The author tells a great story and I like her characters. My issue is with the narrator. His tone is incongruous with the character's situation. When a character should be sounding distressed or concerned, they sound upbeat or happy. In fact, rarely does his tone vary between characters. It is continually upbeat and happy even when a teenage girl is crying or someone has been shot. Also, these are characters from Southern California, LA, to be precise and one of the main characters has a southern twang. All of this distracts from the book. I will be going to the paper versions of books if this narrator is reading.
I would recommend this to someone looking for a light and entertaining read
I enjoy this series. It is a good solid read. The characters are likable and believable. I do occasionally get annoyed with the protagonist and want her to have more of back bone but it actually works for her overall. I would recommend this series to someone looking to be entertained but not overwhelmed by graphic images.
I am not sure if I can recommend this to anyone really.
I found this book dated and disappointing. The author seemed to have an agenda about the inequalities that women face in the world a subject I am generally sympathetic to. However the author was heavy handed with her points and made me uncomfortable with the relationships between each character. I like a book that does not tie up the ends in a neat package. Her ending neither had a twist- it was predictable nor did it make me want more. She seemed to have run out of ideas on how to end it so just explained it all at the end. I felt cheated and actually a little angry that I wasted my time on this book.
This is a well written book but very depressing. But that is not why I only gave it 2 stars. I found even in the Harry Potter series the grown ups not behaving as good parents and often causing pain unnecessarily. This is true in this book also. JK Rowling seems to have a good grasp on the adolescent brain and rational but I feel she diminishes adults and their ability to respond appropriately.
Also, I appreciate learning about other countries and culture and love to learn through literature. I felt she was weak bringing me into the social structure. As an American reader, it took a bit to understand how the politics influenced the story.
JK Rowling is obviously a talented writer but her observations skew towards the dark side of adults and the low side of children. It is for this reason that I would not recommend her book. I will not read another.
I love Louise Penny's Inspector Gamache series and look forward to each of her books. This is no exception. Her narrative and descriptions are full of beautiful images that I can see in my mind's eye. Her characters are fully developed and continue to develop through each book.
I want to savor a good book listening or reading. I would never want to listen in one sitting because I want the time to absorb the writing.
I love to listen to the Eve Dallas series and look forward to each new book.
I found myself more disturbed about the graphic topic of this book than ones in the past. I believe it was because of the believable terrorist attack aspect that made it so uncomfortable. That said, it is still a very good listen maybe all the more so because it was so imaginable.
Just more Eve Dallas
I enjoyed this book even though at times I wish the protagonist would be more self assured. Perhaps that was what makes her more appealing is that she is not the typical "I am the woman in charge".
If you want a good solid but not necessarily intellectual mystery read, this will fit the bill.
Having a better grasp of how vet and teaching hospitals work. Mr. McCall Smith has always seemed to have a good understanding about his subject even if he does use artistic license. This book lost me totally in his treatment of both the veterinarian world and the dogs.
Not at all.
not the problem
I was trying to stay with the author until he surgically removed 2 legs of a dog. I could not listen any further. The whole ludicrous idea that a person could lecture to convention of vets and not know a thing and get away with pushed my credulity. But to be allowed to do surgery with disastrous and a cruel outcome was the end of my listening. I am not a squeamish person but Mr. Mc Call Smith's treatment was insulting to me as a reader and to animal vets in general. I know that some vets can get carried away by their own importance and lose sight of the animals and the humans that own them but this is not the way to address the issue.
I will admit that I did not listen to hear the end of the book but felt I had wasted enough of my time on it already.
I wonder what happened to Mr. Mc Call Smith that he stooped to such writing in bad taste
I plan on listening to the whole series. I really like the protagonist. She is not a whiner or helpless.She manages to try to work out her jams herself but is smart enough to know that she is in over her head. A little like Stephanie Plum I found myself laughing out loud.
The narration was terrible. The person narrating has a smokers voice that is both squeaky and raspy making the performance difficult to listen.
I found the whining attitude of her protagonist irritating beyond endurance and would have to shut it off just not to get mad.
A different narrater would have made all the difference
. I think that the book and plot were engaging except for the whining self deprecation of the protagonist. I will listen to her books because she does have a good way of telling a story and a mystery that is interesting. I just find her main character embarrassing as an adult woman.
I would again buy this book if it had a different narrator and it was on sale.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.