This used to be one of my favourite Ngaio Marsh books but somehow this did not work so well in the audio form. The humour somehow does not come over very well, the old ladies are pathetic but not funny and the dialogues are quite dated.
Perhaps not one of Trollope's best but still more interesting than "The Prime minister" which was the one I took before and actually gave up on half way through.
This one has entertaining side stories and Timothy West's reading is excellent as always.
This is a classic. I read it more than 40 years ago and it still kept me glued to the (this time) headphones. On the whole the narration was good although sometimes I wished that Simon Preble would clear his throat a bit.
The story is a bit disjointed and sentimental for my taste but Anton Lesser's performance makes it a classic
I loved this long, long story, so well told both by Dickens and by Anton Lesser, perfect!
A fairly typical Wallander story - except for the end which was not satisfactory and a surprising treatment by the author of his long standing, key character.
Old style detective/romantic tale with Miss Silver clearing up the mystery and a happy end for the main characters - what more do you want?
Maybe not the best Wallander story but good all the same. I think this is Mankell's first Wallander book and the character and his background appears fully created here.
It took time to get used to the narrator.
May be not as well constructed as David Copperfield, which I listened to before, but very enjoyable even so and the reading first class.
There are some audiobook authors that I can always rely on for a reasonably good detective story and Ann Granger is one of them (Reginald Hill and Henry Mankell also). Granger does not always stick to the storyline but gets there in the end.
Trollope is always a good value in Audiobooks, over 20 hours of a well read story that keeps you glued to the headphones - even though you may have heard it nearly all before in other Trollope stories
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.