I purchased this book because it was first in the series. Am listening to the end to get the background, but the narration is distracting because of the reader's odd intonations. Sometimes it's quite good, and sometimes it is very sing-song. I did enjoy the mystery story, but, because of the narrative stylings, had to struggle / focus to not lose the threads.
Gripping Crime Drama
The crimes were never really solved till everything comes together. Then it all made perfect sense
Mr. Lee is my favorite narrator. He reads with restrained passion. He also speaks Austrailian superbly
I'd just finished "In a Sunburnt Country" by Bill Bryson. His travels thru the land down under. The Bat takes place in Austrailia so I got to stay in character for this book or in country you might say
Say something about yourself!
Jo Nesbo's first Harry Hole novel is great example of modern detective fiction. While it doesn't really break the mold of alcoholic damaged detective goes through the seedy underbelly of (insert city here), it still grips the listener and makes you actually feel for the characters. I won't say that you'll fall in love with them, but Harry's interactions with them seems organic and keeps the suspension of disbelief alive throughout the book. Some of the plot points seem to have poor explanation, like one didn't get the whole story behind them before Nesbo put them to page, but that might just be me. Overall, a good start to a series and I look forward to more adventures and mysteries with this series.
(SPOILER WARNING) The description of Baurguetta's (sp?) murder inspired true dread, and the thoughts in Harry's mind as they drag the waters was beautifully done. A true verbal still life picture into a scene a dread, misery, and loss of something that felt like it was never truly there.
John Lee did an exceptional job. His Australian accent seemed quite authentic to me. I will say however that two characters did sound almost exactly alike, but this issue rarely rears his head in the reading.
No, unfortunately. However, that just may be my personality. Always moving, always listening.
I'm glad that "The Bat" was not the first of this series I've read, or it would have been the last. In general I have enjoyed the Harry Hole series by Jo Nesbo, but this one, for me, was laborious to listen to. The characters lacked the form and depth the other novels have, and again, another deep love affair begins and ends in a week.
The narrator was Ok, but nothing special. Some voices were well done and others not as well done. Over all it was a good try but no banana.
An abridged version of this would have worked better for me. Rambled on too much.
No, I have enjoyed his other books so far, this just did not hold the same interest for me.
The problem is I prefer someone like Robin Sachs and this guy is no where near that.
Quite a bit of the sex, drinking. Also for me there were too many side stories that were, I guess, fables of Australia.
I struggled to finish this. I couldn't wait for it to be over. That is not usually the case with his books.
I'm new to Audio-books and already hooked.
But how could you not like a book featuring Harry Hole? Narrator was good, but creeped me out in his Swedish woman voice.
After listening to several books in the Harry Hole series, out of sequence (this book was only recently made avaialble), it was enjoyable to learn some of the back stories alluded to in later books. Anyone just "discovering" Jo Nesbo and Harry Hole will do themselves a great service by starting with book 1.
I've never been to Australia; but have several good friends who leve there; and John Lee "nailed" the accents as far as I can tell. Most enjoyable was the final chapter. Some may say "predictable"; but it's a helluva finish.
We get to meet Harry almost on holiday at first; but he soon demonstrates why he was sent to OZ to solve the case.. We also get to see a rather unflattering, yet understandable side of Harry that needed to be told.
To dedicate the narration to Robin Sachs was a thoughtful gesture. He adds (IMHO) authentic Aussie accents and allows you to get into the story very fast.
John Lee is a personal favorite and his narration led me to Harry Hole. The Scandanavian main character will naturally put one in mind of Stieg Larssen and I thoroughly enjoyed this book as I did those. I found The Bat less dark though and refreshingly non-formulaic as many police procedurals can be. Harry is another flawed detective that is very easy to like. The characters and plot are well-developed. I am writing this when I am nearly done book 2, Redbreast, and I very pleased to have found the series. Great job Mr. Nesbo!
I love reading and I love Audible. Their fantasy and Sci-Fi selection is excellent!
Overall I thought the story was pretty good, though not my favorite in the Harry Hole series. John Lee does a good job reading but something about the way he goes low at the end of sentences annoyed me. It is not as bad sped up a bit, but it really made me miss Robin Sachs who was just perfect.
author came highly recommended but book felt as if sprung from an outline--overly plotted with characters who fail to come alive...reader's Australian accent grating and not suited to the detective from Norway--I really thought the Aborigine fairytales a form of padding rather than anything integral to the story.