Some interesting insights into the attitudes of that generation regarding family and children, the terrors of war and hardships endured both at home and abroad. A collection of anecdotes with somewhat romanticized commentary doesn't make a great book. I would love to see a proper documentary on television but as a book, the abridged version is quite sufficient to get the gist of the author's views. The bit I dislike most was the adulating tones on the war stories of George W.Bush and Ronald Reagan. Their stories paled in significance to the other people in the book and belied a slight bias of the author in relating these stories.
No. He's a great commentator but not such a great writer of books.
Nothing. The voice was clear and in keeping with the nature of the epic stories he had to tell.
I would condense the content, a lot of the story from The Persimmon Tree is repeated and re-repeated far too many times in this book. There are a lot of cliches and editorial misses that should have been excluded and detract from the telling of this sequel.
restricted the amount of cliches about women and expanded more on the final outcome of his writing his story and Marg Hamilton.
he redeems some of the self depreciating humor and allows you to overlook the authors at times tedious repetitions and cliches.
yes but only if it were together with the first book, The Persimmon Tree. No idea on actors!
Read the Persimmon Tree first or you'll be disappointed and irritated. I read this sequel and can understand why other readers were disappointed and given poor reviews. This is not his best book, but I did enjoy most of it as part of the previous story. It took me a while to get into the first book, so I read The Four Fires which was more fun and more akin to The Power of One. I felt I had to got into the style of this author and so decided to go back to the Persimmon Tree but had to make an effort to tolerate some cliches and repetitions of storyline especially for Fishing for Stars.I still enjoyed it overall. There is some good storytelling and information in there, once you get used to the writing style but not everyone's cup of tea! One for fans I think and not the best Bryce Courtney book to start with.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.