I've been a fan of David Sedaris since the late 90s and I love Barrel Fever, Holidays on Ice, Naked, and Me Talk Pretty One Day. I loved his outrageous humor and his eye for the grotesque and absurd. After that book I thought he started moving into more somber, earnest territory, and also started repeating himself. The only essays in this book that seem funny are the live readings where you hear audience laughter punctuating his remarks.
For a fan, this book was really repetitive. He's studying languages, reminiscing about his dad (who now sounds downright abusive rather than ridiculous), talking about Paris, making fun of homophobes, telling stories about book tours, etc etc.
Slowed down and subdued. It's been strange to hear his reading voice has gotten slower and calmer with each new audiobook.
It's disappointing -- I loved his manic, unmistakable voice in the earlier books. How did he describe it? "With its girlish timbre and high, excitable pitch". Voices do get deeper with age, but it sounds like he's working to "sound less gay". Sounds like the speech therapy he made fun of in "Go Carolina" has finally worked :-(
Not unless he finds some new things to write about.
Other reviewers complain that it's not as fresh as his older works, but its good moments are great. The dog poetry would do Ogden Nash proud. Even the production credits at the end had me laughing out loud.
"... there are times when silence is a poem." - John Fowles, the Magus ^(;,;)^
While I enjoyed this collection more than Sedaris' previous book 'Squirrel Seeks Chipmunk', it just didn't rise to the levels of his great collections ('Naked' or 'Me Talk Pretty Someday'), or even his very good collections ('When You Are Engulfed in Flames' or 'Dress Your Family in Corduroy and Denim'). I just feel like he is retreading the same ground, picking up the same litter, and is starting that phase in his career where he is like a band from the 80s that isn't creating as much as exploiting his better work.
I hope I am being overly pessimistic, and maybe I am just jaded from the horrible audio experience my wife and I had last night listening to him at Gammage Auditorium in Tempe, AZ, but it seems that the reading typified my feelings about his book. Sedaris was reading to a comfortable group in comfortable shoes, reading comfortable stories. We all laughed at the appropriate parts, we all knew what we expected and David Sedaris delivered the goods -- mostly.
The audio quality wasn't great, but I walked away mostly amused that I somehow ended up parting with 1 credit at Audible, $15 bucks on Amazon, $45 for a live reading, and while mildly entertained ... I wasn't particularly blown away. It was like I was a beer-bellied, middle-aged man at a Journey concert. I figure I didn't pay for the new set, just for the couple hours of nostalgia at how great it was ten or twenty years ago. Now, I've just got to figure out now how much nostalgia will cost me tomorrow.
If you like David Sedaris, you won't be disappointed by his latest work. Quirky, funny, and self-effacing as always, Sedaris is more focused on the world around him than he is focused on himself or his family. There is still some of his trademark self-absorption and family analysis, but he seems to be slowly sorting out all of his self-loathing and lingering family resentment, and he now has energy and attention to devote to other topics. Interestingly, in terms of family analysis, he has turned his attention on his father and away from his mother.
Fans of David Sedaris rejoice--this is his best collection of essays since "Me Talk Pretty One Day"--at least in the humble opinion of this reviewer. Sedaris is in top form here on topics ranging from airline travel to the pitfalls of foreign language instruction (Japanese, German, Chinese) to the casual everyday cruelty of children--and of adults, for that matter. The tone is in turn poignant and sarcastic, and always unflinchingly honest.
Sedaris' humor has an edge to it and he doesn't spare himself from its blade, but he unfailingly finds the comedy in his experiences and invites us to do the same. His turn of phrase manages to state truths while at the same time being very funny--one example I can't get out of my head is his observation that Americans see Australians as "Canadians in a thong."
While one or two of the essays had a familiar ring to them (perhaps from a version appearing on an episode of This American Life?), the material is almost all new as far as I can tell.
Sedaris' deadpan delivery style greatly enhances the listening experience--this is certainly an instance where the audio surpasses the print version. Highly recommended!
It is what it is.
David Sedaris is brilliant. His outlook on everyday life is hilarious. I am sad that I missed his lecture in my city last year.
While the first few family stories made me cringe, I enjoyed David's writing style. This compilation of short essays made we want to crack my diary open again.
Yes, this audiobook included light music between the numbers and it was a nice break from the story for a moment. Also, some of these essays are recorded live, so you get to hear reactions from the crowd, which you wouldn't get in print.
David Sedaris of course! I've read most of his other books and love them, but this was the first audiobook I have done where he is the author. I also loved hearing stories about his dad, just because they were so outrageous and funny.
He does voices for his family and people in his stories, they were all great.
I really liked hearing about his upbringing, and travels in his early 20's.
I think that this is a superb audiobook. Sometimes David sounds a little funny, but it helps the story have a little more character! I'd like to hear another narrator give some of these a shot - I performed a piece in college for a Communication Performance act. I'll likely give another of his a try.
I bought this book on a whim. I'm not at all familiar with the author, but the title caught my eye. Before I bought the book I read the review and I also read the reviews of the other books that the author has written. So I took a chance, I bought the audio book. As a first time listener to this author I really wasn't sure what to make of it. Reading reviews, I expected to laugh out loud and have a grand old time with each essay. Now, I would be lying if I said that I didn't get a few chuckles. I especially enjoyed the bit about the dentist's office, and also the bit about the colonoscopy. Other than that, each story was just one mundane glimpse into the author's life after another. Maybe I didn't pick the right book to start with with this author, I don't know. I'm willing to give it another chance with another book but just not at this time. I'm not really sure what all the fuss is about with this author. Honestly the book was not all that interesting and most of his stories seem to be fairly pointless and not very exciting. Again I'll try to be fair and give the book 3 stars. Maybe he has some better works but as for this particular book, I don't know that I would really recommend it to anybody.