointing. There was very little build up to it and it was very brief. It could have served as an event to build up the tension and excitement to a bigger and better ending.
The book mostly focused on the two main characters in a "do I love him/her" tug of war. There were other multiple minor story lines introduced in other characters that never went ANYWHERE. I understand they were trying to set up future books, but it was a little overkill. I wish Callahan had chosen 1 or 2 to develop more and actually go somewhere with them.
What made the book really good was the chemistry between the two main characters. I could have continued to listen to more about them and hope Callahan picks up their story in future books.
"Good start, but slow in the middle"
This book started off really well with quite a bit of drama and tension. I didn't want to stop listening until about half way through. The story suddenly became stagnant and didn't seem to go anywhere. I had to make myself finish it. I really wish Maya Banks had done something with the last half, it could have been an excellent book.
"Another great book!"
I loved this book as much as the first one in the series. I liked the uniqueness of the characters and the story line. I didn't want to stop listening and finished the whole book in just a couple days.
"My least favorite of the series"
This book was okay, but not as good as the other books in the series. I like the two main characters well enough. However, the story line was pretty bland and uneventful. This narrator was okay, but there were a couple of quirks that got on my nerves occasionally. I'll continue to read the series, though (assuming more books come out).
"A nice change"
Though this isn't my favorite book in the series, it was nice to come across a change. Sometimes when there are a multitude of books in a series, they can all start to run together and follow the same patterns. This book had a completely different approach to the plot and foes. I thought I might get bored with the whole story happening at one event in the course of an evening, but it managed to keep my attention and interest. I'm glad the "bad guy" wasn't just another elemental trying to move in and take over the city or get revenge on Gin. I'm also glad there was a little bit of a break in the plot between Gin and her sister. I agree with the other reviewers in that I dislike Owen greatly and hope she moves on in books to come.
"It was fine"
There was nothing really wrong with the book, but there was nothing really great about it. The characters were fine, the plot was fine, there was sufficient action, and it wasn't boring. However, there was nothing exceptional about it. I didn't love it and I probably won't remember it past today. It seems like something was missing. Maybe tension and drama, as well as some character development.
The narrator did a great job and probably helped the book by really bringing the characters to life.
"Love the series, but this is my least favorite"
There were several aspects of this book that I didn't care for. My main issue was the overwhelming number of side stories that were going on throughout. It was like the book had ADHD or something. By the time the book returned to the main story, I had forgotten what was going on.
My second issue was the weak story line between Blay and Quinn. I just don't think the two characters were strong enough to have their own book. It isn't the m/m that I had a problem with, but the lack of depth of the characters. I personally think Blay is extremely bland, boring, and has no personality.
I couldn't really connect with this book at all, maybe it was the inability to relate to the m/m romance. I think Ward handled the issue with delicacy and applaud her efforts. However, I just found this book lacking in so many ways for my personal tastes.
"For a younger demographic"
I don't think this book was as bad as some of the reviews, it is just meant for a much younger reader. An aspect of the book that was both a pro and a con was that there was a lot of action and the characters moved from one emergency to another. It kept the book moving forward, but there was almost too much of it. The characters were pretty unique and each had their own personality, something brought out very well by the narrator.
If I had a teenage daughter, I would recommend the book to her. It was just a little too young for me personally, but I can't fault the author or book because I chose to read a YA story.
"Only 2 stories worth listening to"
The first two stories were pretty good. The third one was so boring that I couldn't finish it. I also didn't notice the narration being bad until the third story.
"Great book, superb narration!!!"
This is my favorite book by Julie Garwood. I loved all of the characters and the story line. What made this book even better was the wonderful narration. Duerden did a great job on the 2 main characters' voices. She gave Iain Maitland a sexy little drawl when he spoke to Judith. The characters often whispered in this book and the narrator did an exceptional job in bringing that out and giving it emotion.
"Another great book in a great series!"
I love this series! Mercy Thompson is one of my favorite characters out of the many series I keep up with. She is strong and independent without being overly aggressive or defensive. I love the way Briggs continues to let Mercy evolve and grow. That was especially apparent in this book, which showcased Mercy's abilities. I also really like the supporting characters in the books. Many of them made appearances and had bigger roles in this book.