It would not be my goal to criticize this work. It is a story that needs to be told and that we probably haven't heard well enough, having been on the other side. But in the end it is too much for me. At some point the story and informational value add versus the shock and grotesque balance went awry. I had to stop.
Taibbi does his work, and he doesn't really hold back from criticizing anyone if he feels it is justified. Have to give him credit on this front. And the book overall does a very good job of broadening perspectives. I read it just pre-Ferguson. Dang.
It is top 10% experience. The only reason I didn't want to listen to it at times was because it was so real, and so poignant that it would burn you out a bit.
The political operative who characterized the auto execs while asking for federal subsidies. For being so spot on.
It's a pretty sad and disturbing book. But it also has hope. And it is very real. This is the world we live in, whether we "see" it or not.
Charlie LeDuff should be commended, for the effort he has put back into his community. And for his very basic, down to earth tell it like it is effort. In a weird way, there is one big agenda here, but it isn't any of the agendas that so often dominate our world of discourse today. It is one rooted in realities, and trying to get some, any, concrete results.
I really looked forward to this. And there are some good parts, leading to introspection and deeper thought. But in some unfortunate convergence of story and narration the result is quite annoying. The voices make me cringe. The characters in the dialogs are horrible. And the overall impression is kinda of well, just downright annoying. Preachy, trite, a bit silly. It is in the end, perhaps just too patronizing. Like the author and/or narrator is "talking down" to the listener.
Probably not, but can't say for sure.
Not so sure about that. I have developed a pretty bad association at this point with some of the voices in this book.
Yes, the subject matter is potentially interesting, the context is a great idea, and at times it does deliver. It stretches you to think a little more about both yourself, the world around you and your reaction to it. But you pay a high price to get there, too high.
Don't talk down to your audience!
Yes, good for driving or a summer read. Not a deep work.
Venkat, the realities of being an administrator
Read cleanly, but some of the voices did make me cringe a bit, particularly of women.
This is NOT a masterpiece. It is entertaining comic book sci fi adventure done well. It's fun. But some of the characters, and some of the situations and inter-personal stuff made me cringe, as being a little trite or thin, or worse implausible.
Great performance, great story, entertaining. Sure it was a little cute, but very good. This isn't a story about a dog, it is a story about life. Good characters, believable real world stuff. Insights and observations we all know and share, but packaged and delivered in very entertaining and enjoyable story. Great perspective.
There are a number, mostly revolving around the triumphs or critical turning points. Enzo out the window is one. Outside the courtroom is another. The walk to the funeral.
Why Enzo of course!
Highly recommend this book. Loved it!
No. My impression is his perceptions are thin, and he is captive to a world view / cultural identity (liberal) which blinds him for truly perceptive and creative work. Nothing wrong with the identity, but the author needs to move beyond it's limitations if he is going to offer anything really interesting, inspiring or creative. Section 3 was so trite I wanted to scream.
No, my assumption is this author is just limited in his abilities.
This was multi-narrator book. They all do a very good job.
The entire 3rd segment is insipid and thin. It relies on superficial tropes about corporate conspiracy and evil doing that is unbelievable. I couldn't bear it. Don't just give me a rehash construct of cultural war perspectives. Give me something that is truly observant of our world, of life, of human nature and of people. I can do with out the superficial rehash of the liberal culture war. It isn't the fact that it is liberal. I would be just as harsh on such a silly effort by someone captive to the conservative agenda. It isn't what I read fiction for. I get enough of this garbage in the news and general media, don't want it
One of the more disappointing titles I have ever experienced from Audible. Some others have been a little flat or boring, had other limits. But given the reviews for this I expected a lot more. Note sure why people think this one is particularly interesting. Found it quite shallow, predictable, and thin.
As much sympathy, empathy and respect I have for anyone and everyone who has served, this book really annoyed me. The author accomplishes little over the first half but to firmly establish he has no intention of doing real research or approaching the questions of what happened objectively. This is a re-hash of a well worn narrative, that at center blames G W Bush for everything from hang nails to global warming and the war on terror. I certainly am not out to defend Bush, but it is oh so intellectually tiring to revisit these old saws.
Worse, there is something continuously grating and ultimately ironically disturbing about the authors attempt to set Pat Tillman up as a "hero". In the end, we all have qualities to admire. All of us make mistakes. A few make the ultimate sacrifice. It is disappointing that this book is just another shallow contribution to our already shallow cultural obsession with the "soma" that are the NFL and Hollywood celebrity worship in the first place. The thesis is that the Bush administration has committed yet another terrible wrong by highjacking Pat's celebrity. In the end this book is no better. I end up not wanting to even hear about Pat Tillman at all anymore. What must it be like for those that give in obscurity, those that don't get a big break from the juvenile judge and whose life doesn't turn out they way it could have? There is just something silly with the whole premise. It sure isn't Pat's fault. And I have enormous sympathy for his loss. But if we are ever going to truly "move on" we need to get beyond the nonsense that is "celebrity hero worship", in whatever it's form.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.