Member Since 2001
I read this book at the recommendation of a friend who loved it but it never really caught on for me or touched me in a way that got me really engaged. There are passages of the book that show evidence of a writer developing inside, but the delivery is not up to the potential. There are good characters in the story, but they are not fully developed at the level of a mature novelist and there's some hat-tipping and insider literary signposts that are cute but are more of a 'wink' at the reader than a substantive anchor for the story. I was able to read through to the end, partially because there was enough promise in the story to hold my attention, but not enough to make me want to stay there. The female characters were expecially weak. I will say there is quite a lot of heart in the telling. But the story left me unsatisfied on so many levels I wish I hadn't started out with such high expectations. When books like this get rave reviews, I'm not certain it's always a help for an author or the reader.
Also, the narration left something to be desired. Although clear and easy to follow which character was speaking, too many of the male characters had palid effeminate voices that didn't suit, such as the way the narrator read Henry's words. It really set you off in an entirely different direction on the character of Henry than the one who was being portrayed.
All that said I was glad I finished the book and I expect someday this author will produce a more mature and less self conscious work. I would only recommend the book to those who like campus novels or tales that mix sports and literature.
I enjoyed every minute of this well narrated and well written book. It is the basis for the part of the movie Julie/Julia that is based on Julia Child's life and it describes both her love of cooking and the delights of living in France...also the delights of EATING in France. A great recommendation for fans of France or of Julia Child."
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.