The book is cleverly written and cleverly done. I really enjoyed the flashbacks that shed light on some of the decisions the characters make.
It may take Scott a lot of time to complete his books, but they are defiantly worth the wait.
Yes, and now you don’t have to read the rest of my rambling.
So, it’s been a while since we were treated to a tale about our favorite two conmen, and now we get to meet that legendary redhead we’ve watch Locke pine for over the last two books. She, like any good woman, has been worth the wait. She is strong, smart, confident, and capable. She is Locke’s match in wits and I wish their contest was more drawn out because the back and forth we do get to watch is just grand. And as always, the flashback story is awesome. The young Bastards going off to be a theater troupe and their adventures really make the book.
I have only one real complaint. Sadly, it’s directed at our Narrator. Page is still great. I still want him as the narrator for the series. For 95% of the book he is as wonderful as ever. . .sadly, that 5% that went wrong involves two of my favorite characters. Father Chains and the Thiefmaker don’t have their old voices; they both sound more like Don Maranzalla. That was really disappointing since their old voices were just so perfect for their physical descriptions.
Now, the ending, that was just amazing. The epilogue, which is setting up the future plot, is one of those “Did that just happen?” moments. Red Seas under Red Skies left me wanting more because it felt a little incomplete, The Republic of Thieves has left me wanting more from shear excitement.
Likes to listen while doing chores; likes to write reviews while he should be doing chores.
It is good to be back reading the Gentleman Bastard Series after a bit of a long wait. While this book did not have the genius of the first one, it certainly serves as a very entertaining episode. Lynch fleshes out characters at a very smooth pace, melding back story with current story arc in ways that often leave you with a cliffhanger, but not have to wait too long for a resolution. The effect is quite pleasing.
Lynch's dialogue is fantastic and Page's characterization of it is spot on! Be warned that the language is extremely bawdy. Even my 36 yr. old former soldier's ears might be too virginal for some of the worst of it. His insults and quips will make you want to use them at parties to impress your friends and confound your enemies.
The weakest part of this book - and it was not very weak - was the con itself. For all that Locke spent the first two books as the most talented and clever confidence man in the world, he spent most of this book flailing like an amateur. I get why this antagonist was extra hard on him, but since the very first caper in the very first book he has been reliable for ingenious and bombastic thievery and mischief. That is more than half his appeal. For this episode it feels like Lynch lobotomized all of Locke's talent, but left his ability to curse alone. I read about Locke because I like hearing about the guy who is always one step ahead of his competitors, not 10 steps behind.
I would recommend this book for people who like fantasy and comedy. I would not recommend starting with this book as it is the third in the series. Begin at the beginning and read the whole story. The previous two editions are available on Audible; enjoy them all.
This is an incredibly good series, especially if you love language, wit, and complex characters. The narration is perfectly marvelous, the characters (of all sorts) beautifully, distinctively, creatively and delightfully voiced. I found Chains and the Thiefmaker to be the same as in the first book, just far less of them (to disagree with another reviewer's impression). The narration is so superb that I chose the Audible over the Kindle when I couldn't wait any longer for Whispersync to happen (grrrrrr).
Scott Lynch creates strong and complex women and I applaud him for it. I really appreciated Sabetha and the refreshing change from a pat and predictable romantic arc, though I do hope further adventures in this series will satisfy my always strong desire for a happy ending. Sabetha may be difficult to get 'inside of', but she has her reasons, and we do get to see inside her head and heart at least once. Her feelings on her role in the Bastards are well articulated and raise issues not often addressed in fantasy fiction. The author appreciates and creates real characters of many differences.
The excerpts from the play the characters are enacting in one thread have the special complexity of language that so arrested my attention and challenged my understanding and tickled my fancy at the beginning of The Lies of Locke Lamora. Thank you. The insults here and there are a special treat, too.
Another satisfying book in the series, this book carries on where the previous two left off, bringing in more explanation and a deeper plot. The fact that Lynch leaves the ending obviously waiting for more story is perhaps a bit unsatisfying, but at the same time there is no doubt that I Will be very happy when there is more story to be had. This book is extremely well-written, with prose that is beyond most authors by far. The narration is beautiful and enthralling. I cannot recommend a series more.
Okay so no spoilers but I like books like.
Mistborn Trilogy, The Way of Kings, Kingkiller Chronicles, The Painted Man, The Blade Itself, Game of Thrones, The Black Prism
If you are into my favorites you will probably like this too.
