Customer Reviews | Audible.com
 

You no longer follow Max

You will no longer see updates from this user when they write new reviews, or suggestions based on their library or recommendations.

You can re-follow a user if you change your mind.

OK

You now follow Max

You will receive updates from this user when they write new reviews, or suggestions based on their library or recommendations.

You can unfollow a user if you change your mind.

OK

Max

United States | Member Since 2010

6
HELPFUL VOTES
  • 2 reviews
  • 68 ratings
  • 256 titles in library
  • 5 purchased in 2014
FOLLOWING
0
FOLLOWERS
0

  • Comstock Lode

    • UNABRIDGED (15 hrs and 17 mins)
    • By Louis L'Amour
    • Narrated By Erik Singer
    • Whispersync for Voice-ready
    Overall
    (110)
    Performance
    (99)
    Story
    (102)

    It was just a godforsaken mountainside, but no place on earth was richer in silver. For a bustling, enterprising America, this was the great bonanza. The dreamers, the restless, the builders, the vultures - they were lured by the glittering promise of instant riches and survived the brutal hardships of a mining camp to raise a legendary boom town. But some sought more than wealth. There was Val Trevallion, a loner haunted by a violent past, and Grita Redaway, a radiantly beautiful actress driven by an unfulfilled need.

    Max says: "Charming...but"
    "Charming...but"
    Overall
    Performance
    Story

    I got this book after reading the glowing reveiws written on about it, as well as L'Amour's other works. I love westerns and L'Amour was high on my list so I felt it was time to give it a shot. The book is filled with charming characters, endearing scenes and some classic western action. However, the fact is the book is just not that well written.

    The dialogue is extremely stilted and unatural. Things that should be be described in narration are instead awkwardly spoken by the characters. For example, when a charater's wife asks if her husband has shot a gun, the husband replies by saying "I have not. In England only the great land owners hunt." It is an instance where L"Amour is trying to explain to the reader why the character hasn't shot a gun. But the husband and wife are both from England, so wouldn't this information be common knowledge to someone who grew up there? It's dialogue that no real human would ever speak. The story also jumps around from place to place often before you really get solid feel for where the characers are. There is often little description of places beyond the most superficial detail.

    I do not want to blast this book. L'Amour is a legend in the western genre and I respect what he has done. It's also clear from other reviews that he is much loved by many people. I want to make clear that there is a lot of good in this book and I can see why so many people love it. But I myself just can't get past the technically poor writing, especially when there are incredibly well written works in the western genre by authors like McMurty, McCarthy, and Guthrie.

    5 of 6 people found this review helpful
  • Cheyenne Raiders

    • UNABRIDGED (8 hrs and 33 mins)
    • By Robert Jordan writing as Jackson O'Reilly
    • Narrated By Michael Kramer
    Overall
    (56)
    Performance
    (23)
    Story
    (23)

    Thomas McCabe is on his way to a brilliant career as a lawyer when, in 1837, he gives everything up to take a job with the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Sent to live with a tribe in the wilds of Missouri, McCabe soon saves the life of a young brave. Subsequently, yet grudgingly, he is accepted by the Cheyenne, until he falls hopelessly in love with the beautiful, and betrothed, Night Bird Woman. Determined to marry her, McCabe must prove himself to the tribe.

    Jim says: "LOVED IT!"
    "Good for WoT fans"
    Overall
    Performance
    Story

    I bought this book in my post Wheel of Time euphoria, just after I finished the final installment of the series. I am a big fan of the western genre and I wasn't quite ready to come down from my Robert Jordan high, so I thought I give this one a go.

    Let me say first that Robert Jordan is not William Faulkner, and the technical aspects of his writing often lean toward the juvenile. However, I do believe that it isn't a requirement for all writers to have pretty prose, and what Jordan lacks in technique he makes up for in an engaging story. The story is very dynamic and exciting with well developed (albeit somewhat two-dimensional) characters who I did grow to have feelings for. And while I don't know for sure how accurate it is, Jordan seems to be very knowledgeable about the subject he writes about.

    And for the Wheel of Time fans who are thinking of buying this, it is fun to see where some of the ideas in WoT might have come from. I can really see a lot of Aiel in the Cheyenne, in their dialogue and actions. This obviously can't live up to WoT but any WoT fan would enjoy it. I laughed out loud when McCabe entered the Cheyenne camp and his mouth went dry (a common physical nervous reaction in WoT).

    I would recommend this as a light read in between heavy hitters. It's a short fun story that is highly entertaining and well suited for audiobook. Michael Kramer does a good job as well. Like I said, this is a light read. If you are looking for a western along the lines of McCarthy or McMurtry, look elsewhere. But if you are just looking for an entertaining story, give it a try.

    1 of 1 people found this review helpful

Report Inappropriate Content

If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.

CANCEL

Thank You

Your report has been received. It will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.