How does a hidden history in our family affect the life we live. What do the secrets do to us, unbidden. Sebastian Barry writes beautifully, poignantly and with a depth that, in the end made me put my hand to my mouth to supress the gasp as the secrets are unravelled and the truth is finally revealed. There is 100 years of Irish history in this novel, seen through the eyes of Rosanne as she writes down what has never been told of her life. Then there is Dr Green, Rosanne's psychiatrist, who is trying to unwrap her silence gently, respectfully and with dignity.
I am deeply moved by this book and give thanks to Stephen Hogan for giving a voice to both Rosanne and Dr Green. His narration could not have been better and as I listened, his voice became my own voice as the story evolved and stirred the tragedy of Rosanne and of those who had pulled the strings of her life.
It was lovely to meet the imaginary characters in this light and enjoyable fantasy, especially when they are placed in my favourite time period. I would have loved to work beside Maya and admire her strength of character and determination.
This is a wonderful insight into the brilliance of a man able to imagine things well before his time. The way he combines his knowledge of the natural world and invent the life preserving world that makes up the mysterious island shows a genius that is well worth listening to.
I had high hopes for this story, thinking it might underscore our obsession with appearance and then pull the rug out from under it. All it did was show how it doesn't matter what happens, appearances rule (for some unfortunates) . The narration was so over articulated I thought I was in pre-school. Sorry ... A total disappointment
Having read this book 5 or more years ago, I was tentative about listening to it, much in the same way that seeing a movie of a book you've read can often disappoint. Humphrey Bower saved me from that kind of despair ... Thanks Mr Bower.
I have not travelled to India but now feel I can taste, smell, hear and see this most fascinating and diverse culture. The depth of feeling and the complexity of the myriad of characters in this novel are compelling and engaging. This personal journey's, unravelling in experiences of great fortune and desperate despair, connected me to Lin Ba Ba's world and at times, he felt like a brother having a deep and meaningful conversation with me.
The story is unbelievable. There are people I know who say it is highly exaggerated, some who say it's all true. It seems unbelievable to me, but in a deeply moving way. This is a man who tries to face himself, tries to see, to forgive and to change. Despite all his crimes, all the responsibility he abandoned, I admired his courage, insights and philosophical reflections on the world, on humanity and what it means to be free.
This is a time filler listen. Good for listening on the go when you don't need to be immersed in the world of words and fully focused in a deep and consuming story. I'm lost for words of praise because, although I enjoyed most of the stories, none stood out and grabbed my attention.
Janis Ian's voice does deserve a mention - soft, strong and deliberate -,it's always a pleasure to hear.
As an Australian, far removed in distance from the horrors of 'Katrina', but close because of television and news media, I wanted to hear this story. Especially because I'm a Registered Nurse, the fact that the scene reported what happened in a hospital, stirred my interest further.
The propensity to litigate is something that I have been sad to see grow in Australia over the past few decades. It is something I've always regarded as 'American' and I found it difficult to listen to the hours of dialogue that related the seemingly infinite ways individuals, companies and corporations sue, counter sue, wriggle and squirm to avoid basic responsibilities and accept the vagaries of life without the need to feed media and lawyers vast sums of money stretching and distorting facts, omitting details, and generally bludgeoning society with half truths and more.
The detail in this book is magnificently detailed. The balanced view cannot be faulted. The horror for those involved is clear. That wrongs were committed - well - I'm not sure. How can any of us judge how we might behave in such a situation. Not only during 'Katrina' but in the life we would then have to lead afterwards.
My husband died 13 years ago, of an aggressive cancer, that removed his quality of life from the day he was diagnosed until the day he died 9 months later. In his last month of life, he woke up every morning crying, begging me to kill him. He would have taken his own life if he had been able. Despite the fact that his eventual death has left a hole in my life that nothing will ever replace, I would have been willing to make his journey toward his inevitable end more expedient had it been legally possible. We afford our pets such respect.
There can be no legal judgement about such matters. Compassion and kindness in the face of suffering are the only two things that really matter and if there is a god, I believe he would agree.
Corporations should not be permitted to manage health facilities. The incongruities that exist in their basic functioning a re not compatible and will inevitably lead to more situations like 'Memorial' if it is allowed to continue.
This is quite a beautiful story, imagined in the cold of the far, far north. You can feel the climate, the extremes of weather, of temperament, of love and loss, of being lost. You can see the beauty of the environment and feel placed there with the characters, some emerging from the ice of their past, some content with the raw pace of surviving.
And the child, she is beautiful, foreign, mysterious and elusive.
But I felt let down by this book, the ending felt contrived, as if the ideas were cut short at their birth and the child leaves the story deflated like a balloon loosing all it's air as soon as it reaches it's capacity. There could have been so much more....
Exquisite story, rich in depth of characters, beauty of human connection and the intensity of soul. I found it difficult to sleep while there were still words to hear of this novel. Thank you Donna Tartt...your work reflected a world both familiar and foreign and will remain with me, like the Goldfinch did to the characters who loved it's timeless beauty.
I love being transported back into earlier centuries and 'The Signature of All Things' did this expertly. I found the story rich and exciting, epic in proportions and fascinating. At one stage I thought that Elizabeth Gilbert must have studied botany herself, so detailed is the information about plants. And to then place all that information in another century shows her skill as a storyteller. Ugly Alma is a wonderful heroine and many of her ponderings about life, love and the universe have been my own, making her even more likeable as a character.
My reason for only giving the story 3 stars is that I found the last third of the book somewhat tedious and slow, despite the fact that many issues are resolved here.
All in all, though, I enjoyed this book thoroughly.
I downloaded this story simply because of the title"Brown Dog". Call me crazy but by the time I finished listening to the story of the hapless, hopeless, gentle, unaffected man, I was in love. Such a wonderful depiction of North American wilderness added immensely to this sometimes very funny, sometimes excruciatingly poignant story. Some overtly 'scenic' reflections of BD's sex life made me laugh out loud and/or cry.
What a deeply "human" man, is Brown Dog.
Report Inappropriate Content