Member Since 2010
Oh wow, I really didn't like this. What a depressing and pointless book. Not that sci-fi books are obliged to be hilariously entertaining at all times but pointlessness is inexcusable. There was no character development. Even if I strongly disliked the main idea of the book (the end of days of mankind is boring, I think) I would still have been interested in seeing the emotional turmoil of the Overlords explored. Their's must be a loneliness worth a thousand books, and all they got were a few hurried sentences.
For most of this book, Kaladin is an arrogant, ignorant, selfish racist. Stubborn to the point of stupidity. He is therefore highly unsympathetic as a character here. I get that that was supposed to be a character development arc, but he stayed an arrogant ignorant racist for too long (more precisely, for 44 out of the 48 hours of the book!!), in spite of numerous evidence that he was wrong. When he finally, and predictably, came to his senses I couldn't grasp WHY he changed his mind, since none of the evidence and the pleading of the various characters had managed to convince him for the duration of the book. I further don't understand why, after having been unworthy for 44 hours, the simple act of him changing his mind instantaneously made him worthy again, and it somehow washed away all the crap he was guilty of for the first 44 hours of the book. I mean, how do the spren know that he won't change his mind again in a day or two? Why trust him instantaneously after he behaved like a moron for almost the entire book? In the Way of Kings I was totally buying it, the bond with the spren made perfect sense because he showed a perseverance, an amazing but believable strength of character, an inherent nobility and goodness. So, of course the honor spren would trust him and bond with him. This second book completely ruined that carefully motivated bond.
I'm not really interested in reading the continuation of the series. Things just stopped making sense in this book. It's also way too long, but that's subjective and only true because seeing Kaladin descend from being the coolest and favorite character to a character that made me cringe every time he rattled on about lighteyes was actually **painful** and that made the book seem way, way too long.
Absolutely fantastic performances by Michael Kramer and Kate Reading, as always. These two are simply unbelievable.
I started listening to this book literally within a minute of having finished Tarnished Knight, and the transition is not smooth. After having the last book end on a certain note, with a certain situation and a certain conversation taking place, this book begins as if that didn't just happen, as if that conversation never took place and none of the important things were ever said, which felt rather weird. If I had known I would have given myself time to forget the last conversation of Tarnished Knight before stating this book.
But nevermind that, it's a good, interesting book. It even made me laugh out loud once. I listened to all of it in a day and a half.
One serious complaint though. There is a twist at the end of this book. A twist that belongs in a soap opera, not *space* opera. It is the very nature of a soap opera that most of the drama in it is due to for example unanswered feelings/inconvenient romance/unfaithfulness/unwanted pregnancy/children outside of wedlock/bla bla bla bla, and that is NOT what I want to read.
Consequently I absolutely hated the way this book ended. It was further more unnecessary because there were numerous other things that could have served as quite effective cliff-hangers, things that have nothing to do with who slept with whom and why; things that instead deal with what the book was actually about - like fleets, and shipyards, and getting trained personel, and dealing with traitors, and maturing as a leader, and and and - all of this is awesome and is what I bought the book for. So I am very surprised that the author decided to finish with ...this. If this is indicative of things to come, I will not be buying the next book. Damn it, I was enjoying the story thoroughly before that last unfortunate hour. But if there was ever a sudden twist in a story designed to ensure I won't be sticking around for the conclusion, this was it. It was just that stupid.
The story was simple but fun! Get stranded on Mars and try to survive? Yes, please! I was impressed by how every time you think, well, ok, *now* it will get predictable, the author made some other unexpected disaster occur. It kept the plot interesting, to say the least. And the problems that the hero had to face were actually pretty scary, almost all of them had me thinking that this is it, he can't fix this, it's over. And then I was worried each time that the solution to the problem will turn out to be unbelievable or that a detailed explanation of it will be skipped because the problem is just too big! In other words I was afraid magic will happen :) But it never did, thankfully. The author created big problems, but then managed to solve them in a believable way, step by step. And I couldn't see it coming either, meaning I couldn't guess in advance what the solutions would be.
Oh and this book is also funny. Not just the main character, but other characters, too, have some fantastic laugh-out-loud thoughts and replies. Though it did make me look deranged in the subway :( and people looked at me funny.
Narration is good. Narrator reads the funny parts in just the right way to preserve the funny. Even to enhance it.
Actually, I imagine the story in this book most likely describes some of the things the people we'll be sending to Mars in the Mars One project in 2023 will have to deal with. So, those people should read this carefully! Several times! :)
This is a very poor effort. I cannot believe it got published, and I wish I had actually *read* some reviews of this book before buying it. Instead I just went with the star rating it has which seemed decently high. I don't understand how the rating can be so high, I gave it one star only because I couldn't give it negative stars, it's *that* bad.
This book is full of literally stupid characters and so many cliches it's not even funny. The storytelling style is naive and simplistic, as if this was written for children. The characters are flat, uninteresting, stereotypical, completely unbelievable and one dimensional. They're either exaggeratedly good or exaggeratedly bad. Like I said - simplistic. But most of all it's really irritating how incredibly stupid they are. This makes the story incomprehensible at times.
The narration doesn't help. I will avoid this narrator in the future at all cost. He's horrible. He's whining, melodramatic, and completely inadequate.
If I could play editor I wouldn't release this book at all. Or at least I'd target a very young audience. This book is below the average adult. I have no problem with the book not having a true ending because there's no way I will subject myself to listening to the rest of this crap. I listened to 3 hours and I can't take it anymore. Enough.
Save your credit for something else.
