You must listen to Armageddon's Children (Book 1) first! It sets up everything, but then you'll need this one as well.
I am also a long time audible listener, and I have to agree with other reviewers about the narration of The Elves of Cintra. Dick Hill was an excellent narrator for Armageddon's Children! He managed a very subtle and realistic Native American accent for one of the characters - it sounded like a separate/different reader he was so good. I was very disappointed when I realized Phil Gigante had replaced him. I thought I would get used to it, and the arbitrary and inconsistent use of a quasi-british accent (why british?) - for some members of the Elf family - it was off putting, but was not the worst part. His pronunciation of words like 'sense' sound like 'since', and 'descent' becomes 'descint'. At least he's consistent about it, but I found it jarring each time. Maybe if this was a tale of the old west, it wouldn't bother me. But come on, this is a professional narrator.
GIT a voice coach, and fix it!
His reading of the fun and entertaining story by Terry Brooks was not all bad, he was able to develop a great deal of dramatic effect with the many action/suspenseful sections, but then he'd say 'injun' instead of 'engine', and I'd think of how great Dick Hill did with that Native American 'Injun' voice - and it'd pull me right out of the story.
Mr. Brooks' book deserves more than 3 stars, but not with the narration....
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.