This seems to have been almost written by a different author. Sharpe seems soft, expresses more emotions, and is different from the hard, calloused man we read about in the first books. The story was still OK, though, and moved along well. Overall, this receives an OK from me.
Really liked this story. As usual, Brandon Sanderson weaves an intricate story that make the characters seem so real. My only complaint is that it was so long and I was starting to tire from the whole story.
Pretty good story and the main character is so real with emotions. But the action parts seem very run-of-the-mill action scenes: good guys are outnumbered, short on ammo (supposedly, but they seem to always have some at hand), and are about to be overwhelmed when someone saves them/they manage to defeat all of the threats.
This was a change of pace from the normal Sharpe books as it takes place on the seas in a warship. I really enjoyed the fleet battle. But the side story of Sharpe's affair with Lady Grace and the trouble between her husband, Lord Hale, is distracting. Also, I didn't really like the hero-worshiping over Lord Nelson.
I don't like the main character's name, Honor Harrington. Good book even though the main character seems more of a robot than a human. It does try to give her emotions but they are very lame attempts. The plot is good and the story moves along pretty well, but sometimes seems to drag. I think I'll try another Honor Harrington book.
This story was pretty good, but the descriptions of Sharpe's emotions and the mistakes he makes as he adjusts to leadership was a curve-ball for me and something I didn't really like. In the early books, there are not much written about his emotions. And in the books after this one, these emotions/mistakes are dropped. Sharpe always seemed to know what to do in every circumstance, but in this book he often doesn't know what to do.
Not as good as the first book in the series, but it was a good follow-up to it. The characters' personality and etc. are not detailed as was in the first book, but I guess they don't have to as there are only a few new characters. I loved the space battles descriptions; they feel more real than any other SF story. However, the love relationship between "Black Jack" and "Madame Co President" feels forced, like it was added later. Another thing that I didn't care for is the first book seemed to go on for a long time while this book seemed short and abrupt.
Much better than the last "new" Sharpe book, "Sharpe's Prey" that Mr. Cornwell wrote after finishing the series. Overall, this is just another Sharpe adventure; bloody battles, wealthy enemies on his same side, and a damsel in distress. Still, it is a good read and the story flows well.
Great follow-up book to the first one. It kept me hooked until the end and then I couldn't believe the book was finished; I wanted more. Can't wait to read the next one in the series.
Just wish that the story followed Mazer Rackham and the MOPS team more and Victor and Lem less.
The story line, in my opinion, doesn't fit the title. The event in the story that the title comes from doesn't happen until the very end. I was so disappointed that it was more a story about a rich brat in the military than an actual story about a mutineer on a spaceship. Also the audiobook performance by Dina Pearlman, was very bad. Many of the characters are male, so why not have a guy do the performance? Instead, you end up with many of the male characters with the same voice. Maybe I'll try the normal book version of the next book in a few years.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.