Sherwood, OR, United States | Member Since 2005
It was an interesting world with some good characters. I felt that some of the key characters weren't that deep or engaging but it still made for good time.
I'd watched the HBO series "Band of Brothers" so I was already familiar Easy Company and Major Dick Winters. I'd recommend that you watch that first but even if you don't this is still a great book.
Major Winters was the rarest of men. He hails from a time where service to country was viewed differently. The book is worth listening to just to experience that different perspective but it is so much more than that.
This is one of my most often recommended audio books.
Do yourself a favor and pick this up, you'll enjoy it and be better for the experience.
I first read this book when it came out and put it on my list of favorite fantasy novels. I then took a 10 year break from fantasy and on a whim I picked up the audio book. I was so enthralled with the story that I couldn't wait to pick up the next audio book (though I'd read it when it was first published).
Narrators - This deserves its own section. Michael Kramer and Kate Reading are outstanding. I've come to view them as the best performers in the audio book arena today. I've gone so far as to search for other books by Michael Kramer because I know he always delivers an amazing performance.
I do want to warn you - this book is the beginning of a very long series and not all the books are as good as this one. That being said, you don't have to commit to the whole series. This book stands alone as a great story.
If you're a fan of fantasy you should absolutely pick this up. You won't be disappointed. I don't know any fantasy reader who hasn't been thrilled with this book.
I've been working in software for well over 15 years and this book contains so many fundamental principles in delivering a quality product that I recommended to my entire team. I'm a product manager in ecommerce at the number one sportswear company in the world and everyone I've convinced to read or listen to this book has had a similar reaction.
If you are involved with (or want to be) delivering software products you should make this an essential part of your business book library. I insist that all my direct reports listen or read this book.
Let's start with the narration. Michael Kramer is one of my all time favorite performers and one of the two narrators that I search for on Audible when looking for new titles. I have yet to listen to a novel that he's narrated that wasn't an outstanding performance. This is no exception.
I finished the other Mistborn books about a year ago and wasn't ready to start another story in that world. While I loved the series I needed a tale that took place in a world that wasn't so depressing. As it turns out I should have continued with this tale because it lacks that oppressiveness that I found so fatiguing in the first Mistborn books.
This is a good tale and I recommend it. The main characters are likable and I found myself laughing at the corny humor.
If you haven't listened to the other Mistborn books I urge you to take those up first. I think this story would be a bit flat without the background of the earlier works.
This could be the beginning of another series in the Mistborn world but even if another Mistborn book is never written this serves as a nice ending to the series.
I'd just completed "Fireblood: Whispers from Mirrowen" and had fairly low expectations when beginning this novel. I was pleasantly surprised. It is hard to believe that they are written by the same author. This story was so much better than Fireblood. The narrator was better as well.
I found I could empathize with the main character Lia. I celebrated her victories and lamented her defeats. It was such a stark contrast from Fireblood where I didn't really care if any of the main characters lived or died. They were all a rather unsavory bunch.
That being said you can tell that writing is not Jeff Wheeler's day job. That doesn't diminish from my enjoyment but you can tell his writing lacks the depth and polish you would find from a fantasy author who makes his living as a writer. I suspect Mr. Wheeler will get there someday if he keeps writing and I would encourage him to do just that.
If you're looking for something polished or an epic fantasy this isn't it. If you want a solid story with a likable main character I'd recommend you pick this up.
I originally read this book when I was in high school and found it just as enjoyable then. I liked the different magic system that L.E. Modesitt Jr. envisioned and worked out. The only thing that kept this from being a 5/5 performance was the very distracting sound effects the narrator produced. They could have been mitigated by good editing but when listening to this on my phone the effects were very loud and distracting. I came to dread them throughout the book.
All in all I enjoyed the experience and would recommend this as a good novel.
I have to admit that about half way through the audio book I was ready to quit and move on to something else. The story felt like it had the depth of a series of short stories and not the rich character development you see in contemporary fantasy epics. That being said I found the second half of the book to be far more enjoyable. There are lots of fantasy novels I'd recommend before this one but I would say it was a good early attempt by an author who makes his living doing something else. I have great hopes for Jeff Wheeler that as he continues to improve his craft the world / character depth that is the hallmark of fantasy will find its way into his stories.
Reasons to purchase:
• The story is faithful to what you see in other contemporary fantasy and is enjoyable as a whole
• The author appears to get better as the story goes so I have hopes that his next novel will be even better
Reasons to avoid:
• I found the narrator's performance to be a distraction. He wasn't terrible, just not someone I'd like to hear again if possible. I'm a little spoiled since I've listened to some great narrators so listening to Mr. Page wasn't as enjoyable as it might have been.
• Some of the scenes were awkward and could have used more editing. A good story at the core but a few areas could have been improved greatly with more editing.
If you're searching for an epic to fall in love with, this isn't the one. If you're looking for a generally good time without high expectations you'll be pleased.
I selected this audio book because I'm a fan of Michael Kramer (the narrator). As always, he does an amazing job. The story itself was good but not great. It seemed to lack depth as if background information about the characters had been edited out. I enjoyed the book but not enough to pick up the second book in this series.
This was the first fantasy I read while growing up. It got me hooked on the genre. I just wish that other authors created main characters that were as likable as Paks. My only disappointment was that I felt the narrator didn't quite do the story justice. By the third book she'd grown on me but I didn't care for her rendition of one of my all time favorite fantasy epics. This is a classic story where the distinction between good and evil is clear and consistent.
A dark story that had characters that we're nearly impossible to identify with making it so disappointing that it leaves one rather depressed. I can't recommend the story or the narrator. It wasn't terrible so I gave it two stars.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.