LAS VEGAS, NV, United States | Member Since 2004
I had no problems with the substance and story of the book. Although I think my being an active age group triathlete helps to make the book more interesting than it would be to someone who has never been kicked in the face during an open water swim! The two protagonists are interesting people and their achievements, which are related in the book, are phenomenal.
On the other hand, the narration is just off. One of the worst of any audiobook I have listened to in 20 years (including back in the audio cassette days). The best way I can describe the narration is that it seemed like the book was narrated by Cruella DeVille. Seriously, listen for yourself.
This is a very interesting book and worth the listen. However, if you're looking for detailed battle narration or specifics on weapons and equipment, this is not the book.
The best way I can describe it is "WWII from the eyes of an aristocrat." Von Luck is clearly an upper crust type, and when we hear about his "Mercedes Cabriolet" he rode around in on the Eastern Front or the "penthouse" in Berlin which fell victim to an incendiary bomb, you get what I'm talking about. Von Luck definitely comes across as an honorable soldier who placed great value on the chivalry and fair play that sometimes took place during the war between the English and the Germans.
This aristocratic tone really develops during the narrative on his time in Soviet captivity. Thank God for the German prisoners and their industrious, no nonsense attitude towards helping (forced labor) their Russian captors with mining and building projects, otherwise it seems the entire Soviet regime would have collapsed!
Regardless, for anyone who is interested in WWII and a version of the events from the other side, this is a must read. The parts about his very close association with Rommel are alone worth the time listening to this book.
And the narration by Bronson Pinchot is very "authentic."
The part I enjoyed about this book was the unique insights which only someone who has been there can bring to this fictionalized account of the US Government's drone warfare campaign. As for the story, I would describe is as simple, straightforward, predictable, and just too conveniently wrapped up and decorated with a nice bow at the end. It's worth the read though just to learn more about how (with room for literary exaggeration) the real drone program works.
If you want to know what went on behind the scenes during Armstrong's 7 TDF victories, this book does a good job bringing out the facts. It's well organized and give an outsider's view of the details as compiled from the written evidence and participant interviews. You also get to hear about all the people who either facilitated the fraud or fought against it. It's more of a journalists version, and not as "personal" as probably one of the best accounts I've read, Tyler Hamilton's "The Secret Race."
If you're interested in the SEALS, this is another in the well done accounts which have come out recently about the Spec Ops masters. The book is a little disjointed, but thats OK because the author gets his point across. I would have liked to have heard more about his time as a training officer, but overall I enjoyed the book. Some people have complained that Rorke Denver as narrator is a bad idea. I liked it. He may not have the English accent nor the sonorous tones of the professional narrator, but his no frills, direct, and sometimes dead serious narration just adds authenticity, and helps you realize you would not like to be on the wrong side of this guy in a firefight.
This is a fantastic story. If there's a single word I can use to describe the author's handling of the events in this book, that word is "love." You sense the author's respect for these men as you experience this book. As a lifelong student of the war in the air during the World Wars, I can say that the research that went into this work is first class. The story makes you want to meet the German pilot and thank him for his humanity. You'll find yourself making time just to listen!
The story is very good. The technical aspects of the accident and investigation are interesting. The main character is very likable and you root for him throughout the book. Overall an interesting story and definitely worth a listen. If the book has any drawbacks, its the lack of exposition of the various characters, who appear and disappear so frequently that they are hard to keep straight sometimes. Also, although the ending is well done and edge of your seat stuff, it seems lacking somehow. It's as if the author had a deadline and had to end the story about a chapter or two early.
BTW, the narrator is top class.
This was my first foray into Z "literature" and it was fun. All around good book. Kept me interested.
First, this is one person's audiobook review and not a "for or against" religion tirade (which is commonly seen when "atheist" books are reviewed).
I thought Hitchens narration was good. What is lacking due to his not being a professional narrator is more than made up for by the fact that he is the author and seems to know the material (surprise!). He reads with flair and wit . . . and you get those classic Hitchens deadpan zingers in all the right places.
As for the substance. This was an entertaining listen with a lot of good ideas. Dawkins' (The God Delusion) is more scientific and Harris' (The End of Faith) is more comprehensive. Hitchens brings his ability to throw literary punches and intelligently rip into religion as the "product of close evolutionary cousins of the chimpanzee" This is a great book, whether you have Faith or not.
My suggestion is Sam Harris first, then Dawkins, then Hitch.
(Disclosure: I have been an atheist since I could think for myself and these new series of books on the subject are a godsend. How many times can you read Bertrand Russell and George Bernard Shaw?)
For those who enjoy knowing about "things" which most people have no idea about, this is a good book. It delves into the world of underwater archeology and treasure hunting within the realm of 500 year old shipwrecks containing valuable Chinese and Vietnamese porcelain. The personality conflicts and risks involved are all painstakingly laid out. Also very interesting is the description of "saturation diving", which is a requirement during such expeditions. The book kept my interest, mainly because I like to be the only person in the room who can talk about Vietnamese pottery. But if you are expecting "Shadow Divers" part II, forget it, that book was five stars and in an altogether higher classification than this one.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.