5 Stars is just not enough..this book surpassed my expectations. It is a complex story so it takes the author at least 4 hours to set up the story & characters, if you can get thru this and establish the "who is who" you will not be disappointed. Great characters, great magic, great story..what else can you ask for. I looked at this series several times and seen the rave reviews, and now I get it.. go ahead you listen to it.. and you will not regret it. BTW I am doing something I never do..I bought the other two book in this series..can't wait for my credits.
Marco Effect re-done
His characters are very distinct
This book is the same book as Marco Effect. Different name different narrator. It was interesting to see how the two narrator portrayed the characters. I downloaded this in error thinking that audible made a typo with it listed also being book fiveof dept Q. I could have returned it but did not. I am a fan of Dept Q. Very unique group of investigators. Assad and his camel colloquialisms make me laugh out loud.
The lack of continuity for the use of all the sexual reference. It reminded me of young boy that is fascinated by the use of swear words and body parts.
NO NO NO
Would not have published it. The only reason that it was published was because he is CF
I was really disappointed in this book. I watch the late show (not anymore) and considered CF to be a pretty witty fellow. But this book is horrible, the ramblings, the constant reference to body parts. The man is obsessed with pr**ks, and t**t. This is the 3rd book in 3 years I have not finished and I read 1 to 2 books a month.
This book could be Sookie Stackhouse (True Blood series) went thru a time warp and stepped out in the 19th century, and her southern accent was replaced with an upper crust english accent. Haven't decided if I want to continue the series, just as in TB this book has sex scene that just really are not necessary to the story.
Jim Dale Yes
Erin M No
The creation of the performers of the nite circus, Didn't care for the love story
Yes, fantastic as usual
Nothing I would watch
I could see this book appealing to romantic readers, which I guess makes me not one
I'm on to book four, yep, I'm invested into this series, book 3 is defenetly worth listening to book 2. The first two books are just a launching point for the series. I don't think the series really sets its own tone until book three, which I enjoyed.
I have looked at this series for a year, because I like the narrators, and Brandon Sanderson. This must have been the first book Kate & Micheal narrated, it is not as polished as the current reads they have done. The story is slow, and parallels LOR to a point of prediction for the story line. The only redeeming part of books 1 and 2, is they are prelude to books 3 and 4, which are very good. So if you have the patience to set the foundation of this series, and give the narrators time to flesh out the characters. Downloaded it.
Wow, what a great story, this has shot up to one of my favorites, Mistborn series was good, but this one is a classic. The writting and crafting of this novel is incredible. I listened to it once and am on my second time and it is just as good the second time. The naration could not be better, Micheal Kramer, and Kate Reading really add to the journey that this book will take you on. The whole sprin concept I just loved...If you liked Mistborn, this book will not disapoint you. Just hope the rest of the series is as great
This was such a disapointment. I am a big Neil Gaiman fan, but this book was so difficult to follow. Sometimes I think some books do not translate well to Audio, and for me this book is a prime example.
I debated getting this book for at least a month, due to the negative reviews, and the low star rating. But I was intrigued by the premise for the book. I AM SO GLAD THAT I DOWNLOADED IT. I loved this book, the plot, the characters. I hope the sequel comes soon. This would be a great series to replace the endless Vampire based books. A Saga of Angels on earth, count me in. I have to apologize to the narator, I ripped her for the naration of The Eight by Kathrine Nevile....She completly redeems herself with this naration.
This is the first time in 2 yrs as a Audible listener that I did not finish a story, I didn't finish part one 4 hours of " maybe it will get better". The book is probably not all that bad, I wouldn't know I could not stand to listen to it any longer. The naration is done as if the narator is being punished to read it. It is forced, has no flow.The book was just frustrating argh #$@^%$. I just finished the " The Help" which is a very hard act to follow. Probably should have waited a week or two before getting another book.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.