Well, the narration is bothering me so much that I don't know if I can finish the book. The narrator reads with a totally weird rhythm. She hurries through most of a long sentence only to make a totally unnecessary and weird pause in the middle of nowhere. I assume it's because she ran out of breath. Or, she'll start with a weird dramatic pause but the rest of the sentence then shows that all the drama was for naught. Example: "The man [pause pause pause] tipped his hat and spat on the ground". Eh?? Why pause dramatically before a hat tipping???!!!! And then there's weird emphasis on words that don't merit emphasis in a sentence that doesn't merit emphasis either. Example: "I tried [pause] with ALL my might and then a door [pause pause] OPENED in my mind". Ok, a door opened, big deal!! I'm so frustrated with this, it's very exhausting to listen to because the narrator essentially misleads me all the time. I don't know if I'm explaining this very well.
about the plot, I read reviews by men who complain about how all the men in the book are evil and get slaughtered by the women over and over. Also some guy complained that the sex scenes are gratuitous and intended for lesbians only. I don't understand why he would think that, I'm on hour 6 and there was one dream/memory where the sex was described in exactly 1 single, not overly long sentence. Exactly one, I counted very carefully. Maybe the remaining hours of the book will be filled with meaningless gratuitous lesbian sex, but so far there's no such thing. One thing that is kind of taxing is how often the men's disrespect for the women is described, over and over, it does feel like the authors are trying to bias the reader to sympathize with the women, but it feels a bit overdone because it's very noticeable. I feel like I'm being lectured.
I give it 3 stars because I'm ignoring the narration. Otherwise the narration would bring this down to 1 star.
well, i thought it was a mediocre book. It is well-written in the sense that every now and then there are some fantastic lines delivered at the right time by the right character. But the female characters are all completely boring and wooden and unreal and did I mention boring?? And you can't have a great male character being madly in love with a boring female character because then there's something wrong with the male character. So, if they're in love they should be equally exciting and fabulous, even when they're on the opposite ends of good and evil. Exciting intoxicating people are attracted to exciting intoxicating people, it doesn't make sense otherwise. That's my biggest problem with this book. Dana was...I can't even remember what she was cause she was so bland and uninteresting.
I only bought this because somebody reviewed it as "the only other fantasy book this year I enjoyed more than Mistborn". But this book is lightyears away from the quality and depth of story and character development that you have in Mistborn. Maybe if I wasn't expecting Mistborn-quality book I would have enjoyed this more....but nah, not with it being full of boring uninteresting bland female characters.
Also, I don't know what makes it so, but after 14 hours of listening to this book one still has the feeling that nothing has happened yet. Weird. Many books can be summarized this way, that nothing of great import has really happened, but they are still enjoyable and fun to listen to. Not this book, for some reason. I don't care about it enough to analyze why that is.
I also had problems with the narrator. I don't understand why half of his voices have to sound Russian. ?? it threw me off, I found it not suitable for a fantasy setting.
I'm giving it 1 star. I would give it 2 stars if it wasn't for the weird and totally unmotivated presence of so many Russians in this narration.
Very nice series, good narration, interesting plot. I recommend this. The very end of the very last book (Victorious) felt a bit rushed but it was still good. I gave it only 3 stars because I wasn't happy with any of the female characters in the books. Dauntless' captain Tanya D. was increasingly unbelievable as a character, too perfect, too holier than thou, and at the end she was essentially continuously disrespecting her commanding officer by yelling at him, lecturing him, speaking to him with sarcasm, etc. I didn't quite understand why that was allowed. So, the female characters were a disappointment, hence -2 stars, but the male characters were fantastic and the plot was superb.
I can't recommend the book for the story itself. Or for the narration. But it's not a total disaster.
PLOT: A small group of people preparing to flee a dying Earth(part 1) and fleeing a dying Earth (part 2). This includes the miserable fate of those left behind, riots, panic, the still advancing sea, and such stuff. Oh, and there was a speck of nazi-style gasing of unsuspecting elderly people by the military, on purpose and in a very systematic way, but for the life of me I couldn't understand what the point was with that. The gasing was not an emotional response done by confused and scared people, it was methodical, ordered, "our heavy duty but necessary last measure" kind of thing. So I don't get it.
OPINION: Unrealistic plotline when it comes to the Ark ship and project. The disaster on earth from the flood was on the other hand quite realistic. Inventing FTL drives in just a decade or two was also completely unbelievable. All characters were flat and uninteresting, at least to me. I listened mostly because I wanted to see how greatly the Ark would fail once it gets to the new planet and everybody dies from an alien virus or something. Which didn't happen.
NARRATION: Yeah, not so good. There's some supposedly Scottish accents, they all sound horrible. E.g. Holle Groundwater's accent makes her sound like she's deranged, not Scottish. And that becomes increasingly annoying the more you listen to it. Otherwise it's ok.
I don't understand why this book had to be that long. If you read the brief book description by audible then you know essentially *all* highlights and the rest of the book just turns out to be bland and boring with endless descriptions and numerous new characters introduced every 2-3 hours. It gets more interesting around hour 30 but you'd have to be very determined to get there. I won't be buying the sequel, I can't take another 40 hours of this.
This story caught NASA's attention? Really? Why, did they laugh out loud in front of the press? It's a pleasant idea, there's no great trauma or suffering in the book and it presents a very optimistic view of our awaiting future. But it's just too perfect, there was no significant effort, or sacrifice, and hence no depth to any of the characters. Carefree people usually grin like idiots and roll their thumbs, they do not come up with deep meaningful thoughts, they do not perform awe-striking deeds that leave you wanting more. That goes for this book too. It's mellow. It's like a children's tale. I only bought this book because it said it caught NASA's attention. I'm sorry now.
Report Inappropriate Content