This is the first Debbie Macomber book I have "read" and will likely be the only one. The writing is simply not very good for an adult level book. Perhaps it has been written as such with the intention of being family oriented, but frankly I doubt children would be interested in the storyline. The premise of the story held promise, but the book simply does not hold up. The writing is quite simplistic and often redundant. It serms there is very little effort put into describing the characters feelings and experiences. For instance, several times she describes characters reacting by "frowning" rather than more accurately describing if they are upset, angry, puzzled, distressed, etc...there are a number of emotions which could elicit a frown, but she simply does not make the effort to be more descriptive or expansive. The author was also repetitive in her general writing style throughout the book. The idea of the story is pleasant enough and I like uplifting stories, but this was a disappointment. I agree with previous reviews that the angels were portrayed as being very dumb...yet continually commenting on how slow-witted humans are!
The narrator affected my experience as well. The accents seemed possibly incorrect and at times inconsistent. The voice she used for the lead male character of Aren sounded very strange. She tried to speak so low for his voice that very little emotion or inflection could be properly portrayed. "His" voice sounded both strained (constipated) and quite monotone (= boring) so it was VERY unappealing to listen to his parts of the story (which are frequent). The parts of the story with only females were much better. I would certainly recommend to the narrator to try not use such an extreme change in lowering her voice for male characters as it simply does not come across well in the way it was done on this audiobook. The general narration as well as the story I often experienced as too syrupy and shallow.
The resolution between Aren and Lucie occurred, once again, in an over simplistic and unrealistic way. Additionally, for a contemporary book, the way it concluded was very provincial and conservative (narrow-minded even) as far as how the future would play out for the female, Lucie.
I had hoped for more after seeing and generally enjoying a few TV movies based on Debbie Macomber books, but this book did not deliver for me and I get the sense that the movies are perhaps transformed quite a bit from her books (unless this one is entirely different from the others).
Wish I had had a better experience with this one!
I hoped to enjoy this book much more than I did. I certainly did not expect a great literary work, but I did hope for a more consistently enjoyable and entertaining experience - and that simply did not happen. Additionally, the magical cats theme was largely what intrigued me as I enjoy both cats and magic; however, the cats role in the book is quite a bit less than anticipated. The plot and characters were generally fine, but it dragged on endlessly with sections which I found to be boring and meaningless with prattle and filler details.
There was a lot "trudging" through inconsequential conversations and situations to make it to the end of this book. 10.5 hours (and however many pages) could easily have been condensed to about half that long in order to tell this story. I forced myself through it since I try to make it through most every audiobook I purchase. If the book was much shorter it would have better kept my attention and interest. Unfortunately, there were many scenes and conversations etc which were not interesting and did not propel the plot/story either. The overall writing was simply not skilled enough to support the length of this book for this storyline. Also, if the book had been shorter, the cats would have played a more prominent role in the storyline as would be desirable in relationship to the title of the book and series.
Unfortunately, the narration did not assist this book in maintaining interest and attention. Although I found that the narrator (Ms. Campbell) clearly has the ability to narrate in a more natural manner...nonetheless, at least 75% of the narration felt very unnatural and was difficult to listen to in a variety of ways. It ranged from being monotone/boring, to "sing-songy", to forced characterization and then to men who mostly speak very slowly often causing them to sound dumb or slow-witted. It is curious to me that the narrator clearly displayed (much less frequently, unfortunately) the ability to narrate in a reasonably natural and believable manner - it is too bad that could not have been maintained 90-100% of the time instead of 25% of the time.
I personally cannot recommend this book, but if you enjoy listening to a lot of filler and largely insignificant and less interesting details at great length then you will probably enjoy this book. Wish it had been about half as long, then it would have proved to be much more enjoyable for me - though more natural narration would also been very helpful for improving the overall experience. If both were the case with this book, I could have potentially given one or two more stars.
The theme and plot definitely have good potential but I simply found this book far too long for the needs of the storyline.
Always a fun read/listen with Mrs. Pollifax at the helm! She is a wonderful character and meets other interesting characters during her undercover adventures. Definitely recommend if you enjoy cozy suspense/mystery genre.
