I really enjoy the “alphabet series”; the books are a guaranteed hit for me every time. I love Sue Grafton’s writing style; her dry wit and sarcasm are great! but I am not so sure the short-story format is the best for murder mysteries. It felt like Kinsey was solving a new murder everyday … it was too fast, too quick, too unrealistic (yes I know its fiction).
As for the “Me” section, it didn't do much for me. No disrespect intended because I know these are very personal stories for Sue – but they didn't hold my interest.
I can’t wait for “W” to come out!
I liked this story and I like this style of cop-drama (more psychological mystery-thriller, less maniacal serial-killer blood-lust) but I still had a few issues with the book:
•Not enough exposition regarding the reoccurring characters - the “Simon & Charlie” storyline.
This series was recommended to me by a friend, and when I saw that Books 1 & 2 (Little Face & Hurting Distance) were not available on Audible, I asked her if I could start with Book 3. She said yes so I dove in not knowing anything about it. If you are wondering whether you can start with Book 3, I would say no. I felt lost regarding their arc and had no real idea what their story was all about. I read the synopsis of the first 2 books to try and fill in the blanks but it was not that helpful.
•I SUCK AT NAMES!
If like me you have a hard time keeping names in stories straight, I urge you to pay extremely close attention because the plot centers around false identities & fake names... very difficult for me!
Aside from that, I think I will like this series. The mysteries seem very interesting... enough to keep going for now at least.
I really like this Liane Moriarty, this is the 4th book I have read and they have all been great so far (Little Big Lies, The Husband’s Secret and What Alice Forgot). This one was no exception, even thought I was never really sure what the point was.
It was a glimpse into the lives of 3 women – their ups and downs, husbands, babies, neurosis… the soap opera of life!
It was all very entertaining but it sort of lacked a beginning a middle and an ending. Still, it didn’t take away from the enjoyment; it was a fun story and I am looking forward to the next one!
In my opinion, Robert Sawyer is terrific. Every book is a hit every time.
This time however, I have a lot to complain about – but it’s not directed at Sawyer, it’s regarding the narration. Absolutely the WORST interpretation of a French Canadian accent I have ever heard. Hands down.
I live in Montreal, I do speak French, I am surrounded on a daily basis with French Canadians speaking English. This guy obviously never set foot in Quebec! His accent is so comically bad that it’s doing this otherwise compelling story a huge disservice. Really, it’s distractingly bad. (At the risk of being perceived as a lunatic, I even wrote to Robert Sawyer about it in case he has some sort of creative control over these things for future books).
French Canadians ‘tok da en-glish like diss’. I promise you ‘Zay do not zound lika zizz’ ... (if you will allow me a tangent, they don’t speak English, they talk English. They don’t make decisions, they take decisions. They don’t turn off the light, they close the light. But those details are not related to their accent, and I can understand how Sawyer would not want to include a lot of phraseology that only a small percentage of readers would understand)
If you aren’t Canadian or if you just don’t know what a Quebecois accent sounds like then you probably weren’t distracted. If like me, you are Quebecois – then you were annoyed and irritated the entire way through.
When a French Canadian speaks English, The = da. This = Diss. They drop Hs when they should be there, and add them where they shouldn’t be, for example:
I am happy to see you = “I am appy to see you”
How are you = “Ow are you”
It’s so hot outside = “It’s so ott hhoutside”
Happy Birthday = “Appy Birdday”
Can I ask you a question = “Can I hhask you a question”
That guy always thinks he’s right = “Dat guy hhalways tinks ee is right”
Is that her book over there = “is dat err book hhoe-verr derr”
I won’t even get into examples of how they put the emphasis on the wrong syllable, more towards the end of the word – naturally where it would be in French.
All this to say, the story was excellent but the narration disappointed me immensely.
I’m an early bird, and therefore I’m usually in bed by 9PM – sometimes earlier. The fact that was I was up until 11PM finishing the book should give you a pretty good indication of how into it I was!!
It’s so satisfying to get your hands on a good book and being so immersed by the story that you devour it in just a few sittings (would have been one if I didn’t have to work!)
The book had me on the edge of my seat, constantly wondering where it was going and what would happen next. It was gripping, enthralling and suspenseful; a great riveting thriller!!!
This was the perfect book for my mood. After plodding though “Crime and Punishment”, I needed a light pick me up and this collection of comical essays did the trick!
