Of course, most of Audible's questions apply to a more traditional fiction or nonfiction work, but I hope I can provide some comments that are helpful. The lessons will provide some basic vocabulary and grammar that someone who wishes to learn Spanish will find helpful. The first third of each new lesson reviews what has been learned previously. However, after a while, words learned early on are almost completely dropped, so some people are going to forget them, and they need to be re-introduced from time to time. There are two speakers, a man and a woman, and their diction is generally clear and easy to follow. They break down long or difficult-to-pronounce words into parts. They could have done this with a few more words. The weakest part of Pimsleur is that it is a cookie-cutter model. They use the same words and grammar for each language. The choices of words can seem odd. For instance,the first drink one learns is "beer." Hm. Also, one has to wonder about the politics of the people who developed a system that teaches people the words for "man" and "woman." "People" comes last, and the words for "boy" and "girl" are not included in Phase 1 at all. Adults only, please! I am studying Spanish because I plan to visit Latin America, and later on, I hope to visit Spain. In the long run, I have found this system unsatisfactory for someone like myself, who is primarily a traveler. In the 1990s, after having taken one semester of Italian over twenty years earlier, I picked up a cassette about an hour long that was on conversational Italian for business and pleasure travel. I learned more from that one cassette than I did from 30 Pimsleur lessons, in part because that cassette had a practical sense of organization: at the airport, at the hotel, in the restaurant. At the end of these Spanish 1 lessons, you will be able to count, understand simple directions, and know how to ask for a doctor. But the other words I already knew from films like "Dirty Harry." The only food items you will know are coffee, tea, and beer! You won't know the words for a bus, plane or train. You won't know the names of any types of stores, like supermarkets, pharmacies, or department stores (though you'll know the word for "buy"--you just can't get to the store). I wouldn't recommend this system, and I know a lot about teaching languages. I have taught French, English, and English as a Second Language at the university level. I have edited ESL textbooks. I have traveled widely. I speak several languages, and I have lived abroad. I know what it takes to get around in another country. Pimsleur isn't your ticket to fluency.
This novel, like the main male character in the work, needs to be less a talker. Lots of meaningless, seemingly endless chatter, or so it seems. A few lovely sentences but not enough to sustain all the noise.
I loved Messud's THE EMPEROR'S CHILDREN and would still recommend that.
She captures most of the characters really well and performs a range of accents and age groups. She does least well with the main character, who is from New England--a slight Southern accent peeks through.
Skip this book and read the first one if you haven't.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.