"A solid story, brilliantly presented"
I enjoyed this book a great deal. Some people seemed bothered by the meandering nature of this story. I enjoyed it all the more for it's breadth. The interludes did confuse me a bit at first, but once I realized they were tributaries off the main story to provide more backgrounds, I just went with it. I would say this book is like a relaxing float down a river. If you want to just get to the end by speed boat, this may not be the story for you. If you want to just follow a story where ever it leads, this is a good one.
The narration of this story was brilliant. The voices were spot on and I was not the least bit distracted by them. In fact, I forgot at times it was not presented by the original cast.
I listened to this book twice in a row and I am sure I will return to it on my next long drive. I found this much more satisfying than the audio books which are a blend of narration and tv show audio.
"Decent story, presentation not great"
I go this book in part to hear how Jamie joined the Tardis crew. For that reason I am glad I got it. I have to say that although the story is fairly decent, I found many of the characters extremely annoying not least of all the two companions travelling with the Doctor. I have a selection of Dr. Who audio books and this is by far my least favorite.
"Chapter 2 is worth it, the rest... eh."
I listened to Chapter 2 of this book at night at bed time. I did feel changes and I did sleep better, had more focus and my dreams seemed more insightful. The other tracks were not at all helpful except for Chapter 1 which gave instructions.
The PDF guide (which I suggest downloading - there is a link on the book page) is only marginally helpful. It refers to a Chapter 8 which does not exist on the book :-( Not sure if it is missing or just not in this audio book. The production of this whole package would be greatly enhanced by a little more attention to accurate and useful documentation.