The best I can say about this is that it is a great idea, but it never quite makes it past just an ok read. Kudos to whoever rewrote this for the TV series.
A very different perspective on death. It was an interesting story. Not sure I would have picked up the book, but glad I got to listen...
Just another girl with too many books and not enough time for them all.
I got a copy of this book from the author/publisher at BEA13. Yes I know! That was one month shy of a year ago and I am just now getting to it. Well the audiobook at least.
The story of all stories starts with a little boy found in the rice paddies of China being returned to his family in the states. The story twist, the OMG of it all is that this boy has been not missing but dead for 40 years and he is the same age as when he died. Eight year old Jacob remembers nothing of the time he has been gone, only waking up in China. To him no time has passed and nothing unusual has happened. Jacob is not the only one. There are hundreds of people just waking up in the most random places with no memory of what has happened to them. They all say they just woke up. The dead or coming back and they all are trying to get back to their loved one.
I love this story idea. I have said it before I am a sucker for an original story idea. This is not a "Night of the Living Dead" book at all. It is more like people just reconnecting with the ones they love(d). There are several storylines and families in this book but Jacob's parents -Harold and Lucille are the main focus. I love the way their love and reconnection of their family builds and grows as Jacob's life touches them both in completely different ways. No absent YA parents here. They have been married forever.
Could you image seeing your son after he has been dead and buried for more than 40 years? You have worked as much as you could through the grieving process. You have moved forward with your life and WHAM!! He's back and looks the same as when you saw him last.
I really like this book but it was not a solid like until I got to the author's notes at the end. The book does not give a explanation as to why this is happening all over the world. The reactions of the population I can see really happening but I needed a bit more. The author's notes give the reader an answer to the why? But the question is ...What made him write this novel? What a touching answer.
Please read the prequels before jumping into this novel. The prequels are great.
This is a rare occasion where I actually learned of the book after watching the tv show, now in its second season. There were some very interesting developments on the show. So, I decided to read the book to perhaps gain some insight as to what may be going on in the show. I cannot tell you how disappointed I was that the show is so much better than the book. Of course there are some differences, which I expected. But, the cast of main characters is so much smaller in the book. The intrigue in the show was not present in the book. Here's the kicker...you never find out why or how the returned came back. To me, that was a cop out. The story built up to the climax, but we never really got a full resolution. This is the first time in my life that a book was not as well developed as a movie or show.
The narrator did a nice job, and there were some very interesting story ideas in the book. But, it seemed like the author just decided to stop writing and threw in an author's note to explain some reasons why, without coming right out and saying that's what he was doing.
I wanted to like the book, and I was excited to read it. But, it was a disappointment.
I enjoyed this book but have been waiting forever (or so it seems) for the sequel. I'm not sure he's going to write it so if you don't like cliffhangers, don't bother.
This was my book club's selection of the month. I didn't like it but I read it as a "duty." We all know that a duty does not have to to be liked - just done.
Well my thoughts about the books; First the disappointments (other than not liking the book in first place): Elvis, Marvin Gaye, nor Otis Redding ever came back! Also the Pastor seeing his wife as "failures," and the way he left her and his continued patterned. Fred Green's revolt (reminded me of the California citizens blocking the immigration bus.) Funny - was the 'love affair' of Harold and the old Black lady, Mrs. Stone. Compassionate, but hilarious! The surprise was Lucille!
No, this was my first.
Job well done!
Goodness no!! Let the dead stay dead!
The Danger Bunny
I have recommended this book to friends and I will continue to do so. This book is not only a captivating book to listen to, it opens your mind to so many other possibilities about life, death and the human condition.
I have never read or listened to another book like tis one. It is a very unique story.
I don't think that I could choose any one part of this book to be my favorite. Every chapeter brought something new and something honest and deep with it.
The father I believe was the most memorable in my mind. The way he said one thing yet his actions were a complete contrast to that.
No. It was read very well, but the story itself was filled with too many cliches, and it did not go anywhere. It also seemed to be written to a very old audience. The most frustrating thing about it was the very idea of the returned. A very intriguing idea, that would require a fantastic explanation, only the writer never offers one. Instead - these people who just reappear in the world as the same people they were when they originally left it - seem to serve no purpose at all before they just randomly leave - just disappear - again.
Moby Dick, if I can get this Audible app to download my purchase to my phone.
No. I did enjoy him very much though. I have witnessed the destruction of perfectly good story lines, by horrible narration. So, I appreciate good narration.
These audible books are priced too highly.
What a great premise! I had hoped and thought it would explore really interesting and difficult questions about how we view death, and what death is and what there is or is not beyond life. It seemed like these issues would be explored, but I felt that they just got basically ignored in favor of a strange mixutre of matter of factness and stereotyped character types. I guess I enjoyed the story but was left very dissatisfied- really no questions were answered, and far too few were even discussed. The end was kind of not even there. What was the author's message? what did he want to leave in our minds and hearts to consider and either agree with or reject? If the answer is just- "I have no idea, form your own opinion" then...I could have done that w/o reading. Sorry to sound so negative- I would read another book by this author, but hope he would think through the bigger issues and use them to inform and frame the story a little more effectively.