Chosen a different book.
The entire final act. It had nothing unexpected, and degenerated into a pit of unpleasant cliche.
How this book got high ratings is beyond my comprehension. The story is nothing more than a glorified Lifetime or Hallmark network movie of the week. The characters are weakly developed and almost cartoons except there is no humor in the book at all. Not one thing happens that isn't telegraphed, and listening is like some sort of water torture where we're just waiting for the next painful drip. There are some small vignettes of good writing in terms of observing and documenting some of life's little conundrums but beyond that this story has nothing to offer but an unpleasant, dour, finger wagging moralistic lesson on infidelity that we've heard a million times before.
I gave it four stars for the quality of the writing. Not the level of enjoyment I got from listening to it - that would be one star. The writing is stellar - JK Rowling is one of the greatest writers of this century, and I do not say things like this lightly. However, I did not enjoy this book. There is a huge difference between great writing and being entertained and I'm going to draw that line here. There are some people who's talent is so great it must be acknowledged, yet I do not care for their work. Thankfully JKR wrote the Harry Potter series so I do in fact enjoy her work - just not this book.I In fact it was a very unpleasant experience to listen to it. The subject matter was dour, dark and depressing. I got the feeling that JKR wanted to prove she's a "grown up" yet it was entirely un-necessary. Anyone with two IQ points to rub together can see the deep sophistication of the Potter books - who cares if children like them too? The audio version of this book was much better than the print version, which I gave up on after chapter 5 and never finished. The narrator did a terrific job. That said, I can't recommend this book to anyone who wishes to be entertained.
I'm writing this review mainly to praise the narrator. John B. Hickey's performance was nothing short of brilliant. His voices and characterizations brought each of the characters to life in a way that was incredibly compelling to listen to. I still can here him saying "aaaah well...." Mr. Hickey was able to channel a clear personality and sound to each character and brought each one to life that sounded absolutely genuine to the listener. This is a huge achievement and Mr. Hickey is obviously a tremendous voice talent. As for the material I'm a big fan of John Irving's works, and this story is good. I suppose one could say that he was courageous in a way to attempt to write this book, but his usual literary tools stood out as such and overall lacked something intangible that makes his writing attain the greatness he's had so many times.
I'm a huge fan of Pat Conroy's work and have read everything he's written. But this book, just wasn't his best work. There were formulaic elements that were obvious "Conroy" tools but they stood out as such. The narrator did a very good job and but the flow of the story was not optimal, and the characters, despite how long the book was, were not developed enough to take this book to the usual level of Pat Conroy's usually brilliant works.
What disappoints me the most is how so many people can give this a high rating let alone anoint it "Audiobook of the year." There is literally no new take on the subject matter and no new insight being offered. And as far as the listening experience goes, it is akin to having a rash that starts out small and then takes over one's entire body. The fact that so many people can derive any sort of pleasure from such a long painful flow of misery that does nothing but get worse and more painful as the story goes on disturbs me in terms of what it says about people. This book/audiobook is the highbrow equivalent to staring at road side car wrecks.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.