I found this lovely story to be rather unassuming just as is the title character. Harold Fry embarks on a completely unexpected and surprising journey which teaches, challenges, uplifts and transforms him as well as others in his life. I highly recommend reading this gem...it may start a little slowly but continues to build in layers as it progresses adding more and more for the the reader/listener to relish and absorb. The narrator is excellent and brought this story to life beyond the pages, in the same gentle understated spirit as the author wrote it. I was truly able to visualize Harold and his journey as well as all of the other wonderful characters. I highly recommend reading this book and experiencing its charm, wit and wisdom.
This was an enjoyable light listen / murder mystery. I like the magical theme of the book so it was appealing and I found it to be decent mystery as well. The narrator was fine but not terrific. I liked some aspects of her narrating better than others....not sure where she is from as she has unusual or unique pronunciation of certain words. When she spoke the character name of Alexandra, it often sounded (to me) like AlexandER instead, but not a "deal breaker" on listening to more of this series (I think she narrates more of the books). I would definitely recommend to anyone who enjoys cozy mysteries with a little light romance thrown into the mix!
Bought this on a daily deal (I think) as the psychic aspect seemed like it could be fun and those parts of the book really are the only interesting portions of the book. Abby is pretty much an arrogant jerk/smart ass a lot of the time - and for that reason would be the last psychic I would choose to consult! Additionally, she is stupid and immature. Not really a protagonist that is either endearing or appealing. Maybe if it had been read differently, perhaps a more appealing quality could have been perceived from her. Though the writing itself pretty much says it all as far as her personality goes...
As far as the narrator is concerned, she is not the worst but I did not feel it was good either. I could actually say narration could rate at 2.5 to possibly 3 stars at times. I am not sure if this narrator would do better with a more well written book or not since she seemed rather one dimensional. I can say I was relieved that lower male voices were not attempted by her as that so often detracts from a book (and vice versa with a male narrator) unless the narrator has the ideal skill and tonal qualities to do so.
At the point in the story when her life truly appears to be in danger, it is hard to stop thinking about how idiotic she is since she is completely responsible for putting herself there by her own stupid immature arrogant behavior and it also makes you wonder about what the male love prospect sees in her! And on top of that, her psychic intuition fails her when she needs it the most...karma perhaps for being a jerk?
Not sure if I would have listened to the entire book had I not been under the weather since it was an "easy mindless" listen/story. I am giving it 2 stars for creativity with many of the psychic aspects, otherwise it would only be 1 star. I would not purchase another Abby Cooper novel, however, since there are other light mystery novels available which are much better written and are truly entertaining and enjoyable (also with much better narration). I was definitely disappointed with this one :(. Glad I purchased it at a low price!
This book is well worth reading to discover how many people you may have known (or know currently) who could possibly be sociopaths. Although this book may not be the most clinically scientific book on the subject of sociopathy, I was engrossed by the composite cases Dr. Stout presents in the book...even though it was at times difficult, creepy and chilling to read. As another reviewer stated, it is more of a "self defense" book regarding sociopaths vs. one which will assist in how to handle a sociopath with whom it is very difficult, or perhaps impossible, for one to cut all ties (a relative, etc). Nonetheless, there is much is this book which is quite enlightening, informative and may very well assist you by helping you to avoid becoming significantly involved with a sociopath in the future...and also help you to recognize when you may have inadvertently encountered one...such as your neighbor. I definitely recommend it and will probably be buying this book for at least a few friends or family members!
