A different narrator
Not with this narrator
His attempt at humor was condescending and distracted me from concentrating on what he was saying
Anger, as I was interested in the information
Ahhhh this is fantastic. I can learn as I walk & do other things. I think this audible version specially with the entertaining way that professor Greenberg presents the lectures is the best way to approach this course. It has brought meaning to a world that I could not ever imagine to understand.
None. This is unique.
No But I have purchased his other audible books and can't wait to dive into opera.
Music made easy
As one of the viewers mentioned, thank you for making this wealth of information affordable for the masses (the enlightenment of masses). I truly wish you would develop and add more material to this section. I find professor Greenberg's style very appealing. His background historical information drives the point home and gives the information a textural depth that would come across very dry in a historical written work. I only wish you could provide supplementary course material as well. I am happy to pay for it.
The contextualization of music development with social, religious, and political events/
I would have today ch 31. I will never listen to Beethoven's 5th in the same way!
Music history is one of the fields of knowledge which I have never had any exposure to. (Shame on the public school system!) I was afraid it would be dry and inaccessible, but this has been a very fun listen and I will listen to more of the same.
When I got so lost in the lecture that I had to slam on the brakes to avoid committing a major traffic violation while driving.
Somewhere in the middle of this course I realized that Professor Robert Greenberg wasn't lecturing, he was performing. He has a knack for knowing just when the material is getting dry and taking funny little detours to wake up your mind again.
There are laugh out loud moments in these lectures.
Many examples are so clear and makes us really feel what the author tried to express
Professor Greenberg is generously passionate about the topic and delivers it with great skill and story telling skills.
When his verbal explanations and excitement for the the music gets the listener primed to hear a great piece of music. And when the music starts playing, and all words melt into the beauty of the sound.
He is a great professor.
I am in love with Professor Greenberg. I wish I had attended even one lecture in college as interesting, entertaining, and informative as this. And I want more. The others that I had hoped were similar just did not measure up. His wit mixed with his passion for his subject was wonderful. Now I'm going to add all his lectures to my wish list.
Greenberg is passionate, lively, funny, and always crystal-clear.
I thought a lot of early music, including plain chant and the madrigal, were not for me. Boy was I wrong!
Almost every time he plays an excerpt that he's been describing, I'm moved.
I fell in love with great music rather late in the game, at age 22, without any knowledge. I've always steered clear of explanation and analysis, fearing that intellectualizing music would throw a wet blanket over my enjoyment. I was wrong. These lectures have increased my enjoyment enormously.
I have bought and listened about 20 audiobooks so far and without hasitate I can assure this is the best of all.
I consider myself as a complete music ignorant, though I like it. My previous audibooks where none of them about music nor art appreciation. I'm an engineer and without any prior music education.
Though this audibook gave the basis to start understanding great music. Gave me the basis to open my own road in music appreciation.
A phat and big round TEN for Robert Greenberg.
That is exactly what this audibook is: a story!
Robert Greenberg nailed it from the 1st chapter all along the last one. He explained with great humor, knowledge and humble, the human history and where every piece of music and composer fits. He explained the different ages with great detailed but never pretentious. This is the perfect formula for any person without any prior music knowledge to be involved in this wonderful world.
Robert's sense of humor, intelligent and even sarcastic comments
The moment I started understanding some Mozart's movements.
The moment I started to differentiate the inner structure of menuettos, sonatas, passacaglias, fuges, rondos, etc.. I started to realize that this was the perfect audiobook for a guy like me.
The moment my ipod started to be filled with classical, baroque, romantic music, operas and not just to hear them, but to own them.
This audiobook really moved me because I am not a passive listener any more, now I understand, now they are not Beethoven's, Mozart's, Debussy's any more, now I'm active, now they are mine.
I really want to thank Robert Greenberg for this wonderful work. I do not know him personally but I believe he changed me in a deep and aesthetical manner.
Well structured, fun to listen to.
Yes. I have listen to four so far and am about to start a fifth.
Too much to digest to listen to in one sitting. A lecture or two per day gives time to chew on the details. (And download some of the works discussed.)