Regarding the performance, just like in “When You Are Engulfed In Flames” the laughs in the live-stand-up-speeches are BEYOND irritating.
How can you rate-evaluate-criticise a classic? There is a reason why it has been popular since 1866; almost 150 years! Overall I enjoyed the story very much…. but….
My ever present difficulty for keeping track of people was made extra challenging by the Russian names; it seemed to me that everyone had the same name!! Example: Alyona Ivanovna and Avdotya Romanovna… I can’t keep them straight.
I had to use mnemonics to help remember who was who, like for instance the main character’s name: Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov. I would say to myself: “Raskolnikov is a rascal, and rascals are up to no good – therefore he’s the killer” but that only helped when I heard his name. I could not retain it 3 paragraphs later to save my life.
It was extremely hard for me to keep up and I had to keep cheating and reread the synopsis on Wikipedia to understand the story; but that’s my problem, not the book’s. I think I have literary A.D.D.
If there is a translation out there where the main characters are called Jim, and Bob, and Fred, I’d read it again – the core story was riveting.
I didn’t get it.
This may be the most unhelpful review... but I can’t think of anything more to say - it just flew right over my head.
Based on the mostly positive reviews, clearly it was just me.
This book is supposed to recall the true story of Romeo and Juliet and also follows their descendants (who are irritatingly also named Romeo and Juliet) on a Davinci-Code-like quest through Siena to find a hidden statue and break a 600 year old curse. It's not terrible, I teetered on the verge of liking it, but I eventually fell into the "I don't like it" camp.
I came across a review on Good Reads that perfectly explains why I would not recommend the book:
“There were things in the book that did not make it past my suspension of disbelief. I find it hard to believe that the Virgin Mary would curse a family for 600 years just because she didn't get her way with the original Romeo and Juliet. I also didn't like how the ancestors of Romeo and Juliet seemed to have this "Well, you're named after Romeo and I'm named after Juliet, so we're supposed to be with each other and fall in love" attitude. It was weird and I didn't find it to be the least-bit romantic. And I found it infuriating the way that none of the characters were ever straight with each other on anything until the very end. And while the climax of the book was satisfying, a great portion of the book left me rolling my eyes.
If you have a deep love of Romeo and Juliet, can buy into the idea of your life being controlled by "fate" and curses, and have sappy notions about romance, then you might like this book. Otherwise, I recommend that you pass it up”
I agree 100%! (well, more like 99% - I didn’t find the book’s climax satisfying)
I was curious about this book because of its notoriety; according to Wikipedia it’s the second biggest selling true crime book in publishing history, the first being “Helter Skelter” published in 1974 about the Manson Murders.
I feel ambivalent about the merits of these kinds of books as they feel sort of exploitive to me, but I suppose that makes me a hypocrite because I am the first one to tune into Dateline Mystery or 48 Hours or the Discovery Investigation Channel!
I think I understand what made the book so all the rage when it was published in 1966, as a society now-a-days we are sadly desensitized to this kind of thing (almost everything on TV feels like Murdertainment), whereas in the 60s we weren’t and so the case was more compelling. In today’s context, this true life murder doesn’t really stand out.
What a horrible thing to say! That the murder is not good enough to be interesting… believe me I am not that callous, just impervious over time. I don’t know if it’s me or the writing style but I just found it boring. I know the point of writing it as a novel was to humanize the people but it didn’t do that for me at all - in fact, it bored me so much I just hurried up to get to the end! Frankly I should have just abandoned it.
I also read that some parts of the story were embellished by Capote and some details were exaggerated to make the story more interesting! If that’s true then it’s another black mark for the book. Overall, I regret this purchase.
Regarding the narration, I just don’t like Scott Brick. Objectively he’s good, (and quite prolific – 584 titles in Audible) but to me he seems overly dramatic. I’ve said about him before: I get sidetracked by HOW he’s saying things as opposed to WHAT he’s saying – it’s distracting and makes it hard to concentrate on the story.
... comparing every suspenseful thriller with a twist told in alternating points of views to “Gone Girl”???
I understand that the idea is to inform people who liked one that they might like the other, but I think it does a disservice to the book because it can cause false expectations and potentially set the reader up for disappointment.
The Good Girl stands up on its own - a great page turner that I easily devoured in a day... stay tuned for the movie, you know it’s coming!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.