It's a story with real people. they are brought to life and they breath in your imagination as surly as you breath while you read this review. It's woth the investment of time. Read it and you'll walk away feeling better.
Brittany (The Book Addict's Guide)
To kick off this review, I just need to say that I adore these books. They’re so rejuvenating for me and SO much fun to read (listened to this one entirely on audio. Love Michael Page). I loved every single book so far and things are getting curiouser and curiouser as we delve into each character more and learn more of the history of this world. That being said, THE REPUBLIC OF THIEVES so far is my least favorite of the series… but it’s kind of like saying Chamber of Secrets is my least favorite Harry Potter book — I love each and every book in this series, they’re wonderful to read, and I always want to learn more about It’s very different from the first book and also from the second in a couple ways.
THE REPUBLIC OF THIEVES has quite a few new things going for it. We still get a taste of Locke’s past in the interludes, but in this book it’s MUCH more prevalent… in fact, it’s an entire half of the book complete with a full plot which goes from start to finish. I wasn’t as much of a fan of that because as much as I learned about Locke and Sabetha (YES, we finally get to see her both in the past and in the present), I really felt like we spent more time in the interludes than the actual current timeline and that left a bit to be desired. RED SEAS UNDER RED SKIES left us with SO many questions, urgent anticipation of what would happen next, and more hints at Locke’s past so although I don’t need ALL of the answers in one book, I had kind of hoped for a bit more of those things spaced throughout book three. Instead it seemed like interludes and pieces here and there of Locke’s current story and then BAM. Last quarter of the book we get tons of info! But it was very interesting stuff.
I also was er… NOT a fan of Sabetha and mostly that’s Locke’s fault, actually. She was everything I look for in a badass lady except the back and forth with Locke bothered me. It was a bit too much toying (and hesitation on both sides) that drew out this non-relationship over several years so the reader experiences it in both past and present. I don’t usually mind that but I felt like Locke pined a bit TOO much and the fact that I only got to know her through Locke’s eyes… it sort of tainted her character. She was up on a pedestal in Locke’s eyes and so I wanted to knock her down. She really did deserve some of the praise but it was overkill and it made me annoyed. I wish I could have seen her in action and gotten to know her beforehand so I could have witnessed how amazing she was firsthand. Locke was so in love with her that I chalked any greatness Sabetha may have held to Locke’s fascination and I felt like I didn’t really get to know her in the best way I could. 3
I also really, really missed the capers and heists and all that is thievery, etc. Yes, they are still working on a job but alas. It’s not really a main focus… It is but it isn’t. The jobs featured in THE REPUBLIC OF THIEVES are definitely more long cons or don’t really kick it into high gear until the end so I felt like I was left wanting so much more trickery and cleverness throughout the whole book.
The good news is that we definitely get to learn more about Locke and his mysterious past. The bad news is that it’s literally the last few chapters. I enjoyed it and holy cow do I need book four now, but I also felt like it was a bit rushed. Especially seeing how the book ends, I wished for much less time in the interludes (which even after the book ends seem somewhat pointless other than to show Locke and Sabetha’s relationship) and a whole lot more time in the present story line. I felt confused that the interludes were a totally separate plot and didn’t seem to have importance to the main story line of Locke, Jean, and the debt they are now in. The reveals and details at the end were really interesting but I would have liked to have been set up more for them and had that little taste earlier instead of just a series of reveals all at the end.
The review may seem a bit harsh, but I really did still love THE REPUBLIC OF THIEVES. I think things get difficult as a series goes on because you don’t want to repeat the exact same story or structure in each book and have things feel boring and predictable but at the same time, I’m not good at adapting to change within a series. I’m assuming we’re going to see more of Sabetha in future books so I hope we’re past this irritating longing stage and the character relationships can really being to develop again (it was to have those same anxious feelings repeat themselves over and over again throughout the book). That being said, I’m just in love with Scott Lynch’s writing and his books and you better believe I am dying for the fourth book (whose pub date has yet to be determined. GAH).
Ok let me start off by saying I loved the first 2 books. But this is by far the worst end to a story I have ever read. There are no conclusions and the author try's to be mysterious with the characters back story's only succeeded in pissing me off. Every thing that made the first two books great is missing from this one. There is no real scheme there is a lot of boring love story that is never resolved and the end only succeeded in raising more questions that you don't really care about the answer to. The only thing I could recommend about this book is the reader.