I picked up this book expecting another tale of the irresistible and insatiable power of the Dark Side and the disturbing corruption that inevitably comes with it, and another glimpse into ancient Sith history. I expected to be terrified by the exploits of a Dark Lord with an army of animated corpses doing his bidding. Like the other tales of the Sith I have read (the Bane trilogy, Darth Plagueis, etc) I expected to see an ancient Sith lord cut a swath of destruction that shaped Star Wars history. I got no such thing. If you like zombie bloodbaths you'll probably like this one ( I am sitting alone in my room with lights still on . . .) but if you are more interested in character development and events that formed the Star Wars galaxy as we know it, then look elsewhere. Don't get me wrong, the book was riveting and I really couldn't put it down, and the idea of a Force-adept who speaks to plants is intrigueing, but it just wasn't quite the battle-of-good-vs-evil-decided-by-individual-choices-and-actions that I expected. I don't think I'll listen to it again.
The narrator does an excellent job performing the voices and conveying the emotions of the characters, sound effects and music score are excellent. I'll be looking for other titles narrated by this actor.
After reading James Luceno's Darth Plagueis and learning the name of the visionary Sith Lord who destroyed the Sith to rebuild and revolutionize them I had to read this series. And I have to say I love this trilogy as much as I love the Harry Potter series (and that's saying something. I've read that series 5 times). Karpyshyn paints Des/Bane in such a way that you have to admire, respect and even cheer for him even as you watch him mature into a creature of the Dark. He embodies everything that we fear and hate about the Dark-possessed of awe-inspiring power, ruthless, fearsome, physically imposing and yet subtle, cunning, patient, with great respect for the past and great vision for the future. Probably the most dynamic villain I've ever encountered; he is truly the Sith'ari in my opinion, and every Sith Lord who follows after him should pay homage to his greatness. I've been waiting for these books to hit audible since the day I finished Dynasty of Evil the 1st time.
I gave the performance 4 stars because I didn't particularly appreciate the narrator's choice to give Bane an aussie accent. It's kind of jarring and annoying. So was the choice to give the denizens of Apatros southern accents. I realize Apatros was a backrocket planet but that's kinda pushing it. And he sometimes forgets which accent he's doing for which character, and it sounds disjointed. He is however, the only narrator I've come across in a dozen audio books who can do a good Neimoidian accent. That's worth an extra star to me.
If you were like me and thought that Star Wars episodes I-III were ruled by special effects and the music of John Williams rather than an epic story with epic characters, then you need to read/hear this book! You will come to understand the nature and history of the Bannite Sith Order, and the masterful and ruthless subterfuge that resulted in the fall of the Galactic Republic and the Jedi order.
All of the characters from episodes I-III are given greater depth and texture than could be conveyed in the roughly 8 hours of film in the movies. Emperor Palpatine will no longer be just a stooped,gravelly-voiced shadow hidden in a cowl to you after this, Darth Maul will be more than a silent, scowling killer wielding an exotic weapon, Count Dooku will no longer seem like Saruman in a cape and boots. The mystery of the death of Jedi Master Sifo Diyas will puzzle you the same way it puzzled the Jedi Council.
And you will understand that Anakin Skywalker was destined for greatness, but NOT in the way that the Jedi imagined when they accepted him for training.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.