Retired CFO, Army wife, Mom of five, Grandma of six, two sons who served in combat, love to read books that reflect my values and faith, love mysteries, historical, military stories, and books that don't waste my time . . . if it doesn't have an ending that was worth the wait, I'm not a happy camper.
Vietnam described in ways you never expect . . . my husband (a retired SGM) and I listened to this on a road trip recently . . . at times we laughed, totally familiar with the military terms, at other times we were totally silent . . . no words . . . absolutely NO words to describe what we were feeling . . . this is not the patriotic, hero stories of comrades at war . . . it's the down in the crap (literally), sinking into despair, wondering what the hell you are there for, tale of soldiers trying to make it one day at a time in a war that nobody wanted to fight . . . it's truthful and hard to swallow . . . it's honest beyond anything I've ever heard on Vietnam . . . no matter what your politics, you need to hear it . . .
People who can endure a fictional (sometimes fantastical) story in a historically valid setting.
No, because in a way "Killer Angels" is fiction as well, but did a fantastic job.
Great voice, good smooth reading.
The scene of the girl who visits the remote medical base.
It was just not for me. It's possible I need my stories to be closer to non-fiction.
Say something about yourself!
A worm's eye view of a selected few vignettes of the author's life before and during his service in VietNam.
The author is long-winded, repeats himself, tells stories out-of-order, says the same things over and over again, and weaves several threads of narrative in and around one another in a manner reminiscent of Kurt Vonnegut. Some people may like that.
But not me.
More organized storytelling.
I did not have a favorite.
Yes, Brian Cranston.
Listening to this story felt like I was listening to my crazy, senile uncles war stories. This was mostly represented in the repetition and poor organization.
Eclectic mixer of books of my youth and ones I always meant to read, but didn't.
The huge positive about this title is Bryan Cranston. It is hard to conceive of a better reading than his. It captured the people, the place and the time. Of course, he had material to work with, but my gut feel was that he put a lot more on the paddock than the personell he had at his disposal. It is like a great coach raising an average team to another level. I felt this with sufficient conviction that I borrowed the paperback (telling that I didn't buy it, I think) and read it. I read it reasonably quickly, although I think I glossed some of it because it was familiar and just plain not as gripping as Cranston's performance. I think this is rare. I've read good books that are read well and it enhances the book, but it started out good. Sure it got better, but it didn't go from a 3 to a 4 star STORY; overall, maybe, but not the story.
So, talking about the story; it was on the good side of ok. A safe 3. I found the "story is not true" part a bit hard to follow, but I'm guessing it was a literary device to convey the blurred line between fact and reality, fear and courage. If not, then I'm one of those people the author says "just don't get it".
I also got the impression that some of the Chapters had been published before as short stories. Sometimes (rarely) the names didn't co-incide and it appeared to be that names had been changed to protect identities at one point in time. This was confirmed by the extra part read by the author.
Turning to that extra part, I have to say that it was very disturbing. The apparently tenous and precarious line that he walks in his life was painful to listen to and in stark contrast to Cranston's assured voice (as the author's voice in the book, proper). In some ways this extra hour is the highlight of the title. In other ways I wish I'd never heard it.
This is a hard title to review. Worth the listen for many reasons, most of them due to Cranston's narration or the contrast between it and the author's real one.
This was a great story, it was a story about reality, about how things happen and sometimes there is no moral or reason for them happening. The thing that was most interesting to me though was that the book was repetitive, but it was done with a purpose and surprisingly it worked well.
This is a tour de force. O'Brien's storytelling is visceral but human, relaying events as they were experienced, full of rush and stillness, horror and beauty. Cranston's narration has the perfect balance of gravity and what I can only describe as fatalist levity, allowing atrocity its due weight but carrying on nevertheless. The effect is to pull you inexorably into these stories, the experience of which you will not soon forget. Strongly recommend.
I'm sure nothing can make us completely understand what it was like to go through the things these men experienced in Vietnam, but this book really moved me. In Audible, Bryan Cranston is the perfect voice to tell the story.