I would give the story five stars because it's a classic (and I listened to "Bobbed Hair and Bathtub Gin" right before this - which I highly recommend) but Tim Robbins' reading nearly drove me insane! His reading of the male dialogue was fine, but he insisted on reading the female dialoge in a whining Southern drawl which made the women sound like drag queens. I found it extremely annoying. I see that everyone else enjoyed his reading very much...just wanted to mention that it may not be everyone's cup of tea.
I rarely listen to fiction and I never listen to science fiction. I got this book because of a review in the Wall Street Journal. I was captivated from page one and had tears rolling down my cheeks twice before the end. I LOVED this book! Now and again I'd get lost in some technical details but it didn't matter, I just listened on through, eventually it would all make sense. Do yourself a favor and Google how this book came to be published. That in itself is another wonderful story!
Such an unusual reader. His voice and style are perfectly matched to this most wonderful story. This was my end of the day book, I listened to it while brushing my old cat before going to bed. I was transported to another world, completely lost in the story. It's so unusual to be captured in this way when there is no mystery or murder! I couldn't wait to get back to it and was sorry when I reached the end. Now I'm about to look through the rest of Peter Altschuler's readings...
easy good fun
Not on the edge of my seat, but I was always happy to return to this book.
He is one of those readers (Timothy West is another) who manages to bring the characters to vivid life. I actually think I would have missed a great deal if I had read the book!
Real Eye Opener!
This book is fascinating if you studied film in the '70's or are a film buff. We idolized these guys, analyzed their movies with great seriousness, intently picked apart all the details, wrote papers on them...hearing the back story here completely floored me. All these guys are people just like us, only they were given free reign to go berserk professionally, financially and many times personally. I adored this book, I laughed out loud all the way through it. An amazing bunch of guys (and a few of the wives and girlfriends stand out too), they made movies I've never stopped loving, but this book did me a favor and brought them out of my college days' perceived god status of them and brought them down to earth.
Yes, just as good. He is only suited for a certain type of book and this is definitely one of them!
Way too long to do that but I HATED to finally reach the end. In theory, yes.
I wasn't thrilled with the reading. Except in very rare cases, I prefer that men don't go to great ends to sound like women and vice versa, This reader's renditions of the more eccentric masculine characters sound kind of ridiculous. On the other hand, when she is simply reading, her voice is perfect for the story and the mood of the book, which I very much enjoyed.
I'm giving this a high rating because I think the story is wonderful. I did however have a terrible time getting used to the insane use of "other voices" for the women and the main character as a child. Absolutely horrible!! A straightforward reading by this narrator would have been fine, he is a very good reader. There was no need for this ridiculous idea of creating some kind of theatre. As one reader mentioned, the women all come across as spineless simps whether they are noble or not. Such a shame for such a long and wonderful book!
Really interesting to hear because more than half of the people profiled are not the most well known cases. Kind of horrifying, as well, as these people are held high as role models by many because of what they say (and not because of what they do...).
A beautifully written book and read perfectly by
John Lee. Of the many, many books I have listened to, this is up at the top (along with The Forsyth Saga).
This book's characters just jump out of the narration, it's absolutely wonderful. James' understanding of a certain female character is uncanny. I adored this book and was so sorry when it ended!
It took me a while to get into this book, it is relentlessly grim - BUT the four main characters eventually steal your heart. After I finished the book, it took me days before I shook off it's sad mood. The book is also an interesting window on India's upheavals in the 70's. The writing is so vivid, often you feel you are right there with the characters. A fantastic book.
Report Inappropriate Content