This book had gotten great reviews, so I was very surprised at my negative reaction. I wonder if this is the first book in my experience that is worse in the audio version than the print version. I usually love atmospheric mysteries, and these get points if set in the UK or Ireland (William Boyd's Restless is excellent). But I just could not get into this one--the characters did not seem at all believable and they all just became annoying after awhile. There were no shades of gray; even the villain was so villainous as to be tedious. A major problem for me may have been the narration--it was really overwrought. And as someone who grew up in Boston, I found the southern (?!) accents of the characters living there to be very jarring. In fairness, I should say that I did finish the book and was curious to see how it turned out. But I'm not eager to try another book by Banville/Black or one narrated by Timothy Dalton!
A wonderful book--I felt that I came to really know the characters, quirks and all, and I found the story to be very engaging. It was a surprisingly moving book as well. And very thought provoking too in getting at some of the big questions about life and how we find the strength to go on. But there is nothing heavy handed in the author's deft exploration of these issues.
I would rather write a review without having to answer these questions! I found the book to be a strange combination of an unconvincing love story with an all-too-convincing depiction of the horrors of life in a japanese POW camp. The characters were not well developed, the plot included contrived coincidences that were completely unnecessary, and the writing was often overly gruesome (including a very lengthy description of an ultimately futile surgery) but also trite and full of cliche. I did finish the book and found it absorbing, I guess. And I certainly learned a lot about a horrible episode in WWII. But I cannot recommend this book. Unbroken, which I also "read" as an Audible book, addresses similar issues and is a far superior book that I highly recommend.
The Blazing World. A very different book to be sure!
Not that I know of. He was a pretty good narrator.
Unfortunately, I can. Hollywood will undoubtedly find the story fertile ground for a movie. I doubt the movie will be any better than the book--it will probably be worse in that it will emphasize the holiest parts of the story.
Like the (few) other reviewers who didn't like this book, I am surprised at the generally glowing reviews it received from critics and its winning the Man Booker Prize. To me, it's a case of the emperor's new clothes. I don't mean to trivialize the difficult subject matter, and clealy the author has tried hard, and to a large extent succeeded, in conveying (and trying to get at the source of) the appalling attitude of the Japanese war effort. But that is not, in my opinion, enough to make this a great, or even good, book.
There is some lovely writing in this book; the author does a wonderful job of slowly drawing the reader in to a world that seems idyllic and almost magical. And then the world changes--and changes in such a brutal and agonizing way that, even for those who miss the connection to Hamlet, it seems clear that nothing good can ever happen in that world again--at least not to the human denizens. But by then, the reader is so engrossed (or at least I was) that she has no choice but to follow the saga to its inevitable end. Edgar's journey is absorbing and engaging (and suspenseful) but ultimately chilling. I realized as I got close to the end that the novel had become almost a horror story--but by then I had to see it through. I'm not terribly sorry I did--it was interesting and well written throughout, even if a little long in places--but I do feel just a little used by the author, who seemed to set up one kind of story, only to turn it into a very different kind of tale. Solace of a sort comes from the sense that the dogs, at least, have grown and had a chance to express their own true natures--natures that are more solid and reliable, perhaps, than those of the humans who breed them.
The plot of this novel is certainly riveting--you are carried along with the story, always interested to know what comes next. And yet I found it ultimately distancing, perhaps because Hannah never really felt authentic to me. She seemed to be a symbol or a caricature rather than a real woman. The story is most successful at showing the effects of American imperialism on a small country in Africa that was, in some ways, doomed from the start. And Banks does a very good job at weaving the real history of Liberia and its monstrous leaders into the fate of his fictional characters. And yet--it just never gelled for me. The narrator did a good job of capturing Hannah's passivity and preternatural calm, but in a way this just heightened my sense of Hannah's one-dimensionality.
These short stories, which collectively form a meditation on aging and connection (or disconnection) and love, are linked by shared characters (especially Olive Kittredge, who appears in all of them). They are set in a small town in Maine, and at times you can feel the salt in the air. Some of the characters are more compelling than others, but Olive is the most memorable: complicated and frustrating and ultimately wise and appealing. This is not a novel but rather a "novel in stories," a format that turns out to feel very different from a novel. In some ways it's the best of both worlds: you experience the vignettes, the moments in time, that constitute the modern short story--but also have some sense of the wider context in which these episodes are occurring.
The reading was generally good, though I did feel annoyed by the slow, halting Maine (?) cadence that the narrator used with some characters. I noticed it less over time, fortunately.
If you like modern short stories of the New Yorker type but also like more meaty novels, I'd recommend this book. I don't think I'll be forgetting the character of Olive anytime soon, and I'm grateful to have known her in the (audible) pages of this book.
What a good book! I'd been wondering how it would work to have multiple narrators--and it was great. The narrators were all wonderful, and the story was so engaging and moving. Leo's "and yet..." resonates with me still. Highly recommended!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.