How in the world this book got even ON the bestseller list is a mystery to me! The characters lack interest, the writing is unimaginative, the plot? is predictable! The story is too simple. I didn't care to even finish it but it was chosen for our book club and we DID want to have something to discuss. NONE OF US WANTED TO FINISH IT. We didn't care about the characters & could barely keep them straight. Save your 1 credit & go buy the book if you must..at the GOODWILL they will have MANY copies!
Interesting characters. A little mental illness, a little mystery, a little raunchy behavior, set in England was it? All add up to a good listen if you are not looking for anything too "deep". I enjoyed it enough to give it 3.5 stars. It would be great for listening in the car...
What a great story! The characters are well developed & each quite interesting. The story itself is timeless yet set in a time when the medical aspects seem impossible. I loved it from beginning to end. Love, murder, sexist macho wariors, old wise men...what more could you want?
Once again I chose this based on star ratings...not always a true meter for me I see. There are LONG dialogues on animals, religion, Canada verses Inda ...but very little story. The story line is there but I'm a good 2 or 3 hours into it & value my "LIFE MINUTES" too much to devote anymore to this one...There are hints of possible good passages ahead but the long rantings between are just not worth it.
I look first at the number of customer reviews & then the stars & chose this book based on that. This was the first in a series & maybe they following ones get better as they are added but this one was a bit shallow. It was entertaining but pretty "Agatha Christy" type plot. The narrator does a good job.
I found the story interesting and it did hold my attention. I was apprehensive of the narrator at first but he was actually very very good, especially since he is the author too. He based this story on factual events that he sites from his family from Mexico. Some facts he does admit are his interpritation of how things might have happened. The characters are great & he does all the different voices very well. I am a great fan of historical fiction and of corse Brother Fish is my all time favorite..this is not nearly as good as that but worth a listen if you like different cultures. He paints a very vivid picture of life in Mexico in the 1900s. It is hard to review without giving any of the story away..but the main character's life does get a bit bizarre & the reader wonders if it will ever end! The story as presented would have made some kind of memorable history I would have thought. Three stars out of 5 is a very fair rating.
When the first story started with the flowery elaborate English narative,I knew I was going to be dissapointed.(actually this story line turned out to be my favorite of the 6..) BUT I was determined not to waste a book. So I stuck with it all the way. But it was a STRUGGLE. Like one other reviewer here, I had hoped that it would all come together at the end but it only barely connected the stories. I don't think I ever did connect the futuristic story to the rest. Possibly this would be a better pick to actually read & not listen to. I wanted to go back often & see if I had missed something but I listen on a iPod Shuffle & going back is not the easiest..The writing & actors were both very acomplished & I did marvel at the writer's brilliant command of the English language.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.