The story is quite well written with good character development and a decent writing style. The voice-acting is excellent. However, the technical side of things seems fairly poorly thought out. Suspension of disbelief is invoked many more times than necessary in this book, in many places seemingly out of laziness. The space battle scenes seem to lack a sense of the actual size of space, and space battles seem more like naval/air battles. For example, a space ship with wings so it can work in atmosphere as well, which seems to go from zooming around the canyons on a moon or the planet's surface back into orbit in a matter of a few seconds, then sweeping graceful arcs through space. While I confess, this is no worse than some of the SF in Star Wars, it feels a little disappointing on this front. Also, as mentioned by others, the book is steals pretty liberally from The Last Starfighter and Star Wars. As a character study, it's good, and it would probably make a decent summer movie, but don't go in expecting anything vaguely like hard SF.
As someone who has been reading fantasy for several decades, this book falls clearly (and this isn't a spoiler) into the "person transported to another world who can do magic" category. The characters are likeable enough, but it feels like there isn't a tremendous amount of depth. There are large jumps in time, and it sometimes feels like a leapfrog from one action sequence to the next. The balance of power doesn't seem ... well ... balanced. It was an enjoyable enough read, and I will listen to the next one when it's out, but if another series produces a sequel first, this one will probably not be the first on my list.
Don't get me wrong, this series isn't a disaster or anything. I will probably give the second book a try.
- good action/suspense
- decent plot concept. Pretty tricky to make inferior technology plausibly relevant, and this is handled reasonably well
- military aspects are fine,
- Writing isn't all that great
- Science is a bit rough. Seems like he may have had to play a bit fast and loose with some numbers to make the plot concept work.
Looks like the beginning of a fairly long series based on what is revealed in the first book. Wasn't sure if i liked it 1 or 2 hours in, but kept going and was quite involved by the end. Will definitely continue.
Do not read this book if you haven't read the other two books of the Kingkiller Chronicle. If you have read those books, and want to see more of his wonderfully sculpted universe, this novella is a great addition. Don't expect it to extend the plotline of the main series. This is a side branching, but wonderfully imagined and beautifully written and read. Unlike many authors in the Scifi/Fantasy genre, where the focus is often on the world and plot, rather than the writing, Rothfuss is a deeply skilled writer. Much like his character, everything simply has to be right. Every word in its place, and carefully considered. Even though it is short, it is well worth the price. I hope he finally manages to finish his trilogy soon, and continues to write.
I read most of Chalker's work back in High School, and requested that Audible make it available (as I'm sure did others). Chalker does speculative SF very well, and has a lot of creative ideas in his books. While certainly some of it is derivative, most of his books are far less derivative than most other authors, and he has a lot of ideas which are uniquely his. This particular series, while voice-acted very well, isn't my favorite (though I had to listen to it again to realize that). His other series, like the Well of Souls, are much more creative and interesting IMHO. Don't get me wrong, this series isn't bad, and like his other books, his universes are well thought out and self consistent. I just found myself getting a little bored as I listened through this series.
Is should start by saying that, not realizing it was the middle of a series, I did start out of order. However, I didn't feel lost, and it was pretty easy to pick up the back-story. While it is fairly well written and is well performed, it just wasn't all that exciting. The science/magic wasn't all that clearly developed, making it mostly about the characters (which can still be fine). I just found myself not caring all that much about them. It was fine, and I finished reading it through the end, but didn't really have much of an inclination to read the others in the series.
Based on the cover art from this series, I was a little afraid it would turn out to be some sort of romance novel (which I do not read) with some sci-fi fantasy tweaks thrown in. Never fear, this is a solid fantasy series, with a very imaginative interpretation of real-world mythology and a good self-consistent set of rules for magic, gods, etc. They are action-packed with good character development, and very solid voice-acting in the audiobook version. I immediately continued with the rest of the series after reading this one. PS - If you are devoutly religious (regardless of the religion), you may not find it quite as enjoyable, as it certainly pokes fun at the idea of any one religion being correct.
I first read these tech/magic crossover books as a teen in the 80's, but it still translates quite well. While the computer tech is a bit dated, those of us who grew up in the dawn of the computer age can still appreciate it, and it's a minor aspect of these mostly-fantasy/mystery books anyway. Great character development, and a very good mystery plotline to pull it all together. Don't expect a tremendous amount of detail in the workings of magic in her universe, but what there is holds together very well. Well worth the read.
I read pretty much everything Chalker wrote back in the 80's as a teen, and enjoyed this series then as well. I sort of expected that I would find it more childish or unsophisticated reading it as an adult. I was completely wrong. Still an excellent book, and definitely his best series. Wonderful character development, a highly original plot, and the voice acting and recording quality are excellent as well.
Report Inappropriate Content