The history behind the novel is quite interesting. The narration is irritating, to say the least
I didn't listen to other Herman Wouk books.
The narration is just too fast and the tone used, most of the times, sounds almost frivolous. I really disliked it.
Good story, ruined by the worst narration I have heard.
Well, in what regards to books, this is a rather average one. Not a great story, written in a very dry style, that even managed to describe the raid on Bin Laden's house in a very non thrilling way. I think this book doesn't bring much novelty in any of the different areas it covered - SEAL training, SEAL missions and the mission to get Bin Laden. Manhunt, from Peter Bergen, ends up being much better written, even if one detail or another is missing - of course, the first hand experience of a SEAL that was in the crashing chopper couldn't really be told but by someone who had experienced it.
I have read or listened to multiple books on special ops and this is clearly one of the worst. Chuck Pfarrer's Warrior Soul or Malcom MacPherson's Roberts Ridge are much better accounts of SEAL training or SEAL sacrifice. Robert L.Haney's Inside Delta Force is a much better book on the life of a special force's operator.
I ended up asking myself what did this book bring that I hadn't read before. Other than some minor personal details, it really does not bring anything you cannot find better told elsewhere. For those really interested on mission Neptune Spear, Manhunt is the book to read.
Considering the negative reactions of fellow SEALs to this book, I wonder if it had any reason to be written. The author claims the goal was to set the record straight. I really couldn't find any serious divergences when compared with the account from Peter Bergen's book, so I really don't think it achieves that purpose, either. Maybe the goal was to write that final chapter where the Obama's administration politicization of a military op is really criticized. While I cannot blame the author for doing it, frankly, there was no reason to write a whole book to achieve that.
No, the narrator makes it impossible to enjoy the story. He totally lacks a proper sense of
Same as before.
Lou Diamond Philips was great (my first audiobook) as well as Sean Pratt. I could almost say anyone but Pariseau, he is that bad.
Report Inappropriate Content