This is the first novel to feature Ms. Peters's Egyptological heroine, Amelia Peabody. It is truly delightful. Although it introduces a recurring character, this book is a treat on it's own--you don't have to commit to the whole series in order to enjoy it (although after you enjoy it, you will be unable to resist the next one.... and the next....). If you like mystery, romance, adventure, and/or humor, you cannot do better than this book. Nor can I imagine a better narrator for the book than Susan O'Malley. The pacing is excellent, the reading is clear, the characters' voices are distinct without being annoying, and the humor of the writing comes through perfectly.
Elizabeth Peters is a fine writer whose books are smart, funny, well-structured, and beautifully written. Her best books (like those of Georgette Heyer, Mary Stewart, Dorothy Sayers, and a handful of others) follow in the steps of P.G. Wodehouse and Jane Austen, proving that reading can be light and enjoyable without sacrificing quality or even delicate social satire. And this book is indisputably one of her best.
This is a charming, frothy book with so much humor and romance. By the end I was really rooting for the main characters, some of whom are classic Heyer and some of whom are a nice change. There are also some sublime, understated observations. So good.
Also, Phylliada Nash is my favorite Heyer reader, and she does a particularly good job with this book. She understands the characters and the humor, gets the mood and voices right, and also doesn't mess up the words like some readers. She's really super, very classy, not melodramatic like some but just dramatic enough.
This book provides interesting backstory for an important character in the Vicky Bliss mysteries. Those are probably my favorite Elizabeth Peters books, especially Street of the Five Moons, Trojan Gold, and Night Train to Memphis. But this book is just a little less polished. It's hard to get attached to the characters or to sympathize with their plight because it all seems a bit unrealistic. Still, a worthwhile listen--entertaining and fun. Well-read in this audio version. Just not as great as I'd hoped.
Summer of the Dragon is a terrific early Elizabeth Peters mystery/romance. It doesn't feature any of her popular recurring characters, but stands on its own very nicely. It is funny from beginning to end. The heroine is very likeable. Like so many Peters stories, this one does a great job of dealing with interesting and believable archaeological/anthropological topics in a very accessible way. The quick-moving and enjoyable dialogue combined with the heroine's down-to-earth voice make everything easy to follow and very fun. Also, this reader does a wonderful job (but for mixing up a word or two in a briefly confusing but not really disruptive way); I thought she really captured the characters without overdoing it. Be prepared that some elements of the story are a bit dated (for example, our heroine gets some flack for being a "feminist," apparently because she is pursuing a Ph.D. and a job) but after all the book was written in 1979.
I just love Georgette Heyer and am frustrated that more of her books aren't available to download on Audible. But this one was an excellent choice for inclusion in the selection! If only they'd add Death in the Stocks.
This is a very witty mystery story with the same type of well-written dialogue and nuanced, lightly satirical, almost Austenian character development that characterizes Heyer's best work.
This narrator generally does a lovely job. A few of the female characters are a bit overdone and single-note, but it's well worth getting past that issue. (I might have subtracted a star for this complaint if there were other options for listening to this book, but to the best of my knowledge no other audio edition is available in any format, and my minor disagreement with some of the narrator's stylistic choices does not by any means prevent me from wholeheartedly recommending this book.)
This is such a wonderful story. I read The Secret Garden over and over as a girl, and still never tire of it. (The same is true of The Little Princess.) I love how real the two children at the heart of the story are, and how their growth as characters is so dramatic but also generally very believable.
Audible has several editions of the Secret Garden, so I listened to samples of all the readers and ended up choosing this one. I'm glad -- the narrator does a very nice job of conveying the spirit of the characters without letting her own interpretation get in the way of the story as written. My only complaint is the same as the previous reviewer's; the editing of this audiobook left no space whatsoever between the end of one chapter and the beginning of the next, and so each time a new chapter begins, it is quite jarring.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.