I don't know but I wasted money on this one!
Don't know yet
Could not relate
Don't waste your money!
Oh yes, great story line and amazing characters.
Yes, she did a great job with the voices and personalities.
OHGosh, I was driving during the wedding scene and almost had to pull over because I was laughing so much!!!
I recently started reading Julie Garwood's books and this one is by far my favorite!!!
It's up there!!!
Jacob of course.
I would have liked to.
I read this book and was so interested in it that I rented the movie, I was not as impressed with the movie because it they left so much out. I had my husband watch it too and he really liked the movie but I found I had to explain some scenes so he understood. This is a book that I would not mind listening to again.
Having this read brought so much personality to the book that I felt I knew Jacob.
HIGHLY HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend!!!!!
I loved the story and how it opened more history to what happen back in the days of the depression. To be honest, I never knew this existed. This was a truly heartbreaking story.
The scene at the bar and the very last scene. Loved Vivian, Molly and Dutchie!!
I would highly recommend this book! The only challenging part was the speed at which the book was read, she reads/speaks very fast.
I loved the adventures and at the end I sat at thought "Oh - is THAT why he did that" and "Oh - I can see why" and "OMG - how sad".
I loved them all!
Awe man, so many!
I was sad that it was all over and there was not another book to follow. I can see where things can be easily picked up and would love to see a book #5!
HIGHLY HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend!!!
This book was very refreshing to listen to, an innocent romance,fiction, fantasy book that you can easily be drawn into. This is a book that an 18 year old would enjoy as well as a 75+ would enjoy, I do recommend this book!
It kept you wondering "what's next".
I bought this because of a sale that Audible ran, I figured what the heck it was cheap..well, it was well worth the money because I enjoyed it and then read the 4 that followed.
Another person reading the book.
NO! I had a hard time with Yann's reading, no voice inflection and I did not find where he added personality to the characters. I had such a tough time that I only heard about 2 hours of the book and had to put it down - I never finished the book!
Sad that I used up a point for this book.
Add some personality.
I never got that far to be able to answer this one.
I'm disappointed that I wasted a point to purchase this book. I truly tried to listen to more but after having some amazing readers in the past (Kate Reading with The Wilderness series) I was hoping for another one. I could not get into the book, could not get into the characters or into the story. I had heard it was a great one so who knows, maybe I'll watch the movie.
Yann's accent seemed forced and was not consistent.
Loved the adventures and Elizabeth's strength!!
These guys do all seem to get into some things that nobody else would but it sure does seem like fun ( at least to read).
Highly Highly Highly recommend!!!
Love Love Love
Ben, he's such a great man!
I can't give it away but, I loved Ben's comment after Hannah asked the important question!
Don't want to- the name is perfect!
I'm going to be very sad after I finish the next and last book, I've become very close to this family. This NEEDS to be made into a movie!!!
I am HOOKED, this is an amazing author and an amazing story!! I just can't put these down.
I feel connected to the characters and feel like I know them personally. Have loved every bit of this book and the five that follow!
She gives the characters personalities like I've not experienced with any other reader.
Yes, but I don't want to give the story away.
I love this series and will be very sad when I finish the last book!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.