This true account was quite illuminating, recounting the life of a girl raised by a hoarding father and shopaholic mother. Both parents love their daughter but are unable to truly change their habits in order to create even a remotely serene and clean haven as a home for their only child. The hoarding father truly cannot acknowledge, much less address, his mental/emotional condition and resulting hoarding behavior. He is completely incapable of throwing anything away. The untenable conditions of the homes in which Kimberly is raised are disturbing and heartbreaking yet learning of it in this book makes for a moving and educational read/listen. I can also say that reading this true life account could perhaps be more motivational for organizing one's own house (etc) than any book written about organizing! It could virtually "scare" you into organizing just by reading about the out of control conditions described. And, understandably, that is essentially the very effect growing up in it had on Kimberly as, once she no longer lives with her parents, she can only bear to live in extremely tidy, clean and sparse surroundings. It is also very difficult to learn about the negative ramifications their family living conditions had upon Kimberly's ability to live an otherwise normal childhood since she was so embarrassed and ashamed about the situation - she lived her childhood in a way wherein she could hide the situation - subsequently limiting her number of friends, not to mention her ability to be truthful with her friends about her home life until such time(s) she saw no other option(s) but to reveal the truth. Narration by the author, Kimberly, was authentic and generally good. Recommended for anyone interested in hoarding or human behavior in general. I did not know how I would like this book upon buying it, but I am glad to have read it and learned about the realities of such a situation.
Listened to this book in just 2 days...and I rarely do that - it had me hooked! Highly recommend this book about a young woman's highly scary and disturbing experience with "madness" caused by a treatable illness which was nearly missed entirely by her medical team, but thankfully was ultimately diagnosed correctly. If it had not been correctly diagnosed, she may have ended up in a mental institution. Even if this is not a typical genre of book you read, it is still well worth the time to become familiar with this vexing and mysterious illness which was not discovered and correctly diagnosed until 2007! It is frightening to imagine how many innumerable people may have been institutionalized or died due to it prior to 2007. It is also worth reading so one can ponder about how often patients may be misdiagnosed due to under-informed physicians as well as many other possible reasons doctors may not diagnose accurately or completely. This is not to be a criticism of all doctors, it is simply a reality and the account of Susannah's experience conveys why I believe (from personal experience) it is often in a person's best interest & highest good to seek multiple medical opinions (western, eastern and alternative), most particularly when a person is experiencing a complicated or mysterious "dis-ease", such as Susannah's type of (and many other) auto-immune disorders. This book is a well researched and well written account of the gripping physical and mental roller coaster Susannah experienced and from which she was very fortunately able to substantially, and hopefully nearly fully, recover.
For me, the narrator/narration was the weakest part of this audiobook. Not awful, but it did not resonate with me overall as an accurate portrayal of the author's emotions, reflections or experiences. There were moments when it grated on me, but all in all I was able to disregard it enough to appreciate, and be engrossed in, the content of this book. Had the narration been superior, I would have given the audiobook an overall 5 star rating. Regardless of feeling the narration could have been much better, I still highly recommend this book in audio or print!
Enchanted is a charming and, yes, enchanting story. The story itself is its own though it weaves elements of multiple fairy tales within it. It is a progressive modern fairy tale. Narration was very good. An engaging, enjoyable and delightful listen suitable for teenagers and up. A good choice as a teen read for the themes and topics addressed within it. I do not have children but am glad to see a book such as this one available for teens as an alternative to the current dystopian trends in teen fiction. Not a Pollyanna story but one with a more positive message than some other teen/YA books. A recommended read for any teen or adult who enjoys fantasy and/or revisiting beloved childhood fairy tales blended together with a modern spin.
3 stars is probably a stretch for the story, but I am glad the author is putting out ideas and concepts which are not mainstream and those core concepts of this story could be very helpful to people on their spiritual, healing or new age journey. It addressed healing the emotions to heal the body which I believe is extremely important and an element about which many people are completely unaware or do not attempt to acknowledge or consider. Since our mind, body and spirit are all interconnected, this is an important message and theme contained in this book. For me, the writing and the story outline were jumbled and not cohesive, even for out of the ordinary topics such as this book contains. I believe the message in the book could have been delivered much more successfully with better writing and a more fluid story.
It is also extremely challenging to listen to this narrator. If there was a much better narrator, it would be much more enjoyable to listen to this book and hear the helpful messages within it.
After listening to the audiobook, I also watched a movie called "Walk-In" which was based on the book. Interestingly, the movie leaves out most of the important messages I feel the book strives to convey and was more unsatisfactory than the book in its content, though the acting in the movie was far superior to the narration of the book.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.