I don't really care that J.K Rowling wrote this under as nom de plume. I don't really care who wrote it. I am simply glad that I found it as it is a very good book and, I hope, the first of many Cormoran Strike detective stories.
If you happen to be a fan of Michael Connelly's "Bosch" detective books, you will be right at home with this book. I don't mean that J.K. has copied the formula, but just that whatever grabs you about Connelly's books will grab you here, too.
As the book unfolds, you can tell that the main characters are being written for the long haul. Rowling's touch with character development has, if anything, improved from the Harry Potter days and she has written some very flawed but likeable ones here.
The overall story is one that left me saying "I have no idea where this is going" the entire way. Stories that end up with some implausible conclusion that no one could have figured out bother me. Stories like this one, though, that are challenging to figure out but make sense in the end are what you want.
Finally, Robert Glenister is an exceptional reader and I trust that he will be kept around for all of the series--I hope so. Jim Dale MADE the Harry Potter books to me and Robert Glenister seems after this first book to be in that same league.
From all accounts this novel was better than the last by Ms. Rowling, but for me, there was a flaw in the drawing of the murderer, central to his motivation, which kept the story from holding together. In addition, there were many subplots/red herrings/secondary characters that were never fully fleshed out.
The writing is polished, as expected from this author. One hopes this first outing---promising but not perfectly satisfying---in what feels like a series, will be followed by a sequel that is better plotted and has a bit more depth.
Tell us about yourself! Attorney/Rancher - eclectic taste in books in both fiction and non-fiction. Preference for British authors in mysteries, love well written dialogue and hate historical fiction.
A contemporary indictment of the British tabloid mentality in the press and the paparazzi, is the backdrop to a larger theme of self indulgence, extreme and sudden wealth, and a plethora of characters who live in the moment in catering to the insatiable demands of a society which lives vicariously. This is a setting for a death of a famous model, a damaged detective who is greater than the sum of his parts, and his skills in finding the truth, in dogged investigation of the discounted and overlooked.
Much like a skillful deposition, this novel, carefully moves from the basic, "Who are you," and "Where do you live," opening questions of a very good interrogator, into seeming innocuous questions of apparent little import, until the pieces begin to fit together and a true picture of actual events and participants begins to reveal the facts.
The author has proven that the ability to develop a plot which demands the reader continue, and characters who are well drawn, was not limited to one genre, and one is eager to follow their development for good or evil.
If you live or have lived in London, you will like the book. If not, it is hard to remain interested, since the things being describe are all dark and ugly. The story drags.
Not sure, the narrator's accent made the narrative at times hard to understand.
The way the narrator is able to convey a different personality to each character with his voices without sounding like a cartoon is amazing.
Yes, in a way there is a lot of dialog in this book, without things actually "happening" and again I feel I would not have found it soo good without the Narration of Mr Glenister.
Not before this one but my very next audiobook search will begin by looking at him first.
Probably, but there are lots of other books to get to first.
Lots of them, but I especially enjoyed when Robin and Cormoran first meet, and also their trip to the high-end boutique.
The accents are amazing. I would never have been able to "hear" the same voices in my head. He captures them all perfectly, and each distinctly as well.
several, but especially learning about Cormoran's friend who died.
A fabulous listen. I will be buying the book, too, so I can page through it and examine the writing technique, but for pure pleasure, I think this is best as a listen.
I should add that this is a character driven work, not an action packed adventure, so it might seem slow to some. I loved it, and can't wait for more!!
I just loved this book and was so sad when it was over. Eloquently written with simply clarity the story so brilliantly performed by Robert Glenister takes you right into the life of the main protagonist who gradually reveals the lives of all the party's to to the main plot. There is a love story too, isn't there; a gentle one insinuating itself into the story and still unfolding and that will hopefully be consummated some time in the not too distant future.
This was an excellent mystery, not a thriller, it didn't have to be to keep me enthralled, and was intelligently thought through right from the very beginning until the very end. Cannot recommend it more highly, knowing you will enjoy it as much as I did. Let's hope that this becomes the brilliant first in a new series by the esteemed author JK Rowlings aka Robert Galbraith.
It was too easy to figure out who the killer was.
I could see a follow up book based on the detective and his assistant solving various crimes.
I'm a professional painter and love ennobling, enlightening literature
it's a good read. if you're looking for profound truths, this is not it. if you're looking for characters and a story involving celebrity type characters, it's engaging and I expect the two main characters will show up in another book. the stage is set for a detective series.
the main characters
this is J.K. Rowling's book; of course one can't escape reading without having read one Harry Potter book. I love her imagination and it doesn't fail her here in terms of plotting and building a friendship between characters.
beauty and the beast collide
some of the characters were painted with one broad brush; I would have appreciated greater nuance. No one is all good or all bad.
There seemed like such a drawn out build up...the end somewhat fizzled.
I'd recommend it-it was fun to read. I love how the characters are so artfully crafted.
I loved every scene where Cormoran is depicted as disheveled, a wreck, hungover. One can't help but love him.
-it just wouldn't be quite right